Montana judge upholds benefit ban for same-sex partners
BY Advocate.com Editors
November 28 2002 1:00 AM ET
A Montana university system policy denying health insurance benefits to partners of gay employees is not unconstitutional, a district judge ruled Tuesday.
In throwing out a lawsuit brought by two lesbian couples against the University of Montana, Judge Thomas Honzel said the policy is based on the marital status of employees, not on their sexual orientation, and that it is a "reasonable and objective standard" for determining who qualifies for employment benefits.
Honzel's decision addressed claims by Carol Snetsinger and her partner, Nancy Siegel, and Carla Grayson and her partner, Adrienne Neff. Snetsinger and Grayson, who are employed by the University of Montana, sued the university system and charged that it was unfairly denying their domestic partners health insurance offered through the university.
UM offers health insurance only to employees, their spouses, and their children. Heterosexual couples who are not married but file an affidavit of common-law marriage, can also qualify. Because same-sex couples are barred by law from marrying, however, they cannot obtain health insurance for their partners through the university system.
In his ruling Honzel said that because marital status is a legally permissible means of classifying people for employment benefits, the policy doesn't violate the constitutional rights of university system employees. Marriage is a legal bond distinguishable from other relationships, Honzel said. "Although the named plaintiffs have committed relationships with their respective partners, they are not subject to the legal responsibilities and obligations which are imposed on married persons," he added.
- Op-ed: What People Don't Get About Dismay Over Jared Leto
- The Striking Muxe: Mexico's Third Gender
- Op-ed: In Boston, an Ugly St. Patrick's Day Tradition Continues
- Anne Rice Announces New Vampire Chronicles Novel
- Trans Woman Sues CrossFit After Being Told to Compete in Men's Division
- WATCH: Gay Man's Grandfather Came Out to Him at 90 Years Old
- Arts & Entertainment Opera Director Gerard Mortier Dies at 70 6 min 27 sec ago
- Television MTV's Awkward Adds 2 New Gay Characters 26 min 57 sec ago
- Print Issue The Striking Muxe: Mexico's Third Gender 6:01 AM
- Current Issue Editor’s Letter: April/May Issue 5:01 AM
- Parenting Is Mr. Peabody & Sherman About Adoption by Gays? 4:00 AM
- Media Former Fox Sportscaster Claims Anti-Antigay Discrimination March 10 2014 9:37 PM
- Women Lorde Takes Down Idiot DJ Who Implies She and Taylor Swift Are Lesbians March 10 2014 9:01 PM