|| News ||
1 2 NEXT  Page 1 of 2

Marriage or Bust

GOProud Chair Christopher R. Barron says the marriage or bust approach of gay activists leaves little room for other reforms that will reduce discrimination against LGBT couples.

DC MARRIAGE X390 (DC AGENDA) | ADVOCATE.COM

COMMENTARY: The media has been whipped into a frenzy in the wake of an NAACP resolution urging the Tea Party to repudiate supposedly racist elements within the movement. As the NAACP and the rest of the left knows, or at least should know, the tea party isn’t a political party, lacks a formal structure, and has no leadership empowered to speak for the entire movement. With this knowledge in hand, I assume the NAACP expects every person who has ever shown up at a tea party event or even believes in the tea party’s message to post a sign in their front yard stating: “I repudiate any racist element within the tea party.” The logistics of this demand aside, the NAACP’s decision to pass this resolution does serve one important purpose – to confirm just how irrelevant the organization is to the modern challenges facing black Americans.

The good news is that the NAACP isn’t alone in sinking to irrelevance. Indeed, compared to the disconnect between most national gay groups and the challenges facing gay and lesbian families in 2010 – even the NAACP and its desperate cry for attention looks relevant.

The national gay rights groups who make up Gay, Inc. share much in common. Almost all of them are funded by the same handful of rich, liberal donors; almost all of them take their marching orders from the Democratic National Committee; and almost all of them pursue a legislative agenda that offers the same policy prescriptions – marriage and more government.

Indeed its pursuit of marriage at all costs, at often at the expense of other legislation that would improve the lives of average gay Americans, is one of the most serious strategic and political blunders in modern history.

Before the left accuses me of selling out the fight for marriage, let me make it clear — marriage is important and I support marriage rights for gay couples. I believe marriage is a debate worth having and a fight worth fighting. Marriage is certainly personally important to me — in March of this year, I married my partner here in Washington, D.C. That having been said, we aren’t anywhere close to marriage equality nationwide and we won’t be for a very long time. Why should immediate improvements to retirement security, tax fairness and healthcare for gay and lesbian families be ignored?

The gay rights movement was born out of the Stonewall riots in New York City in 1969: an uprising against government action. In truly Orwellian fashion, however, Gay, Inc. has worked feverishly to morph a movement that had its roots in getting the government out of our bars, out of our bedrooms and out of our lives, into a movement hell bent on expanding the reach and power of that same government.

Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Twitter. Follow us on Facebook Follow us on Facebook. 1 2 NEXT  Page 1 of 2
Reader Comments
  • Name: John in Dallas
    Date posted: 8/2/2010 10:52:46 PM
    Hometown: Dallas

    Comment:

    wow Josh!! Get out of LA fast before they hang you infront of "Micky's" for saying that-LOL! WELL SAID, "Stop being single-issue voters. Vote for your best interests. I promise, once you see what those are, you might be surprised who you have some common ground with. ' Until the gay community get's their act together they are nothing more than a "frindge group" who whine about the same ol worn out issue. You are sooooo right on point about Taxes, goverment, and all of it. I was so sick of California and the BS, my partner and I left the bankrupt state of Calif and moved to Texas-we love it! I was born and raised in Calif and worked for the Los Angeles Police department till I retired in 2008-it got to the point I could not stand the damn gay community and all the "bitching and moaning" they do. I wanted to say "grow up fools!" Now I am in Texas in a RED STATE and we love it!

  • Name: John in Dallas
    Date posted: 8/2/2010 10:38:12 PM
    Hometown: Dallas

    Comment:

    WOW!!!! GREAT ARTICAL IT IS ABOUT TIME SOMEONE IN THE GAY COMMUNITY "CALLED IT LIKE IT IS"- I AM AN OPENLY GAY CONSERVATIVE AND LOVE THIS-those talking trash about this artical are some meaningless to me and a gay man I won't even waist my time trying to respond to them and thier remarks-it is not worth my time. Great artical!!

  • Name: Derek Washington
    Date posted: 8/2/2010 11:10:07 AM
    Hometown: Las Vegas

    Comment:

    Yeah Yeah Yeah. We recently had a Dems vs Reps debate here and the GOProud guy kept ducking any issue that he saw as "Gay". I understand as a Black man that I am more than one thing. However, as a Black man, I know I was unshackled during the civil rights movement and because I'm Gay I have been reshackled. I think being considered a whole citizen is a little more important than anything else. I have taxation without full representation which these Gay R's should be up in arms about but aren't. I think they want to fit in so bad with the straight kids that they are willing to be like a fat kids who takes being the brunt of teasing just to tag along with the "cool" bullies. Sad actually.

  • Name: Peter
    Date posted: 7/29/2010 2:12:11 PM
    Hometown: Chicago

    Comment:

    Never understood gay conserv's, but oh well, that's your perogative...Anyways, a couple things - hate crimes: there are practical benefits - M.Shephard Act gives the feds resources/$$ to investigate crimes, when local authorities don't; you don't have to participating in a "federally-protected" activity to charge someone w/hate crime, and most imp. FBI has to track hate crimes against trans-folks. That all being said, I don't get why LGBT folks would want to vote Repub. Less taxes? Great, 'cept we know tax cuts usually benefit upper middle class, wealthy and business; Strong defense - great again, 'cept it looks like our defense is now mostly offense (2 endless wars -1 of which is prolly illegal if not immoral); Indv. freedom? great as long as you're not planning on getting married, having an abortion, adopting a kid; Not saying Dem's are perfect (far from it), but they're gonna be a lot easier to get on our side than Repub's.

  • Name: Joshua
    Date posted: 7/28/2010 8:18:23 PM
    Hometown: Los Angeles

    Comment:

    The larger point here is this: basing your votes based on only one issue is a very stupid thing to do. There is a whole package of other issues that will help gays and lesbians TODAY that are worth supporting. For instance, issues that actually will help to bring equality to all Americans are: marriage equality, equal and low taxes, free market health care. Issues or activities that will not bring equality to all Americans: giving money to Democrats, hate crimes, ENDA, the death tax. Grow up. Stop being single-issue voters. Vote for your best interests. I promise, once you see what those are, you might be surprised who you have some common ground with.

  • Name: Gabino
    Date posted: 7/28/2010 10:08:47 AM
    Hometown: Miami

    Comment:

    I find it ironic that many of those on here so adamantly fighting for gay "marriage" might've been the ones in the 60s and 70s arguing for "free love" and the destruction of the institution of marriage as a remnant of our "Christian" past! And why not use the term "civil unions" if you are so oopposed to the "christian right". After all, marriage is a sacrament taken from the Bible. What you should be arguing for is civil unions for straight and gay - government completely out of the mariage business. Let Churches marry. On the economic front, I agree with Chris completely as well. We live in the richest society man has ever created because our Constitution mandated liberty as our guiding principle. When man is given liberty to pursue his happiness, great things happen. Do NOT tell me how to think by passing laws like ENDA and hate crimes. Prosecute a crime for what it is - murder is murder, it does not matter if I scream "I hate you!" while I'm killing you. That is thought control!

  • Name: Dennis
    Date posted: 7/28/2010 8:05:11 AM
    Hometown: Rochester

    Comment:

    I'm sorry, Mr. Barron, but if you don't support marriage equality, which is pretty much what you say here, then taking advantage of by getting married to your long-term partner (and oh, there must be a place in heaven for him) is pretty hypocritical. Choose your issues to focus on as you see fit. That is your right. But don't denigrate the work of others simply because their priorities don't line up with yours. When the conservative right starts respecting the opinions of those who don't agree, we will have come a long way towards solving all of our problems.

  • Name: ozzy
    Date posted: 7/28/2010 6:12:20 AM
    Hometown: sacramento

    Comment:

    Yawn...

  • Name: Jonathan
    Date posted: 7/27/2010 8:56:45 PM
    Hometown: Duluth, MN

    Comment:

    I think the reason why people respond so passionately to gay marriage is because it's a single issue in a sea of gay rights challenges. Marriage is a dream for so many, who spend decades trying to meet anyone and find nobody at all, after moving, after trying different groups, and after not trying so hard. It's a great reminder for a lot of us that coming out felt like it was for nothing and years wasted only to end up alone. What needs to be understood here is that we are not moving forward. More young gay men remain closeted, this time on the internet, with no intentions of growing up, coming out, and learning how to date other gay men. I see it all the time. In real life, there are definitely visible gay people, but usually the same ones over and over...we are becoming more anonymous now than when the bookstores/saunas were open. We aren't learning the quality of a person and the greatness of love that leads to marriage. What good is marriage if you can't find anyone?

  • Name: Stephen
    Date posted: 7/27/2010 7:24:46 PM
    Hometown: Pensacola

    Comment:

    How dare you sir. How dare you say that marriage is a dream and we are unrealistic. I am a young gay man and to me, marriage is not a dream...it is a hopeful reality. I live in the south, and my chance for marriage equality is very limited from where I sit. It must be nice to make your lofty proclamations from Washington, DC where you can have a legally recognized marriage. I am not left or right when it comes to my political viewpoints. I am a person dedicated to fulfilling the promise that this country has made to it's citizens, equality. So sir, as you sneer at the "impossibility" of marriage as you take full advantage of the one you currently enjoy, the rest of us will keep working. We will keep fighting and lobbying and talking to our friends and neighbors changing one mind at a time if we have to. But what we won't do, what I WON"T DO, is condemn myself to second class citizenship, to cater to your political agenda. Shame on you sir. Shame on you.

 PREVIOUS 1 2 3 NEXT  


Don't Miss
  • Best of Broadway How Broadway Does a Flea Market

    Find out why actress Kathleen Chalfant calls the annual Flea Market and Grand Auction in Times Square "the most glamorous flea market you've ever seen." It raised half a million dollars to fight HIV/AIDS.

  • News Is CPAC Illegally Discriminating Against Gays?

    Fred Karger once again isn't being allowed a table at one of the GOP's biggest annual gatherings, and this time he's threatening legal action because he believes he's being discriminated against because he's gay.

  • News Obama Makes the Case for Fairness
     

    He made the case for “a return to the American values of fair play and shared responsibility” — a theme pertinent for an LGBT community facing disproportionate poverty rates and legal barriers to equal rights.

  • Film Mosquita y Mari’s Path to Sundance

    Director Aurora Guerrero talks to The Advocate about the making of her new film and how she believes mainstream media simplifies the lives of LGBT and Latino characters.

  • Film Young & Wild: A Director’s Perspective

    The director and cowriter of Young & Wild, a film about a teen struggling to reconcile her raging sexual drive with an evangelical upbringing, writes about making the film and her own life growing up lesbian in Chile.

  • Arts and Entertainment Hot Sheet

    The top 10 entertainment highlights on our gaydar this week: Ross Mathews takes over, Mrs. Danvers fondles again, while Halston and Carol Channing get documented.

  • Travel Slideshow Flag Gayest Cities in America, 2012

    It's no secret that megalopolises New York City, Chicago, and Los Angeles have robust LGBT life — and we've even heard tell of little queer hoods like the Castro and P-Town. This isn't that list.

 
 
Advocate Subscribe Promo Banner 300x50
 
Follow Us Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterSubscribe to our RSS feedsDownload our app
Facebook Activity
 
COVER 1055 X135 | ADVOCATE.COM
Today's Headlines