World
Is There A Marriage Backlash

By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Private Policy and Terms of Use.
After recent defeats in Maine and New York, poll expert Nate Silver, of the blog FiveThirtyEight, took a look at the numbers to see if they indicate that there's a nationwide backlash against marriage equality.
Silver's conclusion: No. "I don't think there's any evidence of a national backlash against gay marriage," he wrote. "It should be borne in mind that gay marriage is still opposed by a small majority or large plurality of Americans. But there's not really any evidence that the numbers are getting worse; instead, they appear to be v-e-r-y s-l-o-w-ly getting better."
Silver also said that people would be wrong to draw too many comparisons between Maine's Question 1, which repealed marriage equality in that state, and anti-gay-marriage initiatives in other states. "Question 1 was the only gay marriage ballot initiative that did not seek to rewrite its state's constitution," he wrote. "If Question 1 had addressed the same question as Proposition 8 in California, which did alter its state's constitution, it might not have passed."
In an e-mail response to Silver's report, Evan Wolfson, executive director of Freedom to Marry, added that "despite the predictable right-wing spin about the senate's stumble in New York, polls consistently show a majority of New Yorkers support the freedom to marry; the assembly passed the marriage bill three times (twice this year, once the night before the Senate failed); every statewide official (U.S. senators, governor, attorney general, comptroller, etc.) and key mayors are for the freedom to marry; and 24 senators got it right. What we saw this week was no trend or even a New York problem; it was New York senate dysfunction, which will be corrected."
See Nate Silver's full report here.