Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

‘You’re doing it’: Judge orders Trump administration to disclose evidence behind Trump’s trans military ban

Judge Ana Reyes rejected the government’s secrecy arguments, saying its motives are central to the discrimination case brought by transgender troops.

pentagon in virginia

In an aerial view, the Pentagon, headquarters of the U.S. Department of Defense, is seen on November 7, 2026, in Arlington, Virginia.

Kevin Carter/Getty Images

A federal judge on Monday ordered the Trump administration to disclose internal evidence about how it developed its transgender military ban. She rejected an effort to shield the government’s decision-making from service members fighting to keep their careers.

U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes gave government lawyers 28 days to produce records withheld under deliberative process privilege and arrange answers to relevant questions they had blocked during depositions. She also authorized questioning of former Army Secretary Dan Driscoll.


When a Justice Department attorney protested that disclosure would complicate trial preparations, Reyes held firm.

“I assume that the government is putting the appropriate resources that it needs to handle the case,” she said. “You’re getting the information over to the plaintiff. You’re doing it.”

The plaintiffs, trans service members affected by the ban, are represented by LGBTQ+ civil rights organizations GLAD Law and the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, alongside Wardenski P.C., Zalkind Duncan & Bernstein LLP, Kropf Moseley Schmitt PLLC, and O’Melveny & Myers LLP.

The afternoon teleconference in Talbott v. Trump concerned evidence in a case that will decide whether the administration’s stated concerns about military readiness explain the policy or conceal discrimination against transgender Americans.

“We’re beyond allegations here”

Related: Fireworks in D.C. courtroom as judge hears DOJ request to undo block on trans military ban

Deliberative process privilege generally protects internal discussions that help government officials reach decisions. Reyes ruled that it could not shield the evidence at issue because the government’s intent is central to the plaintiffs’ constitutional claims.

She mentioned her earlier findings that the administration rushed the policy, lacked basic supporting data, failed to analyze contrary evidence, and neglected to evaluate costs and effects on readiness.

“We’re beyond allegations here,” Reyes said. “The court has made preliminary findings on animus.”

In her March 2025 ruling temporarily blocking the policy, Reyes described it as “soaked in animus and dripping with pretext,” finding that the administration’s stated justifications likely concealed discriminatory intent.

Even if the privilege applied, she said, the plaintiffs’ need for evidence controlled exclusively by the government outweighed its disclosure concerns. Sensitive information could receive safeguards, she said.

Reyes left separate attorney-client and attorney work product claims unresolved and clarified that she was not broadly reopening depositions.

“Be judicious,” she said. “Don’t ask for every single one.”

No pause before trial

Related: Pete Hegseth defended his anti-trans slurs under penalty of perjury. The DOJ wants them excluded from trial

Justice Department attorney Jared Littman argued that the ruling would prejudice the government as it prepared for trial. Reyes extended her initial 21-day deadline to 28 days but refused to pause the order while the administration considered seeking appellate intervention.

“I’m quite confident that the government can muster its resources to produce some documents,” she said.

The two-week bench trial remains scheduled to begin on January 4, after the administration withdrew its effort to seek a ruling without trial.

“We’re not moving trial date, and we’re all moving forward,” Reyes said.

She permitted a two-hour deposition of Driscoll about his knowledge of the policy, including its implementation. Government lawyers argued that plaintiffs were speculating about his involvement in developing it.

“I’m sure Mr. Driscoll can find two hours in his life to do this,” Reyes said.

She offered to reduce questioning to one hour if the government provided a sworn statement that Driscoll had no relevant conversations with members of the administration’s transition team or Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and no role in developing the executive order.

Related: Judge hints at federal class action, orders DOJ evidence in trans military ban case

Hegseth’s statements remain in dispute

The hearing followed The Advocate’s reporting Sunday that Hegseth defended his anti-trans rhetoric in sworn written answers while government lawyers sought to exclude those statements from trial. The administration maintains that its restrictions concern medical qualifications, but plaintiffs argue they target transgender people regardless of fitness to serve.

Reyes previously warned that inadequate written answers could lead to Hegseth’s deposition. She did not order that deposition Monday or decide whether his statements would be admitted at trial.

When Littman repeatedly called the Pentagon the Department of War, Reyes corrected him.

“Every time you say Department of War, I’m going to say Department of Defense,” she said.

Hegseth has restyled the Pentagon as the Department of War under a Trump executive order authorizing that secondary title. But changing its legal name requires legislation.

“While we’re in here, we’re going to call it what the statute says,” Reyes said.

FROM OUR SPONSORS

More For You