"Family Guy" has fun with AIDS  | News Feature | Advocate.com

||  News Feature  ||
     
"Family Guy" has fun with AIDS
Fox TV’s irreverent animated series aired an episode this summer that showcases a comic musical number called “You Have AIDS.” Overburdened AIDS service organizations are not amused.
An Advocate.com exclusive posted August 22, 2005

The Fox TV network and its animated comedy series Family Guy apparently think AIDS is a laughing matter.

AIDS groups are leveling harsh criticism against the network after it aired and then reran an episode of the show that includes a lengthy song-and-dance joke about a sick man who is diagnosed with AIDS.

The episode--titled “The Cleveland-Loretta Quagmire”--aired on June 12 and was rerun on August 14.

In the show, the program’s main character, Peter Griffin, offers to tell a friend that his wife is cheating on him because of his self-proclaimed gifted way of breaking bad news to people. As an example of this alleged skill, the program shows a flashback as to how Peter told a gaunt man lying in a hospital bed of his AIDS diagnosis. The man is also depicted as young and sporting a goatee, possibly subtly suggesting that he is gay.

Peter is shown as part of a barbershop quartet that dances around the ill man’s hospital room, singing “You got the AIDS” and making it clear that the man is not just HIV-positive but has developed “full-blown AIDS.” The shocking song-and-dance number continues to speculate about how the man became infected: “when you stuck that filthy needle in here,” sung as the quartet points at the man’s arm, or through unprotected sex.

The full lyrics of the song are as follows:

You have AIDS.
Yes, you have AIDS.
I hate to tell you, boy, you have AIDS.
You got the AIDS.
You may have caught it when you stuck that filthy needle in here.
Or maybe all that unprotected sex which we hear.
It isn’t clear, but what we’re certain of is that you have AIDS.
Yes, you have AIDS.
Not HIV, but full-blown AIDS.
Be sure that you see that this is not HIV, but full blown AIDS.
Not HIV, but full-blown AIDS.
I’m sorry, I wish it was something less serious, but it’s AIDS.
You’ve got the AIDS.

The episode was written by Family Guy writers Patrick Henry and Mike Henry, and directed by James Purdum.

Fox officials defended airing and rerunning the episode, saying Family Guy intends to push the boundaries of good taste through its brand of insult-laden humor and that the show has targeted many demographic groups, not just HIV-positive people.

“Over the years, Family Guy has skewered virtually every ethnic, religious, and social group,” says Fox spokesman Steven Melnick. “The audience that tunes into this series is well-aware of what to expect from the show--a subversive and sometimes shocking comedic view that occasionally skirts the borders of appropriateness. This scene is not a joke about HIV but rather Peter’s ignorance and inability to convey bad news. Given the nature of this series as well as the well-established cluelessness of this particular character, the scene--while certainly abrasive--is not beyond the expectation of the Family Guy audience.”

But AIDS groups aren’t amused. And they’re not buying Fox’s defense of the show, saying that joking about a disease that affects more than 40 million people worldwide, most of whom will die of the ailment, is reprehensible and serves only to worsen AIDS-related stigma.

“A barbershop quartet singing blithely about AIDS is about as funny as a song about breast cancer or leukemia, especially to the people living with the disease,” says AIDS Project Los Angeles executive director Craig E. Thompson. “It is inexcusable for Fox to air a program that stigmatizes AIDS and less than subtly reinforces homophobia. It should be socially unacceptable to see this kind of garbage passing for entertainment in 2005.”

David Munar, associate director of the AIDS Foundation of Chicago, says that while Family Guy may have been attempting to use dark humor to show the inappropriateness of delivering bad news through a song-and-dance number, that message might have been lost due to the subject matter of the song. “The risk, of course, is that some viewers might not get the joke and believe that AIDS has become a casual, laughing matter,” he says.

Both the AIDS Institute, based in Washington, D.C., and Philadelphia’s ActionAIDS believe Fox and Family Guy officials owe HIV-positive people--and all those working in the AIDS arena--an apology for suggesting that becoming infected with HIV or developing AIDS is funny.

“The portrayal of HIV/AIDS on Family Guy was irresponsible,” says AIDS Institute executive director Gene Copello. “There is nothing comical about a person lying in a hospital bed dying of AIDS or any other disease. Fox owes people living with HIV/AIDS and their families an immediate apology.”

Kevin Burns, executive director of ActionAIDS, says, “It is disturbing that Fox television would take such a cavalier approach to the subject of HIV/AIDS and the difficult task of informing someone of an AIDS diagnosis. Fox owes the community an apology. In addition, they should consider the many opportunities they have to support people living with HIV/AIDS and to educate the larger community about HIV/AIDS treatment, care, and prevention.”

Fox officials did not respond to requests for additional comments.

Reader Comments

These comments are reproduced as written by visitors to this Web site. They have not been edited for content, grammar, or spelling. The viewpoints appearing here are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or views of advocate.com, The Advocate, or its affiliates.

  • Name: GG Allin
    Date posted: 2008-07-01 8:50 PM
    Hometown: NYC

    Comment:

    Gay people get AIDS? I thought it was a needle thing. Oh well. I am off to see my lover Gaetan Dugas now. He is SOOOOO hot!


  • Name: Sung Dude
    Date posted: 2008-06-26 6:41 AM
    Hometown: Los Angeles

    Comment:

    This article is really reaching to portray the young man as gay. If Mr. Adams had paid attention, he would have noticed that the doctor in the scene said "I don't know how to tell you this, Mr. Devanney..." Tom Devanney was (is?) a staff writer for Family Guy. It's in the credits. Another writer, Mark Hentemann, has also appeared on the show (as himself, that is, although he has voiced other characters). Aside from being utterly lazy research (thus reprehensible on a strictly professional level), claims supported this poorly only make gay media seem alarmist and confused. There was nothing to specifically imply that the young man was gay, and a strong case suggesting it was an inside joke; the in group in this case is people who can read and hold their hypotheses until they have all the facts. also, this is hilarious, and it's possible to laugh at it while recognizing the gravity of the situation (not to mention the difference between cartoons and real life).


  • Name: badingers
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 4:15 AM
    Hometown: brookfields

    Comment:

    gays and AIDS are funny. even without family guy.


  • Name: Armatiage
    Date posted: 2008-06-05 8:35 PM
    Hometown: Dunwich

    Comment:

    Tbh I think the AIDs groups have found an anthem :-p and the song off Team America to a lesser extent ;-)


  • Name: Erin
    Date posted: 2008-05-26 12:59 AM
    Hometown: Tampa

    Comment:

    Honestly, the whole point of the little bit was to laugh . To live and yet laugh I say. We have too much fear and seriousness in our society we tend to forget to laugh. I believe the direction that Family Guy was heading for was to laugh into the face of AIDS. Sure, it was funny and perhaps a bit cruel, but to come think of it , we all need to laugh and breathe.


  • Name: Francisco
    Date posted: 2008-05-14 10:03 AM
    Hometown: Neutral Zone

    Comment:

    Oh, BTW, "The man is also depicted as young and sporting a goatee, possibly subtly suggesting that he is gay." Because ALL gays sport goatees. SERIOUSLY!


  • Name: Mimi
    Date posted: 2008-05-13 8:50 PM
    Hometown: Toms River

    Comment:

    People really need to give it up. One cannot expect that the show is going to sensor its humor. Family guy pokes fun at every and someone is bound to be offended but that is COMEDY. If we were to sensor all offensive material, there would be no TV, no music, no radio, no computer, no books, nothing. Get over it and laugh a little.


  • Name: Eck
    Date posted: 2008-05-13 8:19 PM
    Hometown: Martinsville

    Comment:

    People should be perpetually somber and apologetic to groups, not only affected by HIV or AIDS, but to all diseased people as well, treated like a charity case is exactly what these people want. Why stop there? Because Family guy chooses not to discriminate against who they offend, it only makes sense that we start treating different races or gender like it's "No Laughing matter". Sure I may be a little biased because I like funny things (see: Commedy), and am a member of SPEBSQSA, but Fransisco has the right idea, they are still people who have a right to be happy just like everyone else.


  • Name: Francisco
    Date posted: 2008-05-13 7:35 PM
    Hometown: Neutral Zone

    Comment:

    I'm gay, I'm HIV positive, and I find this song incredibly hilarious. Being trated like a dying person sucks; when I get aids, I want someone to sing this song to me. IT'S NOT TREATING AIDS LIGHTLY; IT'S LIVING WITH HUMOUR. We need it, for real!


  • Name: Worthy Evans
    Date posted: 2008-05-09 11:14 AM
    Hometown: Columbia, SC

    Comment:

    I'll say. After watching that episode I went out and tried to get the AIDS myself. The barbershop quartet didn't show up like I had expected. I guess that I should never fall for gallows humor. And never laugh.


Back to top

Submit a comment for this story:

*Type your comment here (Required, 1000 characters max.):

*Name (Required): 

*Hometown (Required): 

*E-mail address: (Required, but will not be displayed)

Is this comment for publication? 
Yes   No

Daytime phone number: (Required for print publication only and will not be displayed)

Please enter the words you see in the box, in order and separated by a space. Doing so helps prevent automated programs from abusing this service.

  

If you would like to submit a comment for posting, please fill out the form above. 

All comments submitted via this form are subject to posting or publication. (To send a private letter to an Advocate editor or writer, please use the e-mail button at the top of the page, or use snail mail.) If you would like your comment considered for publication in The Advocate magazine, please include your full name, your city of residence, and a phone number where you can be reached during business hours so that we can confirm your identity. Your e-mail address and telephone number are strictly confidential and will not be shared or used for any purpose other than to contact you about your comment.

Comments that do not concern specific articles in The Advocate or on Advocate.com will not be posted or published. See the Contact page for sending comments for reasons other than responding to Advocate editorial and news stories.

Please note that comments sent by fax or snail mail are unlikely to be posted, although they will be considered for publication along with all letters received via e-mail or via this Web page. Comments that chiefly concern Advocate.com content will be considered for posting only on the Web site. The Advocate reserves the right to edit submitted comments for grammar, spelling, obscenities, or libel; we will, however, do our best to preserve the original comment's style and intent. Comments considered for publication in The Advocate magazine may also be edited for length.

More Exclusives
  • Police Woman
    Long before Sam Adams made waves as Portland, Ore.'s gay mayor, the macho world of Oregon police enforcement was crashed by lesbian Jennifer Bills
  • Phair Play
    Fifteen years after the release of her revolutionary album Exile in Guyville, Liz Phair performs all of the album's 18 tracks in Chicago -- with mixed results
  • Aloha From Hawaii
    Advocate.com correspondent Job Brother takes a look at Starwood Hotels' newest property on Kauai and some of the resort group's recently remodeled gems on Oahu.
  • She Still Bops
    With Cyndi Lauper and a who's who of queer and queer-friendly talent, the True Colors tour is entertainment for all orientations and all generations.
  • State of the Unions
    Searching for the perfect tux? Wondering what you need to know to tie the knot? Look no further. The Advocate has joined forces with our friends at Out to bring you a comprehensive guide to all things marriage.
  • Obama Woos Clinton Donors, LGBTs Included
    Sen. Barack Obama meets with Hillary Clinton's donors in D.C. on Thursday, but the campaign's efforts to romance Clinton's LGBT fund-raisers is still finding its groove.
  • I'm a Dad
    Actor, singer, and all-around entertainer Sam Harris talks about his journey of adoption and the joys of taking on his latest title: father.
  • Good Golly, Miss Molly
    Molly Ringwald discusses her new ABC Family series, her daughter's gay godfather, her obsession with eBay, and why Andie could never have ended up with Duckie
  • Provincetown Film Festival
    Jane Lynch, Alan Ball, and John Waters descend on the Cape. Will Henderson gives us the queer highlights from this year's festival.
  • Hair Apparent
    Jaclyn Smith on the success Bravo’s Shear Genius, her Angel years and the quest to gain more inner strength
  • Katy Perry Isn't One of the Boys
    With a number 1 single just around the corner and Madonna among her fan base, Katy Perry's two gay songs have made her a pop sensation.
  • The Gay Goodfellas
    Inside the Gill Action Fund, the most effective pro-gay political weapon you never heard of.
  • Obama And One-Man, One-Woman Marriage
    Sen. Obama reminded us this week that he believes marriage is between a man and a woman, something LGBT people might have easily forgotten over the course of the primary.
  • The Whole World Is Watching
    The media spotlight turned to California last week as the first marriages were performed. Although for the most part it was a rare glimpse at the human angle of our battle, sometimes their silence spoke louder than words
  • The Godfather of Electro-pop
    Former Depeche Mode and Erasure member Vince Clarke reunites with bandmate Alison Moyet this summer for a Yaz reunion tour. The straight man to some pretty gay acts tells us why he stopped singing, what broke Yazoo up, and why the future of electro-pop music may be monkey brains
  • It's The Economy, Stupid
    California's non-partisan Legislative Analyst Office is studying the economic impact of a state ballot measure that would ban same-sex marriages. Will the findings sway voters in the fall?