Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Kim Davis still owes more than $565,000 for denying a gay couple a marriage license. Now she faces sanctions

A federal judge found that the former Kentucky county clerk broke disclosure rules.

A woman wearing glasses and a black women's top sits in a room.

Kim Davis in 2015.

Ty Wright/Getty Images

Former Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis asked a federal judge Monday to spare her from sanctions after he found that she failed to disclose assets to the gay couple she denied a marriage license to in 2015. The couple is still trying to collect more than $565,000 in damages, attorney fees and costs.

At issue are three deeds Davis signed months before she told the couple’s attorneys she had made no property transfers worth more than $2,000. The deeds show she transferred her interests in three parcels from her late mother’s estate. Davis says she understood herself to be carrying out her mother’s wishes and believed her answers were truthful.


“I had no intent then, and have no intent now, to conceal anything or to otherwise answer in any way other than the truth,” Davis wrote in a declaration filed Monday.

U.S. Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins declined to hold Davis in contempt but gave her until November 16 to correct her answers and explain why he should not sanction her. He has yet to decide whether to impose a penalty.

Related: Kentucky homophobe Kim Davis, who denied gay couples marriage licenses, must pay over $360,000

Davis’ lawyers at Liberty Counsel, a conservative Christian legal organization, said her answers “were at best an honest mistake and should not be sanctionable.” Michael J. Gartland, an attorney for the couple, told the Kentucky Lantern he would continue to press for sanctions.

“This is all made up to try to get out of trouble now,” Gartland said.

David Ermold and David Moore began seeking information about Davis’ finances in August 2025. A jury had awarded each man $50,000 in damages. Attorney fees and costs brought the initial judgment to $360,084.70. The court later awarded another $205,201.21 in fees and costs for the appeal. The judgment remains unpaid.

Davis told the men’s attorneys that she owned no real estate, had made no transfers exceeding $2,000 and was not a beneficiary of any trust or estate. But in a November 6 order, Atkins found that certified public records contradicted those answers.

The records included an affidavit showing Davis inherited a 50 percent interest in her mother’s estate, an estate inventory, and documents naming her as a co-administrator. The three deeds showed she transferred her interests in the properties in April and May 2025. Those transactions fell within the five years covered by the couple’s request.

Under federal rules, Davis was required to correct or supplement her disclosures if she learned they were incomplete or inaccurate. Atkins found she had failed to do so.

“Instead, Defendant violated the Rules by not disclosing her assets and providing no responsive documents,” Atkins wrote.

Ermold and Moore filed a separate lawsuit in state court challenging the transfers, alleging that Davis moved the inherited property to family members to prevent the couple from collecting the money she owes them. They want the Rowan County court to set the transfers aside. Atkins limited his federal ruling to whether Davis had met her obligation to disclose the transactions.

Related: Kim Davis is petitioning the Supreme Court to overturn marriage equality

Davis became a national figure in 2015 when she repeatedly refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples in Rowan County, Kentucky, citing her religious beliefs. The U.S. Supreme Court had just recognized same-sex couples’ constitutional right to marry in Obergefell v. Hodges. Davis said issuing a license bearing her name would violate her beliefs.

Davis spent five days in jail for defying a federal court order. A deputy clerk issued the couple’s licenses without Davis’ name, and Kentucky later removed county clerks’ names from marriage licenses.

Related: Gay Man Denied Marriage License by Kim Davis Wants Her Job

In 2022, a federal judge ruled that Davis had violated the constitutional rights of same-sex couples by denying them marriage licenses, rejecting her argument that religious freedom protected her actions as an elected official. After a federal appeals court upheld the judgment, Davis asked the Supreme Court to review her case.

The justices declined in November 2025.

FROM OUR SPONSORS

More For You