Skip to content
Search AI Powered

Latest Stories

Who’s behind America’s anti-trans bills? A new archive lets you follow the paper trail

What began as a spreadsheet of anti-LGBTQ+ legislation grew into an archive of hearing videos, campaign ads, and more than 500 court cases.

a server farm

A new digital archive lets users search for anti-trans legislation.

Envato

One of the hardest parts of keeping a record of transgender life in America is getting the names right. Ahead of Friday’s Transgender Day of Remembrance, Advocates for Trans Equality identified 62 trans people in the United States who died over the past year, including 28 who were killed. The group says the count is incomplete in part because families, police and news outlets sometimes misidentify trans people after they die.

Civil rights attorney Alejandra Caraballo has spent much of this year working on a different part of the public record. When a politician invokes transgender people in a campaign ad, sponsors a bill restricting their rights or votes to pass it, that history can be remarkably hard to piece together. The ad lives in one archive, the bill on a state website, the hearing in hours of committee video. If someone sues, the next chapter unfolds on a court docket.


The Trans Data Initiative, announced November 9, brings those records together in a free national archive. Caraballo, a trans woman who teaches at Harvard Law School’s Cyberlaw Clinic, built it with a team that had already spent years tracking LGBTQ+ legislation by hand.

“You can find that legislator and then see every other bill that they’ve sponsored related to trans issues,” Caraballo tells The Advocate. “And then you can also see where they’ve spoken in hearings and what they’ve said.”

How a bill travels

The project began with what Caraballo calls “a glorified spreadsheet.” She and fellow trackers Allison Chapman, Erin Reed and Liz Saila assembled a legislative history stretching back to the fights over marriage equality. Saila, the team’s archivist, still reviews bills individually, recording what each would do and whether it would restrict or expand trans people’s rights, according to Caraballo.

By late October, Caraballo says, the team had cataloged about 8,900 measures dating to 2003. She had matched roughly 1,000 hearing videos to bills and selected more than 500 court cases for the database. She says she covered the project’s expenses herself.

One way to follow a bill is to follow a sentence. The archive compares legislation eight words at a time and flags groups of at least three bills that share substantial passages. A local reporter who recognizes a line in a new bill can compare the wording across states, then ask the sponsor where it came from.

What stays private

The harder question was what to do about the parent who appears at a single hearing. A committee video may have been public for years. Making a parent’s testimony searchable from anywhere changes who can find that family and how much effort it takes.

The public site names lawmakers and experts hired to defend restrictions. Its hearing pages link to official videos but omit searchable transcripts. The team says it withholds private individuals’ names from its own records, checks each release for information that should stay private and accepts requests to take material down.

The invitation-only version gives approved researchers access to a fuller collection. Journalists, academics and advocates can request an invitation by identifying themselves, their affiliation and what they hope to learn. The team decides whom to admit.

“When you collate it and collect it all into one easy, searchable, usable database, suddenly you’ve lowered the barrier of entry for people to use it and then potentially use it in malicious ways,” Caraballo says.

FROM OUR SPONSORS

More For You