In which Dave
White, tireless recapper, fact-finder, and opinion maker of
all things Idol, is heard to say, “Oh, shit.
American Idol is back.”
My
husband/partner/whatever says, “How can it be a new
season of this show already? I thought it was still on
from last time.”
“You’re a bad payer of attention,” I
say. “The excitement is back and more electric
than ever.”
Then he expresses
a litany of American Idol–related
concerns that have been troubling him lately. Like, has
it passed its sell-by date? Didn't three former winners just
get dropped from their record labels? And what of that
Idol-adjacent “next big rock band”
show? How’s season 4 finalist Jessica Sierra
doing on Celebrity Rehab With Dr. Drew? And are the
new Dreyer’s ice cream flavors available?
I answer him
calmly:
1. Yes.
2. Two former
winners, Ruben and The Boogie, have been dropped. The
Boogie doesn’t seem to care. And Ruben’s
family is keeping the news from him. Meanwhile, McPhee
was not a winner, she was the runner-up. But yeah, she
just got canned too.
3. We
didn’t watch the next-big-band show, as didn’t
most of America. It happened, but it was inside a big
soundless vacuum. One of those bands was composed
entirely of the now-grown kids from American Juniors
and no one even noticed.
4. Jessica seems
to be doing well on the rivetingly distasteful Celebrity
Rehab, alongside that girl from the Urkel show who
did some lez-porn and now seems to think she’s
addicted to weed. They gave her a spot on that
show instead of Brad Renfro? On their heads be it.
5. Yes, the new
flavors are here. They are "Color Purple Grape,”
“Daughtry’s Snarly Bits of Choco Bunches of
Oat Clusters and Nuts,” “Taylor Hicks's
Smoker’s Cough Crunch” (already recalled from
stores), and “Clive Davis’s Foot in Your
Ass, Kelly Clarkson,” which reportedly tastes
like Clive Davis's ass-covered foot.
Now, some people
aren't fond of the first act of each American Idol
season. The long weeks of auditions strike more
sensitive viewers as needlessly cruel. But
clear-thinking people know they’re a public service.
They make it easier for families and friends of
talentless loons to finally broach the long-festering
topic of how their loved ones' singing sucks dead donkey
dicks. In fact, it takes the burden away entirely and
creates an environment where those hurtful words never
need be spoken by anyone close to the
“singer.” You get a wealthy British guy with
bad hair to do it for you for free, and on national
TV, where it will really sting the most. Some people
need hard lessons. They just do.
So for this first
week they're in Philadelphia and Dallas. The camera
zooms around giant stadiums filled with people who think
it’s their turn for the universe to bestow on
them happiness-giving fame. They come from everywhere
and do all manner of things for a living. One young woman is
an Air Force pilot; one guy makes cotton candy for a living
and has the teeth to prove it. Someone else makes
balloon animals. I think the cotton
candy–making job sounds like it might be kind of fun.
Unless you had to clean the machine. I would only want
to do it if I could have a machine-cleaning assistant
and I just got to be the guy who did the swirly part
all day. One girl in Dallas gives birth while waiting for
her chance to audition. She names it
“Idol” and considers this “only
appropriate.” Then we see a funny montage of people
going, “Ahhhhhhhhh!” like they’re
doing that exquisite corpse thing, but with a long note in a
string of different keys. The effect is that of a huge line
of people about to have a giant orgasm.
And that’s
just the first two minutes. Then Seacrest says,
“This………………….
is A-MER-ican Idol,” the way he’s honed
to a reflex over years of at-home practice instead of
using that time to form meaningful human
relationships. And the games begin for the seventh time.
The theme music plays, affording Cathy Dennis another
Hermès shopping spree.
[A pause in
writing while I go to YouTube to watch old D-Mob videos
featuring Cathy Dennis.]
Click here to follow The Advocate on Twitter.
Page 1 of 3
Dave White is the author of Exile in Guyville
and is mildly embarrassed that today he willingly
listened to Ace of Base’s “The
Sign.” But only mildly. Find more of him at
www.imdavewhite.com.