Alabama Judge, Ordered to Recognize Same-Sex Marriage, Denies Second-Parent Adoption

The Alabama probate judge who refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples until a court order forced him to do so is now being sued again -- over his refusal to process an adoption petition from the couple whose lawsuit brough down the state's marriage ban.

Mobile County Probate Judge Don Davis has refused to process a second-parent adoption petition that would allow Cari Searcy to be legally recognized as a parent to the son she and Kimberly McKeand have been raising since he was born in 2005, reports AL.com, a site for several Alabama newspapers.

McKeand gave birth to the child, who was fathered by a sperm donor who has waived parental rights, but Alabama law has not recognized Searcy's role in the boy's life, even though the women were married in California in 2008 -- a situation that led them to challenge Alabama's same-sex marriage ban, which was struck down by a federal judge last month.

Even after U.S. District Judge Callie V.S. Granade's January ruling in Searcy v. Strange (which invalidated the ban) took effect February 9, Davis initially refused to issue same-sex couples marriage licenses.

That prompted four couples to seek -- and earlier this month, receive -- guidance from the Judge Granade, explicitly ordering Davis to allow same-sex couples to marry. That clarification formally named only Davis in his capacity as Mobile County probate pudge, but probate judges across the state took the guidance to mean they too were required to begin issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples.

Trending stories

Gays went feral at an iconic Pride celebration in Pensacola, Florida

France becomes world’s first country to enshrine abortion rights in constitution

Listen up WNBA fans, players are fed up with sex toy bit, so can you please keep it in your pants?

Pete Buttigieg's betrayal of trans people will cost the Democratic Party

Checking out: nhow London, the city’s coolest hotel

Thanks to U=U, HIV-positive people can live long, happy, healthy lives

Wilderness, woods, and Wigstock: Drag icons light up the Catskills

'Wednesday' and the liberating queerness of its badly behaved women

All 6 rogue Mississippi cops got long prison sentences in 'Goon Squad' torture of 2 Black men

Malcolm-Jamal Warner leaves behind an enduring HIV legacy with his groundbreaking 1992 film

How climate disasters hurt mental health in young people

The Talk: Starting the conversation

Joe Biden has tied the record for most LGBTQ+ judges confirmed in federal courts

Electric Forest is a once-in-a-lifetime experience for everyone in the LGBTQ+ community

15 of the worst lesbian girlfriends in TV and movie history

Crypto bros say they organized dildo-throwing pranks at WNBA games to promote memecoin

Need an escape from American anxiety? Consider Colombia.

Rosie O'Donnell defends 'The View,' drags Trump: 'We're in a dictatorship with good lighting'

Elon Musk uses burner accounts on X, doesn’t fact-check: report

JT opens up about gay uncles, queer fans, Bad Bunny, and 'Love Island'

Gay model arrested after his estranged husband was found dead in their New York City apartment

How the Black AIDS Institute continues to fill in the gaps

An HIV survivor once helped Superman star Christopher Reeve, and was helped in return

The sex toy prank at WNBA games isn't funny — it's sexist

Celebs and LGBTQ+ community mourn Jasmine International's passing

• 0
• 1
• 2
• 3
• 4
• 5
• 6
• 7
• 8

Despite the end of the marriage ban, Davis is now refusing to recognize Searcy and McKeand's marriage for the purposes of a second-parent adoption, which would ensure the women's son has two legal guardians.

Davis last Friday issued what is called an "interlocutory decree," granting Searcy certain parental rights on a temporary basis, but it also included this wording: "It is further ORDERED by the Court that this Decree is qualified in nature, and the Court will not issue a final adoption order until a final ruling is issued in the United States Supreme Court on the Marriage Act cases before it."

Davis was also the same judge who denied an earlier second-parent adoption petition from Searcy by citing the marriage ban, leading to the couple's ultimately successful original suit against the ban.

Davis declined comment on the matter to AL.com, while David Kennedy, a lawyer for Searcy and McKeand, expressed exasperation.

"I'm disappointed," he told AL.com. "The United States Supreme Court made a decision with the ruling in the Searcy case [declining to extend the stay on Granade's ruling]. We don't think that it's fair or equitable to Cari Searcy to wait until the Supreme Court has ruled on some Sixth Circuit case." That case involves the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals' ruling upholding marriage bans in Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky, and Tennessee; the court will hear it this spring.

The temporary order, he added, gives Searcy only limited protection. If McKeand were to die before a Supreme Court ruling, relatives could challenge Searcy's parental rights, and she would not necessarily get custody of their son.

"That's actually very much an open question," he said. "It's the reason we filed the [original] lawsuit."