Prosecutors are
opposing efforts to apply New York's marital
privilege law to same-sex partners, arguing that a man
charged in a school embezzlement scandal can testify
against his companion. Stephen Signorelli, charged in
the theft of $11.2 million from the wealthy Roslyn
school district on Long Island, has asked a judge to prevent
Frank Tassone, his longtime companion and the
district's former superintendent, from testifying
against him. Signorelli is among a half-dozen people
accused of participating in the theft over several years.
Marital privilege
means communications between married people may not be
used in a criminal prosecution. The Nassau County district
attorney's office argued in a response filed Monday
that the request should be denied, since New York
State does not recognize same-sex civil unions or
marriages. That argument "is not intended as a commentary on
what the law ought to be, but rather what it is," the
filing said. Prosecutors also contended that marital
privilege could not be applied to joint participants
in a crime who are trying to hide their activities, The
New York Times reported on Tuesday.
Signorelli, of
Manhattan, is fighting charges that he stole at least
$219,000 from the public school district as part of a
broader series of schemes. Tassone pleaded guilty this
year to stealing at least $2 million from the district
between 1996 and 2002. As part of his plea bargain, he
agreed to testify against other defendants in the case,
which meant he might have to take the stand in
Signorelli's trial. Tassone will spend four to 12
years in prison and will pay back an estimated $2 million.
If convicted at trial, he could have faced up to 25
years.
While Signorelli
said in court papers that the two "have been loving
partners for 33 years," Tassone's lawyer, Edward Jenks, has
described the relationship as a platonic one.
Signorelli's lawyer, Kenneth Weinstein, said the two
were in a "spousal relationship in every sense of the
word." (AP)