N.Y. Marriage Lost ... For Now
The New York state senate on Wednesday voted down a marriage equality bill by a wide margin following months of delay and protracted political drama.
In a special legislative session, the senate voted 38-to-24 against the bill, eight votes short of a majority, with no support from Republican senators. A state assembly marriage bill had passed for a third time late last night.
Governor David Paterson, who made marriage equality a centerpiece of his agenda, issued a statement a few hours after the vote that acknowledged the widespread sense of disappointment among advocates for the bill.
“I believe in my heart that if people had voted their consciences today, we would be celebrating marriage equality tonight,” said Paterson. “That did not happen.”
The governor quickly sought to turn the discussion toward the future.
“As disappointed as we are today, let’s get up tomorrow and redouble our efforts,” said Paterson. “We are going to lay the foundation to make people feel comfortable to vote their conscience and not fear political backlash.”
The vote followed an emotional three-hour debate that included tears from the legislation’s lead sponsor, Senator Thomas K. Duane, who is gay, and tirade from Senator Ruben Diaz, Sr, a Pentecostal minister and Bronx Democrat Senator who called the bill "treason," and argued that marriage equality should be decided in a public referendum.
Speaking to reporters following the vote, Senator Duane said: "I wasn't expected to be betrayed, and so I have some justified anger. But it's just going to propel me to — I don't want to say redouble my efforts, because my efforts have been pretty strong — but I'm not going to let up."
New York City Council Speaker Christine Quinn, who is openly lesbian and lobbied intensely for the bill, echoed Duane's anger.
"I am mad," said Quinn, in a telephone interview late Wednesday afternoon as she returned from Albany. "There were people who had made promises and that's not where they ended up."
Still, the speaker said she was not caught off guard by the vote outcome.
"I knew when I went up to the gallery to watch the debate that we were likely to lose," said Quinn.
Win or lose, Empire State Pride Agenda, the state’s leading LGBT lobby, framed the result as a long-awaited opportunity to learn where legislators stand on
the marriage equality issue.
"While we are disappointed by
today’s vote, we are pleased that the issue of marriage equality at
last was debated in the New York State Senate,” said executive director
Alan Van Capelle in a statement issued shortly after the vote. “We had
long called for a public debate on this matter so we could determine
who was truly on our side.
“It is a step forward for our
democratic process in New York that a debate and vote have now
occurred,” said Van Capelle. “Now we know where we stand, and where we
need to concentrate our efforts in the future.”
No Republican legislator voted for the bill, despite being freed by their minority leader, Senator Dean Skelos of Long Island, to vote their consciences.
The Log Cabin Republicans of New York issued a statement seeking to situate the outcome squarely on the shoulders of Democrats, however.
Follow us on Twitter.
Follow us on Facebook.
Page 1 of 3