Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

‘Some will never come back’: VIDA’s gay owner on the D.C. community that a mass shooting has forever changed

David von Storch tells The Advocate about the employees protecting one another, the loss of James Stuart, and the difficult work of making a familiar place feel safe again.

vida fitness

Outside Vida Fitness in Washington, DC’s Logan Circle neighborhood on August 20, 2024.

Photo by Allison Robbert/The Washington Post via Getty Images

The gay owner of VIDA Fitness hopes to reopen its Logan Circle gym in Washington, D.C., as early as Saturday, following a mass shooting that killed a longtime member and wounded five others. But David von Storch tells The Advocate that restoring a place where people felt safe will take more than repairing the building.

Some members have canceled. Others want to return immediately. And some are still discovering how deeply the shooting affected them.


One trainer told von Storch on Sunday that he had thought he was doing okay. After surviving the shooting, he had gone to his other job at an arena. Then a team scored. A celebratory cannon sounded. He began sweating and froze.

“I’ve heard some firsthand reports of those that are really suffering,” von Storch says. “And that’s been our focus.”

Thursday’s attack killed James Stuart, a gay man known to friends as Jimmy, inside VIDA’s Logan Circle location. Stuart, 46, managed the luxury condominium building above the gym. Five other people were wounded, and the gunman later died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound.

For von Storch, the founder of VIDA and D.C.-based Urban Adventures Companies, the aftermath has brought responsibilities that extend beyond reopening a business. Employees who guided members to shelter are processing their own experiences. People who once organized their days around a workout are deciding whether they can walk through the doors again.

“Some will never come back, and we understand,” he says. “Some we need to help process and give them space.”

Related: Suspect reported dead after shooting at popular gay-owned D.C. gym kills one, wounds four

“My friends and my family, my chosen family”

Von Storch was in Colorado on Thursday morning when his phone began filling with messages. Someone had been shot at his gym. Then he heard that others were wounded. For hours, he says, he struggled to establish where the victims had been and what was happening inside.

Without answers, fear took hold.

“I was very concerned that this was a mass shooting within the club,” he says. “And that really sent me spiraling because what if it was specifically an antigay mass shooting?”

Authorities have pointed to the gunman’s longstanding dispute with the condominium association over maintenance problems in his apartment. Police identified him as emergency medicine doctor Matt Wade Lambert, 55. On Friday, investigators said they believed he had waited inside the gym for nearly an hour before Stuart arrived. Surveillance footage showed him approaching Stuart from behind and shooting him, according to WJLA-TV, the ABC affiliate in Washington.

Before those circumstances became clearer, von Storch was trying to get home on the next available flight while imagining what might be happening to people he knew. He lives a block from the gym.

“I just couldn’t stop thinking about my friends and my family, my chosen family,” he says.

At the rental car return in Aspen, an agent asked where he was headed. When von Storch said Washington, the man mentioned the gym shooting.

“That’s my gym,” von Storch recalls telling him.

As The Advocate previously reported, the attack prompted a large police response and a prolonged standoff above a business with deep ties to Washington’s LGBTQ+ community. VIDA operates four gyms in the District and two in Northern Virginia. Von Storch’s businesses also include salons, spas, and pool clubs.

But the people he was worrying about that morning were more than customers and employees. They were his neighbors.

Related: Mass shooting at popular gay-owned VIDA Fitness in D.C. leaves one dead, suspect barricaded

The people behind the toll

Stuart had belonged to VIDA for 15 years, von Storch told Washington, D.C., NBC affiliate WRC-TV. His employer, EJF Real Estate Services, said he had worked there for 13 years and described him as a beloved colleague.

Police revised the victim count Friday, confirming that five people had been wounded in addition to Stuart’s killing.

Among them was Susan Thurston Hamerski, who had traveled from Minnesota for her daughter’s wedding. After the newlyweds left for their honeymoon, she stayed to care for their dog, Wrigley. She was walking him when she was shot in the face, her daughter, Madeleine Hamerski, writes in a GoFundMe appeal.

Her mother is now in stable condition but faces multiple surgeries and months of rehabilitation, according to the appeal. The couple cut their honeymoon short to be at her side.

Inside VIDA, von Storch says, some members and employees had been within feet of the shooting. Others sheltered in closets, hallways, and whatever refuge they could find, waiting for police to give the all-clear. He later watched surveillance footage that captured both the shooting and the reactions around it, helping him understand the distress people were describing.

He has also heard how employees protected others. Instructors guided members toward shelter. Managers activated the fire alarm under the gym’s emergency protocol. An instructor who was teaching that morning was organizing a gathering for members and employees who had been there.

“We have some folks who’ve stepped up and are doing really extraordinary work to help their colleagues and fellow members both at the time of the shooting and in the aftermath of it,” von Storch says.

Praise for D.C. officials

Von Storch speaks with particular gratitude about the Metropolitan Police Department’s response, describing officers who kept his team informed while managing the emergency.

“The police came over to us during many parts of the day, and they treated us like neighbors,” he says.

He thinks some of that familiarity may come from first responders' proximity to another VIDA location. Von Storch points to fire, rescue, and police facilities across the street from the company’s U Street gym, describing a connection between the people working there and the VIDA community.

“They were so intent on both protecting the process and including us to the extent that they could,” he says. “The amount of information and the timing of the information was really remarkable.”

He also credits the speed, accuracy, and detail of updates from police and the mayor’s office with helping keep rumors and misinformation from taking hold.

A return that cannot be rushed

Water from the building’s sprinkler system flooded VIDA and damaged its ceilings, von Storch says. The gunman had lit a fire in his condo above the gym.

Much of the remediation inside the gym is complete, though the spa will take longer to reopen, he says.

As of Monday, he hopes water service will be restored Friday, allowing the fitness center and salon to reopen Saturday. The schedule remains tentative and depends on building systems and sprinkler testing.

The emotional timetable is less predictable. One trainer told von Storch that returning to work with clients would help him. Others need more time. Von Storch says the company must accommodate those differences without deciding how someone else should recover.

“This is part of their life, and they want to reclaim it,” he says.

Before reopening, von Storch hopes to hold a ceremony honoring Stuart, the surviving wounded, and those neighbors who helped others. The preliminary plan calls for people to form a line extending from VIDA’s entrance down the street as local churches ring their bells. A memorial kettlebell would pass from person to person toward the doors, symbolizing a burden carried together.

Neighbors and nearby businesses would be invited to a reception inside.

Von Storch knows Stuart’s killing will always be part of the location’s history. He says that his focus now is to honor that loss while helping people decide what their relationship with the place can become.

“It is our burden to carry that,” von Storch says, “and to also be strong enough that it doesn’t define us.”

FROM OUR SPONSORS

More For You