Mass. law preventing out-of-state couples from marrying challenged
April 24 2004 12:00 AM ET
The battle over gay marriage in Massachusetts continued Friday, as state lawmakers attempt to undo a 1913 law that forbids out-of-state couples to marry in Massachusetts if their union would be considered illegal in their home state, according to The Boston Globe. Rep. Robert P. Spellane is set to file the bill that would reverse the contentious law before legalized gay marriages begin on May 17.
Gov. Mitt Romney has informed his administration to instruct city and town clerks to uphold "the law as it exists on May 17," the newspaper reported, and Thursday he referenced the out-of-state question at a meeting of the Governor's Council.
"It's going to be a lot of work for the clerks," said Romney, whose legal staff is compiling a catalog of guidelines for the clerks to follow, including a list of court rulings on gay marriage by state. He told the newspaper that clerks will instruct couples to "read it and tell us if you're eligible under your state's law." The proposed bill would eliminate this practice by striking two sections from the state's marriage statute that outline how to deal with out-of-staters.
In the past, clerks have allowed the couples to determine whether their marriage would be legal in their home state and have requested the couples to sign sworn affidavits as verification.
Spellane, a Democrat, hopes to sidestep this tedious process, saying the 1913 law violates the state supreme court's November ruling that it was unconstitutional to bar same-sex couples from marriage.
"There's no doubt it's a discriminatory law," he told the Globe. "People are using it to their advantage. [But] there is no confusion about it in relation to the ruling in November, and it's incumbent on us to remove it." House speaker Thomas M. Finneran, who controls the fate of most legislation in the chamber, has yet to review the bill, the newspaper reported. A spokesman for Finneran declined comment Thursday.
Justice John M. Greaney, one of the four supreme court justices who formed the majority in the gay marriage ruling, suggested in a footnote that out-of-staters will not be able to get married in Massachusetts. "The argument, made by some in the case, that legalization of same-sex marriage in Massachusetts will be used by persons in other states as a tool to obtain recognition of a marriage in their state that is otherwise unlawful is precluded," he wrote.
- Timothy Dolan Uncomfortable as Pope Calls for Study of Civil Unions
- WATCH: One Gay Man's Touching Plea for Equality in Utah
- Low-Income Apartment Complex for LGBT Seniors Opens in Philadelphia
- Op-ed: A Second Look at Bisexuality
- Gay-Helmed Sci-Fi Film Space Station 76 Debuts at SXSW
- Op-ed: It's Time To End 'Swiss Cheese' Equality
- Politics WATCH: One Gay Man's Touching Plea for Equality in Utah 1 hour 6 min ago
- Religion Uncomfortable: Timothy Dolan Versus Pope on Civil Unions 1 hour 10 min ago
- Politics WATCH: Low-Income Apartments for LGBT Seniors Open 2 hours 26 min ago
- Comedy Johnny and Tara at 30 Rock, Can't Stop With Play-By-Play 1:00 PM
- Comedy 8 Movies Made Better With 'Let It Go' 11:50 AM
- Film Gay-Helmed Sci-Fi Film Space Station 76 Debuts at SXSW March 08 2014 8:15 PM
- Religion Archbishop Dolan to NFL Hopeful Michael Sam: 'Bravo' UPDATED: March 08 2014 6:04 PM