The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear a lawsuit brought by Gays Against Groomers, an organization the Southern Poverty Law Center identifies as an anti-LGBTQ+ hate group, over Colorado lawmakers’ refusal to allow witnesses to misgender and deadname transgender people during legislative hearings.
The justices rejected the appeal without comment, leaving intact a federal appeals court ruling that shielded five Democratic state lawmakers from the lawsuit. The decision ends the case without settling whether restrictions on misgendering violate the First Amendment.
The controversy began in 2024, when Colorado lawmakers considered Tiara’s Law, legislation intended to make legal name changes easier for people with felony convictions, including transgender people seeking identification documents reflecting their identities.
Rich Guggenheim of Gays Against Groomers and Christina Goeke of the Rocky Mountain Women’s Network opposed the measure. They alleged that lawmakers interrupted their testimony after they refused to use a transgender person’s correct name and pronouns. Goeke also alleged that portions of her testimony were removed from the legislative record.
The activists sued, arguing that lawmakers had discriminated against their political viewpoints.
Related: 12 far-right groups with extreme anti-LGBTQ+ positions that threaten civil rights
A group with a documented history
Gays Against Groomers, founded in 2022 by Jaimee Michell, presents itself as an LGBTQ+ organization protecting children. Its activities tell a different story.
The Southern Poverty Law Center has documented the group’s harassment campaigns targeting transgender people, drag performers, hospitals, and libraries, along with its promotion of conspiracy theories equating gender-affirming healthcare with child sexual abuse.
The Advocate previously reported that Michell appeared on Fox News after the 2022 Club Q massacre in Colorado Springs and suggested that such violence would continue unless gender-affirming care ended.
In 2024, the group falsely suggested that Colorado’s gay Democratic governor, Jared Polis, had endorsed its work. State officials apologized after acknowledging that the organization’s ceremonial flag request had not been properly vetted.
What the Supreme Court left standing
A federal district court dismissed the lawsuit in November 2024. The 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that decision in March, finding that legislative immunity protected lawmakers’ authority to establish and enforce hearing rules.
The Institute for Free Speech, representing the plaintiffs, criticized Monday’s decision.
“We’re disappointed that the Court declined to take up this case,” attorney Del Kolde said.















