BY Advocate Contributors
October 16 2010 1:55 PM ET
In his declaration to the court, Stanley argues, “Changing the policy will also require the writing of new policies and regulations by the relevant components within DoD and the Services based on those recommendations; and the conducting of education and training programs for servicemembers and commanders. These items cannot be fully developed for implementation until the Working Group's recommendations are presented to the Secretary of Defense, and the Secretary makes decisions about those recommendations. It is not possible to determine now, prior to the report's completion, precisely how long that process will take, but this entire process will likely take some number of months.”
In fact there are very few policies or regulations that will need to be changed or updated. The ones that will need to be changed will largely only require deleting the sections that relate to investigations and discharges of gays and lesbians. The military already has very robust equal opportunity and diversity training programs; these merely need to be updated to include sexual orientation.
Stanley mentions a survey that has gone out to 400,000 service members to solicit their input on this issue, as part of the efforts of the working group. He argues the Pentagon must have time to analyze the data and take into account the results. What he doesn’t mention is there has been extremely low response to this survey, largely because service members are apathetic about gays and lesbians serving openly. In other words, our men and women in the military today have far more important issues to worry about than who someone loves.
The survey itself established a bad precedent because the military is not a democracy. Surveys are not conducted asking our troops if they want to go to war, or if they want to spend another Christmas away from their families. Surveys of this scale were not conducted when the military was racially integrated, or when women were admitted to the service academies in 1976, or most recently this year when the Navy announced it would integrate women onto submarines.
The United Kingdom found its military in a similar situation a decade ago. The European Court of Human Rights ordered the British military to abolish its policy of discrimination against gays and lesbians. Instead of appealing the decision or requesting a delay, the British Ministry of Defense immediately complied with the court’s ruling and virtually overnight changed its policy to allow gays and lesbians to serve openly. It issued a policy of zero-tolerance of discrimination based upon sexual orientation and established a code of social conduct, applicable to all personnel, that is still in effect today. The Ministry of Defense formally lifted its gay ban on January 12, 2000, within four months of the September court ruling, and invited ousted troops to reapply for service.
Stanley goes on to assert that an immediate suspension of the DADT law “will cause significant disruptions to the force in the short term and, in the long term, would likely undermine the effectiveness of any transition to accepting open service by gays and lesbians in the event the law is repealed or eliminated.”
What he doesn’t say is that the Pentagon has already publicly stated it will abide the judge’s orders and stop all investigations and discharges, effective immediately. It has been four days since Judge Phillips issued her ruling and the Pentagon has not crumbled, nor has the sky fallen. There have not been mass gatherings or demonstrations of gays and lesbians declaring their sexual orientation, nor will there be once DADT is truly history. This underlies the fact that sexual orientation is a highly personal and private matter. Gay and lesbian service members will come out in their own time, in their own way to people they trust; many will remain silent about their orientation.
Stanley served honorably as a Marine Corps officer for 33 years. Yet he is relying too much on his personal background as a Marine and not enough on the wealth of research material that demonstrates there is no military necessity to discriminate against gays and lesbians. Even the 1993 RAND report to the Pentagon stated such, yet this report was buried and never made its way into the Congressional hearings that year. Stanley is also of a generation that largely does not support the repeal of DADT. It has been nearly half a century since he first joined the military, and much has changed in our nation and our armed forces since then. The generation of young men and women joining the military now largely don’t care about sexual orientation. They’ve grown up with gays and lesbians in their schools, sports teams, communities, and certainly in their military.
There is no valid reason the Pentagon should further delay implementation of Judge Phillips’s decision. To do so creates unnecessary administrative and bureaucratic delay and continues to weaken our national security. The men and women serving our armed forces are professional and mature enough to deal with this change a few months earlier than anticipated. The military is good at following orders and with strong leadership from the highest levels, this issue is no exception.
Maj. Mike Almy was discharged from the U.S. Air Force under "don't ask, don't tell" in 2006. He testified in the Log Cabin Republicans federal trial in July challenging the policy.
- Op-ed: Adopting the T in LGBT
- Schumer Admits Reason He Left Gays Out of Immigration 'Provides Little Comfort'
- Does Expansion of Rights Also Expand Antigay Violence?
- A Reason for Pride: Gay Parents Are Changing the World
- Multiple Attacks on Gay Men in NYC, Hours After Rally
- Op-ed: My Life as a Gay Boy Scout
Sign Up For Email Updates
- Commentary NYC Hate Crimes: Why I'm Afraid for First Time in My Life 1 min 36 sec ago
- Women WATCH: Portia de Rossi Spills Ellen's Most Annoying Habit to Jennifer Aniston 24 min 39 sec ago
- Living Well Why Shacking Up Is Good For Your Health 30 min 42 sec ago
- Politics Schumer: The Reason We Excluded Gays Offers 'Little Comfort' 1 hour 26 min ago
- World News PHOTOS: Startling Response to Right-Winger's Suicide in Notre Dame 1 hour 56 min ago
- Crime Does Expansion of Rights Also Expand Antigay Violence? 2 hours 48 min ago
- Film New Man Of Steel and Wolverine Trailers Debut 9:03 AM