The duo, starring on Broadway together, took a photo outside Stonewall Inn
Richard Caswell, a.k.a. Vito Gallo, was thrown in jail after he barged into Michael Lucas's studio last month
He was chided by Jon Stewart on The Daily Show for enjoying his 'first' a little too much
The celebrity dads are getting into the Halloween spirit early as Tweedledum and Tweedledee.
Plus: Chelsea Handlers says she's not transgender