Sex and Fantasy From Best-Selling Authors Jacqueline Carey and Larissa Ione
BY Diane Anderson-Minshall
June 27 2012 5:00 AM ET
What happens when you simultaneously interview two New York Times best-selling authors, one of fantasy fiction and the other of paranormal romance? A scintillating conversation between Larissa Ione, whose latest book is Lethal Rider, the third entry in the riveting Lords of Deliverance series, and Jacqueline Carey, the author of the best-selling Kushiel’s Legacy series of historical fantasy novels, the Sundering epic fantasy duology, and the postmodern fables Santa Olivia and her latest, Saints Astray. Carey lives in western Michigan, while Ione, a former meteorologist and EMT worker as well as an Air Force veteran, lives in Wisconsin.
The Advocate: How did you enter your genres? How did you begin in fantasy and paranormal romance, respectively?
Carey: I have always loved fantasy; I think probably stepping through the wardrobe with Lucy in C.S. Lewis’s Narnia Chronicles was my first exposure when I was really little. But how I actually began writing is a story that teachers love. I started in high school when I was really bored in a class, which had to do with overlapping curriculum; it was not the teacher’s fault. I started a novel in the back of a notebook, and it was great because it looked like I was taking notes. And I just, I kept it up, it was sort of fantasy, it was part soap opera. It was utterly dreadful, but that’s how I got hooked.
Ione: I started because when I was old enough to start choosing what I wanted to read I chose horror. And my favorite creatures were always vampires. So when I first started writing as a teenager, just kind of doodling, most of my stories were paranormal. And so when I started reading romance there wasn’t a whole lot of paranormal romance at the time. So the romance I was reading was mainly romantic suspense, and when I started trying to get published I was writing contemporary romance, usually with a medical slant because I’ve always been interested in medicine. And one day I was watching an episode of Angel, which was a Buffy the Vampire Slayer spin-off, and Angel was injured really badly and he needed a hospital but he couldn’t go because he was a vampire. And it all clicked right then that I could blend the two: I could get back to the paranormal roots I loved while still writing the kind of contemporary medical stuff. So my Underworld General series was born and that’s how it started.
Because of the sometimes risqué or socially unconventional themes introduced in your works (same-sex love, explicit romance), what does “fringe” mean to each of you?
Carey: This is an interesting question, and I can’t really come up with a satisfactory definition in my mind. I don’t really consider my work on the whole “fringe” in my own mind; science fiction and fantasy have been pretty solidly in the mainstream for a while. But the Kushiel series in particular, because of more than anything I would say the BDSM elements, had a sort of stealthy, under-the-radar fringe element to it within something that came out as very much a mainstream publication.
Ione: I’m with you on that — I can’t really come up with a definition of “fringe.” Back when I first started, my first stories were erotic, especially my Sydney Croft series, which I write with New York Times best-selling author Stephanie Tyler. Those kind of push some boundaries, and it was probably considered more fringe back then. Now erotic romance has become so popular I don’t see it as being really on the fringe. Gay romance is really booming too, so I don’t think it’s as fringey as it used to be. It’s really become more mainstream. For example, when we first started writing the Sydney Croft series, we made the head of our organization in the series bisexual, and our editor kind of gave us a “Do you really want to do this?” kind of thing. And admittedly, we got some backlash from readers from that first book back in 2007 when it came out, but the majority of readers loved him and by the end of the series he became one of the most popular characters. So I think things that were kind of fringey when we started are less so now.
Carey: I agree. I think it begs the question of what is “fringe.”
What are the differences or similarities between writing gay and straight love scenes?
Carey: I would have to say in my experience there isn’t really a difference other than the plumbing, as it were. For me, making a scene erotic has to do with really connecting with the emotional and psychological place the characters are coming from. Obviously the technical details are important too, but that’s where the real charge comes from. And I’ve had a lot of readers tell me, “You know, I went back and reread your Kushiel’s Dart, and a lot of the scenes I thought were incredibly graphic weren’t actually as graphic as I thought.” I’m trying to get the reader to do the work in their own imagination. But the one thing I have not written is a really graphic, erotic male-male sex scene. And I think in part that’s because my one male protagonist stayed kind of stubbornly heterosexual and I didn’t want to shoehorn that in there just for the sake of doing it. But I think that when we talk about writing sex scenes, that’s one of the most intimate human experiences. And a male-male sex scene is one where I don’t have anything to bring to the table in terms of that experience other than friends who insist on telling me about their prostates and things. But I don’t have the visceral experience of that. At least in a heterosexual love scene, you know, I’ve been half of that.
Do you think that if you were to write a man-on-man love scene, the emotional charge you spoke of would play the same kind of role as between two women?
Carey: Oh, absolutely. And I did write a male-male romance in a novella, but I didn’t get as graphic and detailed as I have in the longer works. But definitely the emotion and psychology is always where it’s going to be at for me, for the real charge.
Ione: I agree with that. I think that there’s often a difference in the scenes depending on if you’re writing for a gay audience versus a straight one that’s reading it just because they want to read an erotic romance. Like, I’ve never written two women together, but I’ve written men. And for me, the way they have sex in the books I’ve written has been a little rougher even when it’s tender, because in my case these are two alphas going at it, two guys who don’t want to let down those walls and who were probably raised to hide their emotions. So the love scenes tend to be rougher, a little more about the physical than the emotional, at least until the relationship breaks down those walls. Emotion is what you’re going for, but they tend to be a little more hidden behind the physical for a while.
- The Top 175 Essential Films of All Time for LGBT Viewers
- #TBT: They Died in the Closet
- Even the Rehearsal Footage From Madonna's Rebel Heart Tour Is Spellbinding
- Hundreds Attend Satanic Statue Unveiling in Detroit Despite Terrorist Threats
- These Are the U.S. Trans Women Killed in 2015
- Franklin Graham: Obama Promoting 'Immorality' by Supporting LGBT Rights in Kenya