Scroll To Top
World

Tyler, Olson, and
Lawyer Gloria Allred File Suit in Wake of Prop. 8

Tyler, Olson, and
Lawyer Gloria Allred File Suit in Wake of Prop. 8

Tyler_allredx390

Robin Tyler and Diane Olson, the first plaintiff couple named in the historic lawsuit that overturned California's ban on gay marriage and the first same-sex couple married in Los Angeles County in June, wasted no time filing a new lawsuit with California's supreme court Wednesday morning. In announcing their legal action, the couple also said the No on 8 campaign -- specifically Los Angeles-based efforts -- dropped the ball in helping to defeat the measure.

Robin Tyler and Diane Olson, the first plaintiff couple named in the historic lawsuit that overturned California's ban on gay marriage and the first same-sex couple married in Los Angeles County in June, wasted no time filing a new lawsuit with California's supreme court Wednesday morning.

Though the fate of Prop. 8 -- which would constitutionally ban same-sex marriage in the state of California -- remained uncertain, with 3 million provisional and absentee ballots still uncounted, Yes on 8 claimed victory Wednesday morning. Tyler, Olson, and their Hollywood power attorney Gloria Allred announced at a press conference at Allred's Wilshire Boulevard office that afternoon that they would file a new lawsuit challenging Prop. 8's constitutionality.

Despite widespread finger-pointing blaming Prop 8.'s passage on the high turnout of black voters and the financial backing of the Mormon Church, the couple said that the No on 8 campaign -- specifically Los Angeles-based efforts -- dropped the ball, helping the measure to pass.

"A few weeks ago I said, 'If we won it would be despite No on 8, and if we lost it would be because of No on 8," Tyler said, accusing the campaign of utilizing "checkbook" politics that replaced unified grassroots organizing. She said the campaign kept the faces of gay marriage out of its ads.

While Tyler and Olson had geared up for another public, political battle in the courts even before Election Day came and went, the effect of Prop. 8's showing at the polls was etched on their faces as they spoke.

"The fact that some people would like to undo our 'I do' makes me very sad," Olson said.

Tyler emphasized that LGBT people need to frame the marriage issue as the civil rights issue that it is, calling Prop. 8 unconstitutional for violating California's equal protection clause.

"This is a civil rights issue," Tyler said. "It is not about a lifestyle, it is about our lives."

Faced with the question of whether domestic partnerships that afforded the same benefits as marriage without the word marriage would suffice, Tyler said, "Separate is never equal."

"We're not going to drink from the separate water fountain of marriage," Tyler said.

Allred spoke out about the terminology of civil unions and domestic partnerships versus marriage.

"Marriage is a fundamental right. The m word means something special," she said, adding that it's because marriage is unique that opponents want to keep it all to themselves.

As the suit makes its way through the California supreme court, Tyler and Olsen will continue their struggle for marriage equality. Tyler told reporters that they would not take Prop. 8's passage lightly and that they were not going away.

"I love Robin," Olson said. "We just want our equal rights." (Tracy Gilchrist, The Advocate)

Advocate Channel - The Pride StoreOut / Advocate Magazine - Fellow Travelers & Jamie Lee Curtis

From our Sponsors

Most Popular

Latest Stories

Outtraveler Staff