Retraction of Ex-Gay Study May Affect Prop. 8 Trial
BY Michelle Garcia
April 27 2012 3:41 PM ET
Scientist Robert Spitzer's recent retraction of a study that suggests so-called ex-gay therapy can be effective may be a gateway to striking down Proposition 8 in court, says New York University legal scholar Kenji Yoshino.
Spitzer wrote a letter to Ken Zucker, editor of the Archives of Sexual Behavior, the journal that published his 2001 study claiming that "highly motivated" gays and lesbians could reverse their sexual orientation. Spitzer's letter also apologizes to LGBT people for "making unproven claims of the efficacy of reparative therapy," he wrote."I also apologize to any gay person who wasted time and energy undergoing some form of reparative therapy because they believed that I had proven that reparative therapy works with some 'highly motivated' individuals."
Spitzer's realization went public after journalist Gabriel Arana's report in TheAmerican Prospect related to his own experience with "ex-gay" therapy, in which he spoke with Spitzer. The researcher said he requested a retraction in the Archives of Sexual Behavior, but the editor had declined to run it.
The study was a significant part of the argument brought forward by antigay forces, especially those defending Proposition 8 in court. They argued that because the study said a person could change their sexual orientation, no one should not be allowed to marry people of the same sex. On Thursday's episode of The Rachel Maddow Show, Yoshino said that Spitzer's announcement could translate to gay people being included as a protected class under the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution.
"The reason that immutability is important is because under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, there’s a standard called heightened scrutiny," Yoshino said. "There's certain classifications like race, national origin, sex, nonmarital parentage, and lineage that get that form of heightened scrutiny. The $64,000 question of this case is whether or not sexual orientation is going to be added to that list. And one of the criteria that's been looked at to determine whether or not a group gets heightened scrutiny is immutability, as you mentioned. So the fact that Spitzer retracting this and the fact that the testimony in the Prop. 8 trial was overwhelming for the fact that sexual orientation is very hard to change could figure into that analysis."
- An Exodus From the 'Ex-Gay' Movement?
- Op-ed: How My Mom Found Out About My Boyfriend
- Martina Navratilova Blasts Russian Antigay Law
- Filipino Archbishop Says Gay Men and Lesbians Can Marry — Each Other
- Op-ed: How Animated Shows Like Futurama Can Unite Us All
- President Obama Adresses LGBT Rights in Berlin Speech
Sign Up For Email Updates
- Commentary Op-ed: How My Mom Found Out About My Boyfriend 39 min 11 sec ago
- Religion An Exodus From the 'Ex-Gay' Movement? 12:50 AM
- Entertainment News A Moment For James Gandolfini June 19 2013 11:38 PM
- Entertainment News Muscle Worship: Meet the Men of L.A.'s New Gay Strip Club June 19 2013 9:45 PM
- Religion Filipino Archbishop Says Gay Men and Lesbians Can Marry — Each Other June 19 2013 7:56 PM
- Travel Drag Racing in Jerusalem June 19 2013 7:20 PM
- Crime Police Seek Suspects Who Vandalized Chick-fil-A With Antigay Slurs June 19 2013 7:18 PM