New Yorkers Protest Smithsonian Censorship
BY Julie Bolcer
December 20 2010 8:45 AM ET
An estimated 500 protesters walked a stretch of the Museum Mile in
Manhattan on Sunday to demand that the Smithsonian restore the David
Wojnarowicz video A Fire in My Belly to an exhibition on same-sex
desire in Washington, D.C.
The protesters, some wearing masks of the late artist, gathered outside the Metropolitan Museum of Art on Fifth Avenue in the chilly afternoon air and walked north about 10 blocks along the periphery of Central Park to the Cooper-Hewitt, National Design Museum, an outpost of the Smithsonian in New York City. During their journey, the block-line line of demonstrators passed the Guggenheim, streams of holiday tourists and locals walking dogs as they chanted, “Put the video back!” and “Show us your morals!”
Organizers said the protest, the largest in years in the city to coalesce around an art exhibition, aimed to send a message from the heart of the art world. A protest took place in Washington, D.C. about two weeks ago, and countless others, including the Andy Warhol Foundation, op-ed columnists and bloggers, have decried the act of censorship.
“This is to send a very loud and clear message to the Smithsonian: Put the piece back now,” said Bill Dobbs of the direct action group Art+, which started to organize the protest about 10 days ago. “The yanking of the video sends a very chilling message, and it raises the larger issue of how cultural institutions deal with sexual minority people and culture.”
Art+ ("art positive") continues the work of the original group of the same name, an ACT UP offshoot forged in the incendiary culture wars of the 1980s and 90s. Back then, the group organized around issues including Republican-led attempts to defund the National Endowment for the Arts. Dobbs and co-organizer Hunter Reynolds knew Wojnarowicz, whose art sparked controversy in his own time before his death from AIDS in 1992.
“He was enormously sweet,” said Dobbs. “And he spoke with the clarity of a sledgehammer.”
Last month, under pressure from the Catholic League and some congressional Republicans, the Smithsonian removed the Wojnarowicz video, which deals with the suffering of HIV/AIDS, from "Hide/Seek: Difference and Desire in American Portraiture," a widely hailed exhibition at the National Portrait Gallery. Critics objected to a 10-second scene in which ants crawl across a crucifix, calling it an instance of “hate speech” against Catholics.
The Sunday crowd, which contained many artists, sought to illustrate the hypocrisy of the charges during the hour-long peaceful protest, which concluded outside Cooper-Hewitt on 91st Street.
“I am a devoted follower of Jesus,” said Rick Shur, a self-described “esoteric Christian” also known as Rick X. “He has been kidnapped and monopolized by a group of people who believe they represent Jesus and we don’t.”
- WATCH: What Happens When a Gay Boy Scout Comes Out to His Camp Leader
- Canada Lifts Lifetime Ban on Blood Donations by Gay Men
- We Love Liberace Now Even More Than 30 Years Ago
- PHOTOS: Real Weddings, Real People
- Op-ed: Are We More Successful Because We’re Gay?
- Peace Corps Recognizes, Respects Same-Sex Couples
Sign Up For Email Updates
- Music WATCH: Adam Levine Gets a Shirtless Paint Job 11 min 49 sec ago
- Books Three Great Books About HIV 13 min 42 sec ago
- Women WATCH: Amy Schumer Uses Tig Notaro's Cancer for Her Own Personal Gain 31 min 49 sec ago
- Crime Editor of Gay Website Beaten in London 34 min 9 sec ago
- Film We Steal Secrets: Is Bradley Manning a Hero? 36 min 28 sec ago
- Film A Drinking Game for the Liberace Movie 36 min 55 sec ago
- Health News Canada Lifts Lifetime Ban on Blood Donations by Gay Men 1 hour 46 min ago