David Kilmnick of the LGBT Network says Maher's HBO show, Real Time With Bill Maher, should be canceled after the remarks.
The cast of the Amazon Prime homosocial castaway series chats with The Advocate about how its gay love story has resonated so deeply with fans.
The series premieres June 2.
McKinnon, who effectively changed queer sketches on the long-running show, stepped into Colleen Rafferty's loose underwear one last time.
McKinnon has been on the show since 2012.