
CONTACTAbout UsCAREER OPPORTUNITIESADVERTISE WITH USPRIVACY POLICYPRIVACY PREFERENCESTERMS OF USELEGAL NOTICE
© 2025 Equal Entertainment LLC.
All Rights reserved
All Rights reserved
By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
We need your help
Your support makes The Advocate's original LGBTQ+ reporting possible. Become a member today to help us continue this work.
Your support makes The Advocate's original LGBTQ+ reporting possible. Become a member today to help us continue this work.
The ninth circuit court of appeals is asking the California supreme court to advise on whether antigay groups have standing to appeal a federal judge's decision that struck down Proposition 8.
In documents released on the ninth circuit's website, the federal appeals court indicates it isn't certain if groups like Protect Marriage have standing to pursue an appeal, since the current governor and attorney general of California are declining to defend the initiative, which narrowly passed in November 2008.
Both Gov. Jerry Brown and Atty. Gen. Kamala Harris support the August 2010 ruling of Vaughn Walker, which declared the antigay measure unconstitutional (the previous governor and attorney general, Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jerry Brown, respectively, took the same position).
A three-judge panel of the ninth circuit heard arguments in December related to both constitutionality and appellants' standing.
"Having considered the parties' briefs and arguments, we are now convinced the Proponents' claim to standing depends on Proponents' particularized interests created by state law or their authority under state law to defend the constitutionality of the initiative, which rights it appears to us have not yet been clearly defined by the Court," judges state in the website documents. "We therefore request clarification in order to determine whether we have jurisdiction to decide this case."
The ninth circuit did deny standing to officials in California's Imperial County -- that county's board of supervisors and a deputy clerk hoped to intervene in the federal challenge to Proposition 8 and defend the initiative.
"Imperial County and the initiative proponents play different roles," says Jennifer Pizer, national marriage project director for Lambda Legal. "They -- the Prop. 8 proponents who say they worked hard on the initiative and a deputy clerk in Imperial County who says she would be affected by [marriage equality] -- have different claims of interest. The fact that it was a deputy -- if it had been the actual clerk, I think it would have been a harder question."
The question of standing for the antigay groups will likely be taken up by the entire supreme court rather than the chief justice, Pizer says. "[An answer] is likely to be months, not weeks, but it won't be years either," she says.
Click here to view the court documents.
Nbroverman
From our Sponsors
Most Popular
Watch Now: Pride Today
Latest Stories
Detroit trans woman Karmin Wells shot and killed
July 16 2025 5:53 PM
Daily newsletter 7/16
July 16 2025 5:12 PM
5,000 users leave trans subreddit in wake of transmasculine controversy
July 16 2025 4:10 PM
Cooper Koch’s Emmy nomination earned him a surprise prison call
July 16 2025 3:47 PM
Florida officials claim SCOTUS ruling allows them to deny trans adults health care
July 16 2025 2:43 PM
Trending stories
Recommended Stories for You
Neal Broverman
Neal Broverman is the Editorial Director, Print of Pride Media, publishers of The Advocate, Out, Out Traveler, and Plus, spending more than 20 years in journalism. He indulges his interest in transportation and urban planning with regular contributions to Los Angeles magazine, and his work has also appeared in the Los Angeles Times and USA Today. He lives in the City of Angels with his husband, children, and their chiweenie.
Neal Broverman is the Editorial Director, Print of Pride Media, publishers of The Advocate, Out, Out Traveler, and Plus, spending more than 20 years in journalism. He indulges his interest in transportation and urban planning with regular contributions to Los Angeles magazine, and his work has also appeared in the Los Angeles Times and USA Today. He lives in the City of Angels with his husband, children, and their chiweenie.