By Kerry Eleveld
Originally published on Advocate.com July 15 2010 4:55 PM ET
Key House lawmakers convened a press conference Thursday on Capitol Hill in conjunction with an array of 37 advocacy groups to voice their support for including LGBT families in the comprehensive immigration reform effort.
“No immigration reform measure will truly be deserving of the term ‘comprehensive’ unless it provides equality for gays and lesbians as well,” said Rep. Jerrold Nadler of New York, chief sponsor of the Uniting American Families Act, which would allow American citizens and green-card holders to sponsor their same-sex partners for residency.
The event came just one day after the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration held a hearing on reform as key lawmakers in the House make an effort to jump-start the issue again before the close of the 111th Congress.
Nadler was joined by out representative Jared Polis of Colorado; Rep. Mike Honda of California, chief sponsor of the LGBT-inclusive Reuniting Families Act; and Rep. Luis Gutierrez of Illinois, a lead member of the Hispanic caucus who introduced a comprehensive immigration bill last December that did not include LGBT families.
But Gutierrez has since voiced his support for adding same-sex partners into the immigration package over the objections of certain groups, such as the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.
“I have been trying to highlight the theme that the underlying part of any comprehensive immigration bill is family unity,” Gutierrez said, “and I’m here today because I think we need to speak out more clearly, more articulately, and more frequently that the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender community and same-sex couples and their binational relationships are part of those families.”
Gutierrez added that he was “confident” Congress could pass an immigration bill “that would include the provisions of UAFA this year.”
The press conference and the lawmakers’ insistence on LGBT inclusion represents a shift in the immigration landscape away from a deference to social conservative groups who have fought to exclude same-sex couples from the greater immigration effort.
Nadler addressed one of the main objections of conservative groups head-on during Thursday’s press conference. While some detractors of UAFA have suggested that allowing LGBT people to sponsor their partners is related to the marriage debate, Nadler rejected the assertion emphatically.
“It is simply a question of whether the law should [perpetuate] gratuitous cruelty,” he said. “Keeping couples apart is simply gratuitous, purposeless cruelty on the part of our government. Government should never ever engage in purposeless gratuitous cruelty.”
Edwin Blesch and his South African partner, Tim, know that cruelty all too well. The couple, who met 11 years ago in Cape Town and were since married there, has been commuting from South Africa to New York and, more recently, to Quebec, Canada, over the course of their entire relationship in order to comply with the requirements of Tim’s travel visa.
While it may sound cosmopolitan to some, Blesch said he would much prefer to sponsor his husband for residency in the United States and be more settled.
“We want to be in one place,” he said, "with a cat and a dog and lead a life in the country with a garden."
in travel and relocation expenses, but even more pressing for them are
some recent health problems that Blesch is experiencing. At 70, he has
been HIV-positive for 25 years and has developed complications
with his medications, among other issues.
Tim, who asked not to
be identified by his last name, said he recently found Blesch
unconscious in their apartment after he had undergone surgery the week
“I thought he was dead,” said Tim, 64, who will soon
have to travel back to South Africa alone and worries for Blesch’s
“It’s a constant worry; I can’t explain that to
anybody,” he said. “It’s every day.”
Steve Ralls, a spokesman
for the pro-LGBT group Immigration Equality, said that as members have traveled around the
country and spoken to the people who are actually affected by this
issue, they have heard “resounding support” for an LGBT-inclusive bill.
“The voices of countless constituents and immigrant families
have now drowned out the dwindling voices of opposition on this issue,”
But the motivation on Capitol Hill may be as much due
to political calculus as constituency support. Despite a recent call by President Barack Obama for congress to take up immigration reform this
year, a comprehensive bill has yet to be introduced in the Senate, and Rep. Gutierrez has acknowledged in the past couple weeks that his bill
does not have the 217 votes needed to pass the House.
although House leadership had been insisting that the Senate move first
on an immigration measure, key lawmakers in the House have made an
effort in past weeks to jump-start the issue again.
government’s lawsuit against the Arizona law and the debate the Arizona
law has sparked across the country has presented an opportunity for Congress to take up the issue in a serous way again,” Ralls said.
“There’s a short window of opportunity between now and the end of this Congress to do that.”
AIDS Action Council
Asian American Justice Center
CenterLink: The Community
of LGBT Centers
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles
The Council for Global Equality
The Episcopal Church
Family Equality Council
Committee on National Legislation
Gay & Lesbian Advocates &
Gay, Lesbian, and Straight Education Network
Mefford, Director of Civil and Human Rights
General Board of Church
and Society, The United Methodist Church
Human Rights Watch
Immigration Equality Action
Labor Council for Latin American Advancement
American Legal Defense & Educational Fund
National Asian Pacific
American Women’s Forum
National Center for Lesbian Rights
Center for Transgender Equality
National Gay and Lesbian Task Force
National Immigrant Justice Center
Institute for Reproductive Health
National Queer Asian Pacific
Out & Equal Workplace Advocates
Families, and Friends of Lesbians and Gays National
the American Way
South Asian Americans Leading Together
Union for Reform Judaism
Universalist Association of Congregations