Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Against North Carolina's Same-Sex Marriage Opt-Out Law (Video)

@ 2026 Equal Entertainment LLC.
All rights reserved

 Judge Dismisses Case Against N.C.'s Same-Sex Marriage Opt-Out Law
  U.S. District Judge Max Cogburn argued the plaintiffs failed to prove they were harmed by the law that allows officials to refuse to perform same-sex marriages if they cite religious objections.
 
 Dawn Ennis 
          
          Sep 22, 2016
          
Dawn Ennis
The Advocate's news editor Dawn Ennis successfully transitioned from broadcast journalism to online media following another transition that made headlines; in 2013, she became the first trans staffer in any major TV network newsroom. As the first out transgender editor at The Advocate, the native New Yorker continues her 30-year media career, in which she has earned more than a dozen awards, including two Emmys. With the blessing of her three children, Dawn retains the most important job title she's ever held: Dad.
 See Full Bio   
                  Follow:
                   
        FROM OUR SPONSORS
        
        The Latest
        
Crime 
        A gunman targeted Tucson’s LGBTQ+ community. A thousand Arizonans answered with love
      Mourners gathered at Catalina Park to honor Vincent Anthony Siqueiros and Cameron Davis Capara, two gay men killed outside Venture-N in a hate crime.
 
Jacob Ogles
 
Crime 
        Utah detectives say accused stalker told victim he ‘couldn’t wait to kill a gay person’
      Salt Lake City authorities say Damyen Vainuku repeatedly sent a former high school classmate threatening messages accompanied by photos of firearms.
 
Jacob Ogles
 
National 
        21 states sue over Trump’s attacks on gender-affirming care insurance coverage
      The states argue that the administration cannot override their decisions about medically necessary care for transgender people.
 
Jacob Ogles
 
News 
        WNBA commissioner Cathy Engelbert announces retirement amid trans athlete debate
      “I retire knowing we have built something bigger, stronger and more enduring than we could have imagined,” Engelbert said in a statement.
 
Samantha Allen

 
        More For You
        
        After Gov. Abigail Spanberger trounced her in Virginia, Winsome Earle-Sears targets marriage equality
     
Christopher Wiggins
 Jul 29, 2026 
Republican gubernatorial candidate Winsome Earle-Sears greets patrons during a visit to Shorty's Diner on November 03, 2025, in Richmond, Virginia. 

         Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
    
        Former Virginia Lt. Gov. Winsome Earle-Sears is returning to the campaign trail less than a year after voters decisively rejected her bid for governor. She is not moderating the anti-LGBTQ+ positions that helped define her candidacy. She is building a new campaign around them. Keep Reading → 
 
        The closet was once the law. Without an LGBTQ+ Bill of Rights, it could be again
     
Kevin Jennings
 Jul 29, 2026 

        D. Giraldez Alonso/Getty Images
    
        “Homosexual Rights? You’ve got to be kidding me.” Keep Reading → 
 
        Marriage equality turns 11 as conservatives renew their attacks on the fabric of America
     
Christopher Wiggins
 Jun 26, 2026 
Same-sex marriage supporter Vin Testa, of Washington, DC, waves a LGBTQIA pride flag in front of the U.S. Supreme Court Building as he makes pictures with his friend Donte Gonzalez to celebrate the anniversary of the United States v. Windsor and the Obergefell v. Hodges decisions on June 26, 2023 in Washington, DC. 

        Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
    
        Eleven years after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that same-sex couples have a constitutional right to marry, the Friday anniversary of Obergefell v. Hodges arrives in a country where marriage equality is deeply woven into American life and still treated by its opponents as unfinished business. Keep Reading → 
 
        New York Republican governor candidate faces questions over the antigay company he keeps
     
Christopher Wiggins
 Jun 12, 2026 
Bruce Blakeman is facing scrutiny for the anti-LGBTQ+ politicians in his circle of influence.

        Howard Schnapp/Newsday RM via Getty Images
    
        A Republican candidate seeking to govern one of the nation's most influential states is facing growing criticism from LGBTQ+ advocates and Democratic officials over his ties to politicians and activists who have opposed marriage equality, supported restrictions on LGBTQ+ visibility, and made remarks condemned as homophobic. Keep Reading → 
 
        Virginia is asking voters to finish the work of marriage equality
     
Christopher Wiggins
 Jun 08, 2026 
Pro-marriage equality activists gathered in Richmond to kick off a campaign to amend the Virginia constitution to protect people's right to marry.

        Phuong Tran, ACLU of Virginia.
    
        Twenty years after Virginia voters amended their constitution to ban same-sex marriages, a coalition of LGBTQ+ advocates, faith leaders, elected officials, and families is launching a campaign to erase that language and replace it with an explicit constitutional guarantee of marriage equality. Keep Reading → 
 
        Most Popular
        
Education 
        The 15 worst universities in the U.S. for LGBTQ+ students
      These are the worst places to go to college if you're looking for a queer-friendly and affirming environment.
 
Ariel Messman-Rucker
 
Opinion 
        When a pastor preaches cruelty, why does the congregation listen?
      The most disturbing part of Netflix’s Death of a Pastor’s Wife is not only what JP Miller preached, but how few people appeared willing to question him, writes John Casey.
 
John Casey
 
Education 
        The 15 best universities in the U.S. for LGBTQ+ students
      These are the top places to get a great education in a queer-friendly and affirming environment.
 
Ariel Messman-Rucker
 
People 
        11 times J.K. Rowling did something wildly transphobic, ranked
      The Harry Potter author has made no secret of her hate-filled anti-trans views.
 
Ariel Messman-Rucker
 
Crime 
        Two men charged after sexual assault of trans woman at UW-Madison
      Two men were charged on September 1 for allegedly strangling and sexually assaulting a transgender woman on the University of Wisconsin-Madison campus over the weekend, in the early morning of August 29.
 
Quispe López
 
Opinion 
        If anyone should get a motel room, it’s Senator John Kennedy and Donald Trump
      The Louisiana Republican's Obama and Colbert antigay smear campaign surely earned Trump’s undying love.
 
John Casey

Site Navigation

Judge Dismisses Case Against N.C.'s Same-Sex Marriage Opt-Out Law

U.S. District Judge Max Cogburn argued the plaintiffs failed to prove they were harmed by the law that allows officials to refuse to perform same-sex marriages if they cite religious objections.

The Latest

A gunman targeted Tucson’s LGBTQ+ community. A thousand Arizonans answered with love

Mourners gathered at Catalina Park to honor Vincent Anthony Siqueiros and Cameron Davis Capara, two gay men killed outside Venture-N in a hate crime.

21 states sue over Trump’s attacks on gender-affirming care insurance coverage

The states argue that the administration cannot override their decisions about medically necessary care for transgender people.

WNBA commissioner Cathy Engelbert announces retirement amid trans athlete debate

“I retire knowing we have built something bigger, stronger and more enduring than we could have imagined,” Engelbert said in a statement.

LGBTQ+ stories deserve to be told.

20 Years Ago Today Massachusetts Made History by Ruling in Favor of Marriage Equality

Reflecting on 20 Years of Making the Impossible Possible – and the Challenges Ahead

21 Photos of Muscle Bears in Love

PHOTOS: Coloradans Celebrate Civil Unions at Midnight

What states are the most dangerous for LGBTQ+ people? Here are the worst 15

More For You

After Gov. Abigail Spanberger trounced her in Virginia, Winsome Earle-Sears targets marriage equality

The closet was once the law. Without an LGBTQ+ Bill of Rights, it could be again

Marriage equality turns 11 as conservatives renew their attacks on the fabric of America

New York Republican governor candidate faces questions over the antigay company he keeps

Virginia is asking voters to finish the work of marriage equality

Most Popular

The 15 worst universities in the U.S. for LGBTQ+ students

These are the worst places to go to college if you're looking for a queer-friendly and affirming environment.

When a pastor preaches cruelty, why does the congregation listen?

The most disturbing part of Netflix’s Death of a Pastor’s Wife is not only what JP Miller preached, but how few people appeared willing to question him, writes John Casey.

The 15 best universities in the U.S. for LGBTQ+ students

These are the top places to get a great education in a queer-friendly and affirming environment.

11 times J.K. Rowling did something wildly transphobic, ranked

The Harry Potter author has made no secret of her hate-filled anti-trans views.

Two men charged after sexual assault of trans woman at UW-Madison

Two men were charged on September 1 for allegedly strangling and sexually assaulting a transgender woman on the University of Wisconsin-Madison campus over the weekend, in the early morning of August 29.

If anyone should get a motel room, it’s Senator John Kennedy and Donald Trump

The Louisiana Republican's Obama and Colbert antigay smear campaign surely earned Trump’s undying love.

Latest Stories

Stay up to date with the latest in LGBTQ+ news with The Advocate’s email newsletter, in your inbox five days a week.

Judge Dismisses Case Against N.C.'s Same-Sex Marriage Opt-Out Law

U.S. District Judge Max Cogburn argued the plaintiffs failed to prove they were harmed by the law that allows officials to refuse to perform same-sex marriages if they cite religious objections.

FROM OUR SPONSORS

The Latest

Mourners gathered at Catalina Park to honor Vincent Anthony Siqueiros and Cameron Davis Capara, two gay men killed outside Venture-N in a hate crime.

Salt Lake City authorities say Damyen Vainuku repeatedly sent a former high school classmate threatening messages accompanied by photos of firearms.

The states argue that the administration cannot override their decisions about medically necessary care for transgender people.

“I retire knowing we have built something bigger, stronger and more enduring than we could have imagined,” Engelbert said in a statement.

LGBTQ+ stories deserve to be told.

More For You

Most Popular

These are the worst places to go to college if you're looking for a queer-friendly and affirming environment.

The most disturbing part of Netflix’s Death of a Pastor’s Wife is not only what JP Miller preached, but how few people appeared willing to question him, writes John Casey.

These are the top places to get a great education in a queer-friendly and affirming environment.

The Harry Potter author has made no secret of her hate-filled anti-trans views.

Two men were charged on September 1 for allegedly strangling and sexually assaulting a transgender woman on the University of Wisconsin-Madison campus over the weekend, in the early morning of August 29.

The Louisiana Republican's Obama and Colbert antigay smear campaign surely earned Trump’s undying love.