Kentucky school officials want lawsuit dismissed
BY Advocate.com Editors
May 21 2003 12:00 AM ET
School officials in Boyd County, Ky., deny that they violated federal law by banning a gay rights-oriented student group from meeting at Boyd County High School and want a federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit against them. The response of the school board, superintendent Bill Capehart, and Boyd County High School principal Jerry Johnson challenges the lawsuit, which U.S. district judge David L. Bunning ruled last month has "a strong likelihood" of winning. "The case hasn't been tried on the merits yet," said Sheri Bryan, chairwoman of the Boyd County school board.
The lawsuit was brought by the American Civil Liberties Union on behalf of the Gay-Straight Alliance, seven students and their parents, and Kaye King, a Boyd County High School English teacher who is the alliance's adviser. The response was filed May 8.
After the school's teacher-parent council voted 3-2 in October to let the group meet on campus, the school board in December banned all noncurricular student clubs from using school facilities. But the ACLU sued in January, saying some student groups were being allowed to meet at the school while the alliance was not. The ACLU said the district violated the alliance members' free-speech rights, failed to end antigay harassment in the school, and violated the Kentucky Education Reform Act by overturning a school council decision.
Bunning agreed. He issued an injunction requiring the district to let the Gay-Straight Alliance meet at the school pending resolution of the lawsuit. Bryan said the school board did not want to appeal the injunction because school is nearly over for the year.
King said on Monday that the alliance has been meeting weekly at the school, with 10 to 12 members attending each meeting. "We're not having any trouble with the students here at school," King said.
In its response to the lawsuit, the district denied discriminating against the Gay-Straight Alliance, failing to address antigay harassment, and violating the reform act. The response also said that the alliance failed to pursue all administrative channels in regard to the club ban and that the district had the
right to ban clubs "to maintain order and discipline in the school district as permitted under both state and federal law."
School board members said in December that they banned clubs through June 30 to give the board time to rewrite the district's club policy. Bryan said the process is ongoing but that the board likely will revise the club policy next month and that it will go into effect July 1. "It will be equitable across the board for all clubs," she said.
- The Top 175 Essential Films of All Time for LGBT Viewers
- Gay Wedding Advice for Gays and Straights
- PHOTOS: Toronto Shows Off Its Pride
- Op-ed: What Happened When President Obama Met Two Trans Service Members
- PHOTOS: The Bare Truths of Trans Men
- Ethics Complaint Filed Against Texas AG Over Stance on Marriage Licenses