Scroll To Top

25 Gay Men Could Have Been Killed by Indiana Serial Killer

Herb Baumeister
Herb Baumeister; Screengrab via WISH

Herb Baumeister was believed to have coerced young gay men back to this house before killing them.

NOBLESVILLE, Indiana (WISH) -- Bones found in the 1990s on Fox Hallow Farms in Westfield are linked to Herb Baumeister, the man largely considered Indiana's most prolific serial killer.

In 1996, authorities found only 11 DNA profiles among the bones and identified eight of the men.

Now, that total of DNA profiles could rise to about 25 men with new testing of the bones.

Jeff Jellison, who takes office in January as the new Hamilton County coroner, said DNA technology has advanced, and it is time to identify the rest of the men.

"The search produced more than probably 10,000 bones and bone fragments," Jellison said. "We believe there are as many as 25 individuals that were recovered from that property. So from that initial find, there were 11 DNA samples identified. Eight of those people were actually matched to DNA samples and were actually identified. There are still three remaining DNA samples that were not matched to anyone."

The Hamilton County Coroner's Office is partnering with the University of Indianapolis Archeology and Forensic Lab to sort the 10,000 bones and fragments to determine which ones can be used to create additional DNA profiles.

"We've identified approximately 100 bones that are viable for DNA extraction. Many of these bones are very, very small, small as a fingernail, because they were crushed. Many of the longer bones were burnt before they were discarded, so DNA may not exist in those bones."

Baumeister was believed to have coerced young men in Indianapolis gay bars to return to his Westfield house before killing them. He took his own life before law enforcement could arrest him.

Jellison said, "We know we have a couple of people that we believe are in that group of bones, and we have been able to track down family members from them. Through our investigators, through my deputies, through law enforcement, we'll go to work."

The coroner-elect is stressing the need for anyone with a male relative or friend missing from the 1980s to mid-1990s in Indiana or other states to come forward and give a DNA sample or a tip to help the investigation.

"When you look at the middle '80s to middle '90s, family members didn't know maybe that their relative was gay. So you have to take 'gay' out of this equation, and, if you had someone missing, a male individual in your family that was missing middle '80s to middle '90s, I need you to come forward, and we don't know that all of these people were gay, so we do know that they are male."

Jellison said getting a sample from a family member is painless.

"We can get DNA from a bone, but if we don't have something to match that to our efforts, (they) go nowhere," Jellison said. "So if someone had a loved one go missing in that time, I need them to come forward and give a DNA sample. It's very simple. It's just swabbing someone's cheek."

The investigation would not be happening without Jellison's dedication. He said he wants to bring closure and give the men a final resting place. He said he cannot fully explain why this investigation took so long to pick back up.

"I can't answer that. I know I've spoken with previous coroners and all of them have said, 'Yes, we should have done something like this.' I think manpower was a big prohibitive factor at that time.

"I mean this is huge. This is a big investigation that's going to take quite some time and a lot of manpower, and our office didn't quite have the manpower to do that.

"I tell people these people were forgotten, but they're not forgotten any longer."

(tm) & (c) 2022 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.

Related: Conviction in Gay-Bashing Murder of Scott Johnson Overturned

30 Years of Out100Out / Advocate Magazine - Jonathan Groff & Wayne Brady

From our Sponsors

Most Popular

Latest Stories

Danielle Zulkosky