AfterElton.com has named Neil Patrick Harris its Gay Man of the Decade, and Jimmy Kimmel had him on his show, in part to celebrate the honor.

Harris ran down the list of other potential winners, including Adam Lambert (“Didn’t we just meet him, like, eight months ago?” Kimmel asked), Ian McKellen (“Well-deserving,” Harris added) and Torchwood’s John Barrowman, whom Harris says he beat by just 20 points.

Watch the Kimmel video here.