Issue Number 1005 | Labor of Love | Advocate.com Labor of Love  | First Person | Advocate.com

Continental promo
|| Home > First Person  ||
 

Labor of Love

Is society ready for this pregnant husband?
From The Advocate  April 8, 2008
 Labor of Love

To our neighbors, my wife, Nancy, and I don’t appear in the least unusual. To those in the quiet Oregon community where we live, we are viewed just as we are -- a happy couple deeply in love. Our desire to work hard, buy our first home, and start a family was nothing out of the ordinary. That is, until we decided that I would carry our child.

I am transgender, legally male, and legally married to Nancy. Unlike those in same-sex marriages, domestic partnerships, or civil unions, Nancy and I are afforded the more than 1,100 federal rights of marriage. Sterilization is not a requirement for sex reassignment, so I decided to have chest reconstruction and testosterone therapy but kept my reproductive rights. Wanting to have a biological child is neither a male nor female desire, but a human desire.

Ten years ago, when Nancy and I became a couple, the idea of us having a child was more dream than plan. I always wanted to have children. However, due to severe endometriosis 20 years ago, Nancy had to undergo a hysterectomy and is unable to carry a child. But after the success of our custom screen-printing business and a move from Hawaii to the Pacific Northwest two years ago, the timing finally seemed right. I stopped taking my bimonthly testosterone injections. It had been roughly eight years since I had my last menstrual cycle, so this wasn’t a decision that I took lightly. My body regulated itself after about four months, and I didn’t have to take any exogenous estrogen, progesterone, or fertility drugs to aid my pregnancy.

Page: 1 | 2 | 3

Reader Comments

These comments are reproduced as written by visitors to this Web site. They have not been edited for content, grammar, or spelling. The viewpoints appearing here are those of the writer, and do not necessarily reflect the opinion or views of advocate.com, The Advocate, or its affiliates.

  • Name: Joanna
    Date posted: 2009-06-28 9:14 AM
    Hometown: Socorro, NM

    Comment:

    While I appreciate other's spiritual beliefs I don'nt happen to agree that the "you will be condemned to hell" nature of comment is of any value in a discussion like this one. As a preop trans woman I am envious of your ability to do something I will never be able to do. Since many dont seem to understand why you would do this and for some reason see this as a some kind of an abomination I would suggest that those who would sling stones make sure that they are without sin (no human is). Congratulations, and I hope the birth goes well.


  • Name: stephanie
    Date posted: 2009-06-27 12:39 PM
    Hometown: san diego

    Comment:

    I believe that human beings sort of expected this to happen because now a days anything is pretty much possible. I just think its wrong that men are being pregnant. Men and women are ment to be one way & I believe that no one has the right to change that, even if you believe it could be a beautiful experience. I think that only women should be allowed to have children. If there's pregnant men now, what can we expect next.


  • Name: Kristin
    Date posted: 2009-06-26 11:50 PM
    Hometown: Maine

    Comment:

    Inspirational story, even for a heterosexual couple to hear. Thank you for being so brave, not only to give birth to a child, but also to be public. We wish you the best!


  • Name: Anonymous
    Date posted: 2009-06-26 2:06 PM
    Hometown: United States

    Comment:

    Why couldn't you just adopt a child?? So many children need loving care, but instead you had to spend thousands and thousands of dollars bringing another child into the world and stirring up controversy and hardship for yourselves. I don't have a problem with it, but don't pretend that you weren't looking to make a statement and get a little fame out of it.


  • Name: Barb
    Date posted: 2009-06-12 2:23 PM
    Hometown: Sacramento

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy, congratulations on the birth of your second child. May he be healthy, and may your family be happy and well. All of your children are lucky to have you as their father and mother - to have parents who love so much is the best chance any child can have. To those who continue to spew hatred and condemnation in the name of God, maybe you should stop and take a step back, and stop making His decisions for Him. Thomas and Nancy's children are gifts FROM God. That Thomas was able to carry and give birth to them is a gift from God. May He forgive YOU for your irrational hatred and vicious cruelty.


  • Name: Carol
    Date posted: 2009-06-11 10:51 AM
    Hometown: Nairobi

    Comment:

    Hi Tracy and Susan, May be you feel that you have already sinned / made so many mistakes that your sins cannot be forgiven. Your mistakes are so small compared to what God has in store for you if you repent. Jesus is ready to forgive you however dirty you are feeling right now. Please reconsider what He did for you on the cross at calvary. He suffered and died for your sins. Please repent and accept Jesus Christ as your saviour and your souls will not be tormented in Hell forever. Anyone who dies unsaved goes straight to Hell where his/her soul tormented day and night. Please do not risk another minute without Jesus Christ. He loves you so much. Just accept him pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeeeee. Repent now and get saved for the eternal torment and fire!!!!!!


  • Name: Carol
    Date posted: 2009-06-11 10:37 AM
    Hometown: Nairobi

    Comment:

    Hi guys, It seems most human beings have already forgotten why sodom and gomora were destroyed. They were destroyed because of immorarity like homosexuality. The same God who destroyed Sodom and gomora will not accept anyone unholy in heaven. I'm not trying to scare you Thomas and Susan. What I'm trying to say is that you will be thrown to HELL and after the day of judgement into the LAKE OF FIRE with the devil and his angels if you do not repent, separate and start living normal lives like God intended when He created Adam and Eve. You still have a chance now to REPENT. Pls REPENT...... and no matter what you have done, God will forgive you. He forgives, murderers, robbers, etc and He also can forgive you if you REPENT and accept JESUS CHRIST as your personal Saviour! Its not too late.


  • Name: Chris Fleming
    Date posted: 2009-06-08 12:43 AM
    Hometown: Manchester

    Comment:

    I feel obligated to respond after reading some of the responses to this most remarkable article. Why does it seem that the deepest love and devotion dredges up the darkest depths of human thought? I would count myself fulfilled to even pass someone on the street with that kind of love in their heart. Yet society, and even the closest of relatives, are actively trying to destroy this purest display of devotion. And why? Because it doesn't fit into their tiny view of the world. Society is too terrified to look away from their keyhole view of the world, as, in doing so, they may find that they are wrong, that the world isn't exactly the way they think it is. The article asks if society is ready for this. It is not now, nor has it ever been society's decision to make. That decision lies solely in the hands of two so devoted to each other that they would take on the world to be able to show their love for each other and for those that will come after.


  • Name: Fingers crossed?
    Date posted: 2009-06-01 4:18 AM
    Hometown: Over here

    Comment:

    Well, good luck with that. That is all.


  • Name: Ciline McCalloway
    Date posted: 2009-05-27 11:16 PM
    Hometown: Forks

    Comment:

    OK ok this is nice and all but pregnacy is the ONLY thing that women have that men CAN't have, why take that away? (Even though he isn't even a REAL man)


  • Name: Victoria
    Date posted: 2009-05-25 7:50 PM
    Hometown: NOLA

    Comment:

    IS THERE ANY WAY TO CONTACT NANCY AND THOMAS? PLEASE LET ME KNOW.


  • Name: Jana
    Date posted: 2009-05-23 11:49 AM
    Hometown: Denver Colorado

    Comment:

    What makes a good, loving, supportive and respectful environment for raising a child? Adults that are good, loving, supportive and respectful. Nancy and Thomas Beatie are in such a relationship and their kids are lucky to have them as parents. Why this situation is raising such hatred and prejudice is beyond me when you can hear of parents in the news that are abusing and killing their offspring with no thought or consciousness. I'm a single mother of a toddler and I support the Beaties in their efforts to produce a family in love, no matter what the means necessary.


  • Name: Daniel Urdaneta
    Date posted: 2009-05-13 1:51 PM
    Hometown: Schaumburg, IL

    Comment:

    can't imagine how's sex between that couple xD


  • Name: T.J.
    Date posted: 2009-05-07 12:46 AM
    Hometown: P'cola, FL

    Comment:

    I agree with Susan. The female reproductive organs were kept, and though their continued intended function after steady testosterone injections is somewhat interesting, what I had in mind being linked to this page was of a born-physiologically-male person carrying a zygote/fetus/infant within. Kind of a letdown, though the story was alright (and jeebus, what jumble in the first attempt!).


  • Name: Susan
    Date posted: 2009-05-04 11:42 PM
    Hometown: DC, USA

    Comment:

    I have to admit, I am very disappointed. Yes, it's wonderful that Thomas took advantage of his old plumbing to have this baby. Big, big deal - the womb was there - nothing special! Nothing like a born-guy gestating - THAT would be newsworthy!


  • Name: Mike
    Date posted: 2009-05-04 10:35 PM
    Hometown: Va

    Comment:

    Alright, I've had enough of this. Advocate, you seriously need to fix your comment interface. Half the time the server doesn't even receive the posts, which throws everything out of order, and your character limit grates against any attempt to frame a complete, coherent thought. Plus the lack of line spaces makes everything difficult to read on the off chance that a post is worth reading. This is probably for the best, as I suppose people were getting tired of my pretension anyway.


  • Name: Mike
    Date posted: 2009-05-04 10:29 PM
    Hometown: Va

    Comment:

    In addition to sex being less simple than many would like to believe, gender is even more complex. Sex is physiological, while gender is generally held to be psychological. (If an expert in the readership should find me wrong on this point, please correct me. The entire point of this long, arduous post is to facilitate dialogue and learning.) And if there's one thing we don't understand about humans, it's the brain. Gender carries a whole host of social expectations, because it is at least loosely tied to sex for the majority of the population. However, nowhere is it written that gender and sex must match up to one another perfectly for every human being. Think about how many men you know who dislike sports, or aren't good at fixing cars. Think about how many women you know who can't walk in heels, or hate wearing makeup.


  • Name: Mike
    Date posted: 2009-05-04 10:23 PM
    Hometown: Va

    Comment:

    "Do have a problem with her getting her 15 minutes of fame with what I see as helping to destroy the strides gays, lesbians, cross dressers, and transgender's have made." Interesting opinion. What strides do you think have been destroyed by this? My thinking is that by bringing this into the open, we force people to think about sex/gender dichotomies and provoke dialogue in the public arena. I feel like any temporary backlash is worth having planted these seeds.


  • Name: Mike
    Date posted: 2009-05-04 10:22 PM
    Hometown: Va

    Comment:

    "A penis with testicles that have SPERM in them is what makes a man." So Lance Armstrong is half a man? Someone who's had a vasectomy or a full castration, as birth control or to forestall the spread of testicular cancer, is not a man at all? What about someone who has functioning testicles, but lost the penis in some kind of accident? Your definitions are lacking. "Oh, come on.. if you wanted to be a man you would've gone all the way, reproductive organs and all. You're a shame to the GLBT community! You should've just stayed a lesbian." No, it's the other way around. The whole idea of a community is to band together for common purpose and support one another in the face of adversity. Specifically, to oppose the rigid notions of sex, gender, and orientation imposed by society. You are shaming the queer community by merely substituting another set of rigid, arbitrary rules.


  • Name: Mike
    Date posted: 2009-05-04 10:20 PM
    Hometown: Va

    Comment:

    "Good luck to the child...it will need all the help it can get." I used to worry myself about how kids in this situation would be treated by their peers. But here's what you need to understand: these are two people who have gone to incredible lengths to conceive and raise a child. This is most definitely a wanted child, coming into a stable and loving home. It boggles my mind that people can call that sick or unnatural. Of the children born to straight couples, a staggering percentage of them don't have it this good. People also contend that a lack of concrete gender roles will be detrimental to the kid's development. Well, are there any laws dictating that a particularly masculine woman or a particularly feminine man, as part of a straight couple, would be incapable of properly contributing to a child's upbringing?


  • Name: Mike
    Date posted: 2009-05-04 10:11 PM
    Hometown: Va

    Comment:

    Forgive me if I do not reply to every negative comment individually, but I'd like to address some of the main points that have been brought up. And yes, I know that this is the internet; I won't take myself too seriously, and I'll try to avoid sarcasm because that sort of thing always gets scrambled in translation. "I understand your desire to have a biological child - but you are putting yourself in a situation that society is not ready to deal with." On the contrary, I see this as brave rather than insane. Society doesn't change on its own; it requires individuals to push the envelope in order to redefine our collective preconceptions. Society will never be able to 'deal with' this until it has examples placed before it, whether it is ready or not.


  • Name: Mandy
    Date posted: 2009-04-19 11:35 PM
    Hometown: Memphis, TN

    Comment:

    I am just now hearing about your story as I'm watching your special on the DHC(Discovery Health Channel), and I just want to voice my support, not only for your endeavor, but for your courage in sharing such an intimate part of your life. Fear not what others think, all a child needs to know in this world is that it was brought into being from love. Who really cares how it got here, although your story is phenomenal. I believe that Susan Juliette will grow up with negative comments about her existence, but I believe that she will be proud that her parents were bold enough to do what it took to give her life, love, and a home. That is what is important, not the fact that you used to be a woman, that is a trivial fact that has nothing to do with her existence. Your prior gender has nothing to do with love and family. You have my moral support 100%. May everyone be as strong as you.:)


  • Name: Emilio
    Date posted: 2009-04-19 7:35 PM
    Hometown: Kansas City

    Comment:

    Greetings from K.C.! Hey, I know I'm only one person but take this for what it is. I'm only 15 and I've been through my own crap in life. It's a hard road. But I've come to discover certain things. For example, everyone has a natural pull to be wanted. Everyone wants to serve a purpose. I believe everyone has one. We all fill a place. You are both incredible, kind-hearted people and you've both earned my respect. Thomas, you're every right to be known as a man. Nancy, you're an incredible support. Good for you both. Peace n' love, Emilio


  • Name: Katie
    Date posted: 2009-04-19 7:26 PM
    Hometown: Honolulu

    Comment:

    I'm actually watching the show on Discovery Health Channel right now and to be honest I think that it's wonderful! I think it is such a selfless act to carry a child for a wife that is unable to do so. Who cares who will be the "mother" and who will be the "father". Parenthood is about unconditional love and support. Not about what gender they are. I have many transgender friends and I believe gender has no effect on raising a child. Gender doesn't dictate how great a parent someone will be. If it did, then why are there so many men AND women who beat, abuse, abandon and kill their own children. They are capable of raising a child. Who cares about what's "natural"? As far as I'm concerned I think its an amazing gift. Congratulations!


  • Name: Katie
    Date posted: 2009-04-08 2:33 PM
    Hometown: Los Angeles

    Comment:

    My thoughts and prayers are with you both. I have been studying pregnancy for 11 years, and I am absolutely fascinated by your story. I applaud your bravery and heroism to go out into the world with your story, and I have been following it from day one. All of the videos of you that are on Youtube, I have subscribed to, as well as other pregnancy videos. I love your story, and I disagree with all the others who think that this is repulsive. It's a beautiful thing to bring another life into this world, and I just have one thing to say to them: LEAVE THIS POOR MAN ALONE!!!!! If you were in his shoes, would you want people to be doing that to you? I doubt it. I wish both of you the best of luck, and a happy life with your children.


  • Name: Ed Green
    Date posted: 2009-04-03 3:23 PM
    Hometown: Skegness

    Comment:

    Man there is a lot of ignorance in some of these comments. What makes a person male or female is their perception: that's why we have different words "gender" and "sex". Sex is a physical characteristic and has nothing to do with identity. Do your research, please, those people who said "she is a woman". Wrong pronoun, wrong gender.


  • Name: windy
    Date posted: 2009-03-28 1:43 PM
    Hometown: Honolulu Hawaii

    Comment:

    ALOHA Nancy and Thomas..... I want you to know that Honolulu, Hawaii is on your side.... I am a one part of a gay couple and I know the difficulties you face..... good luck to you all..... and congrats....


  • Name: Cait
    Date posted: 2009-03-27 5:53 PM
    Hometown: Bexley

    Comment:

    Kinda hilarious to read through the comments and watch for spelling, grammar, and punctuation. People with brains are on your side, Nancy and Thomas. Best of luck.


  • Name: Angela
    Date posted: 2009-03-25 2:14 AM
    Hometown: Carson City

    Comment:

    I just wanted to let Nancy and Thomas know that I am one of their supporters and I am very sorry that much of the world is being so closeminded and cruel. What other people think about you does not matter. Just be happy and enjoy your wonderful family. I wish Nancy and Thomas the best!


  • Name: Kathy
    Date posted: 2009-03-25 12:23 AM
    Hometown: Houston

    Comment:

    I am extremely supportive of Nancy and Thomas. I hope this opens the eyes of people who do not understand the idea of acceptance. The "norm", of which many people associate themselves with, is not the norm for many other cultures and countries. Some places do not believe in distinguishing a Male/Female role for individuals, so who are we to even speak on this subject. Why are you so concerned with what role Thomas plays in your life? Would you consider a person born as a hermaphrodite male or female? Would YOU try to make that decision for such an individual? It is not important for us, as outsiders, to judge and make assumptions for people that are living such a happy life. I hope that Thomas and Nancy have a beautiful life together with their new family. I wish the best to their child and hope happiness in their days ahead. As for the people who are leaving such nasty comments, I hope you have a happy life as well and find happiness within yourself without ridiculing others.


  • Name: Dave
    Date posted: 2009-03-24 9:24 PM
    Hometown: frankfurt

    Comment:

    I really wish people would stop calling this woman a man she is a woman who wanted to become more manly like , she is still confused you say you want to be recognized as a man yet you are carrying a baby ? go figure....Men do not get pregnant , carry nor have babies, if you were so disgusted with being a female why go and have a baby give birth ...wake up call having a baby is Woman thing , not a man thing so you are contradicting yourself .... I think you are just someone with a lot of self issues , very confused. i just hope that the child will not be if she does I guess you are prepared to spend lots of money in sending her to a therapist.


  • Name: dave
    Date posted: 2009-03-24 9:14 PM
    Hometown: frankfurt

    Comment:

    YOU are a Female and you will always be you stated that in that message you played on your cell you were threatened no I heard no one say they would hurt you they voiced their opinion , facts that you were born a woman that wanted to look like a man ,, you are a grown woman a she -he so you make your choices but as hard as you will love your child did you even stop to think how she will be confused, teased and maybe you think that is cool but see the thing is it isnt like this just happened you did this , you caused it and it's a shame because the world has enough problems as it is that your child will have to deal with why go make it more difficult?? You can convince yourself that what you did is fine to you it may be but it is not and your REAL FAMILY does not have to support your choices in life when they do not agree with them they can love you TRACY from afar .


  • Name: Dave
    Date posted: 2009-03-24 9:09 PM
    Hometown: frankfurt

    Comment:

    I agree SHE is not a HE , they asked what makes a man a man ...Well DNA genetics, yes some people are born with deformities, but this was not the case you were born a healthy beautiful girl who later chose for whatever reason to take testosterone to try to look like a man , and you do . You say that you felt like a man inside why didnt you get rid of what made you a female you can not have it both ways " I want to be a man " MEN DO NOT HAVE BABIES! you said what do people consider a man to be and you answered most people go off of appearances since when did you see a PREGNANT man walking around??? You have not.


  • Name: Becky
    Date posted: 2009-03-24 8:30 PM
    Hometown: New London

    Comment:

    I just watched your documentary on Discovery Health Channel. I think that Nancy is a very amazing woman and that Thomas is a male in every aspect. I think that what they are doing is a beautiful thing. Babies need love more than anything, and Thomas and Nancy clearly have endless amounts of it. Although there are rediculous fanatics that threaten all sorts of things, know that what you're doing is 100% natural.


  • Name: Audra Blackwood-Foladare
    Date posted: 2009-03-24 2:05 PM
    Hometown: Brooklyn, New York

    Comment:

    You are brave and determined to share your story with the world. I am extremely proud of the two of you to do what no other couple had attemped to do, let a man get pregnant. However, you showed us to open our eyes more and pay attention that not all women are unable to concieve. Does anybody look at it that way?No. You'll have my full support. AS FOR THE CLOSED MINDED SOCIETY WHO CONDEMNS ANYONE GUESS WHAT, WE DO NOT APPLY ANY LABELS TO OTHERS. NO ONE SHOULD CHASTISE ANOTHER HUMAN BEING JUST BECAUSE ONE IS DIFFERENT THAN THE OTHER. THEY ARE UNIQUE AND I ADMIRE PEOPLE LIKE THAT. UNTIL YOU ACKNOWLEDGE WHAT IS LIKE TO BE IN THEIR SHOES, OR HAS NOTHING POSITIVE TO SAY TO AND ABOUT THEM, ESPECIALLY THEIR FAMILIES WHO FAILED TO RECOGNIZE THEM. THEY ARE STILL YOUR FLESH AND BLOOD, IT WILL ALWAYS STANDS UNCHANGED.


  • Name: Christin-Edward
    Date posted: 2009-03-15 11:09 PM
    Hometown: Maryland

    Comment:

    To everyone who was so disrespectful and inconsiderate when commenting on this story, you should be ashamed of yourselves. Thomas and Nancy are doing a wonderful thing, bring life to a child, being able to support said child, and paving the way for future transgendered parents. And how dare the representatives of the transgendered community tell you to hide your pregnancy, and then lie about it! I'd like to let you know even though they are deemed representatives of us they don't represent every one. I fully support you both and cant wait for your second child's birth. I hope all goes well. Good luck♥ -Ed


  • Name: Bibi
    Date posted: 2009-03-12 7:22 PM
    Hometown: Corpus Christi

    Comment:

    PLEEEEEEESE ! get real . who are you kidding . You two lesbian have a book out there and making money off your baby. "Disgrace" yeah, that's what I thought. good luck. your gonna need luck when your baby grows up and tries to figure out what should she be? uuuuh! maybe a boy today and a girl tommow! "maybe I'll go to the prom with myself" I guess you'll be writing articles and books all your life to direct others & make as well. you are so in love with yourselves that you don't care what consequences your child will have to live with. Oh, wait a minute, you think that all this sick people who are on your side will probably be having children as you or will be telling their children and grandchildren that its ok to do as you have; therefore when your child is grown half of the world will already have a new kingdom in the world that you children will fit right in. whatever......


  • Name: Jennifer Meyer
    Date posted: 2009-03-06 10:13 AM
    Hometown: Raleigh, NC

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy, I read your story when you originally wrote it, and have watched your documentary on television since. Your courage and fortitude are to be applauded. The world can use a little bit more love and strength like yours. Congratulations on the birth of your first daughter, and I hope the birth of your second child goes as well or better. You are leading the way into a more inclusive world for all of our children. Yours, Jennifer Meyer Raleigh, NC


  • Name: Rhonda
    Date posted: 2009-02-11 3:46 AM
    Hometown: Detroit

    Comment:

    This woman is kidding herself. Legally she might be a man, hell, even in her mind she may be a man, but to go out and pedal this story to the masses is just ludicrous. There are a ton of things that are "legal" that don't make sense."Pregnant man" my ass. If you cut off your tits and grow a little facial hair that doesn't make you a man. A penis with testicles that have SPERM in them is what makes a man. I'm not saying they don't have the right to have a baby and live happy lives, but I don't appreciate the shit-sandwich they're feeding to the general public, because let's face it, people are conformist sheep and most are idiots that will buy this lie! People are all saying "this is spitting in god's face!" or "congratulations! I'm happy for you!" and all this really is is some mannish lesbian with penis envy. Don't be amazed. You can't change your DNA and she is of the XX chromosome. Deal with it. She's just another pregnant woman


  • Name: Nicole Cristelli
    Date posted: 2009-02-10 9:45 PM
    Hometown: Salem, MA

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy, I hope everything goes well for the duration of your pregnancy, and that you'll be welcoming a healthy, happy daughter into your family in July. The world could use more loving parents just like you! Your daughter will someday realize just how lucky she is. Best wishes from New England, Nicole


  • Name: Nicole Cristelli
    Date posted: 2009-02-10 9:41 PM
    Hometown: Salem, MA

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy, I sincerely hope everything goes well for you, and that you have a happy healthy daughter come July. The world needs more loving parents out there. Best Wishes from New England, Nicole


  • Name: AHauntedPoet
    Date posted: 2009-02-09 2:29 PM
    Hometown: Columbus Ohio

    Comment:

    I am apparently the last person in the universe to hear about this.... just saw the story on TLC. I say CONGRATS on the first baby, (and on the 2nd one - I googled!) and GOOD FOR YOU! The intolerant yahoos of the world can blow it out their ear. Good luck with everything and if you're ever in Ohio, stop by, I'll cook you dinner.


  • Name: Amber Hudson
    Date posted: 2009-02-09 2:27 PM
    Hometown: Lexington, TN

    Comment:

    I think it is just wonderful. After being pregnant and losing the baby, I know that having a baby is a miracle. The people that are rude to you are just jealous if you ask me. They don't have to live your life, so I don't know what their problem is. Keep your head high and be proud of something so beautiful. With lots of love from the Hudson family.


  • Name: don
    Date posted: 2009-02-09 3:43 AM
    Hometown: bend

    Comment:

    I don't watch the news so i had no idea somehting so awsome could be happening in the old cowboy town where i grew up! I am so excited! I am a born male, but your love is totally transentant of sex. my ex wife and i have two awsome boys! I just wish i could get a hold of you to take you guys to some great family spots that are on private land. and if you ever need a free ski instructor, Batchlor makes me pay anyway, so it would be an honor to ski with some good people for a couple hours and help them out where I can. my best wishes


  • Name: Elizabeth Hollander
    Date posted: 2009-02-09 2:23 AM
    Hometown: Modesto, CA

    Comment:

    TO THOMAS AND NANCY, I REALLY ADMIRE WHAT YOU ARE DOING, THERE IS NOTHING "UNNATURAL" ABOUT IT. YOU ARE TWO PEOPLE WHO WANT TO GIVE YOUR CHILD THE BEST LIFE POSSIBLE, IT DOESN'T MATTER IF YOU ARE A MAN AND A MAN, A WOMAN AND A WOMAN OR A MAN AND A WOMAN... THE ONLY THING THAT MATTERS HERE IS THAT THIS CHILD IS LOVED. I'M SURE THERE ARE PEOPLE WHO HAVE THOUGHT SURRAGACY (SP?) AND INVETRO WERE UNNATURAL AT SOME POINT, IT'S JUST GOING TO TAKE PEOPLE TO LOOK PAST THEIR IGNORANCE AND ACCEPT THE DIVERSITY IN THIS WORLD. THERE ARE SO MANY PEOPLE OUT THERE WHO HAVE CHILDREN AND DON'T TAKE CARE OF THEM, PEOPLE WHO REALLY SHOULDN'T BE PARENTS. IT REALLY MAKES ME SMILE TO SEE TWO PEOPLE SO IN LOVE AND EXCITED ABOUT PARENTHOOD. CONGRATS TO YOUR NEW FAMILY, I WISH YOU ALL THE BEST!


  • Name: Bruce Paul
    Date posted: 2009-02-09 12:28 AM
    Hometown: Coppell, Texas

    Comment:

    This is not an incredible story. A biological woman has her breasts removed and decides to live life as a man, then decides to get pregnant and have a baby. Any woman can take hormones and look like a man then stop the hormones and get pregnant. Thomas, stop kidding yourself. You are biologically a WOman having a baby. Happens every day. I have no problem with you living your life as a man and raising your child with your wife in a loving environment. But don't claim that you are a man having a baby. I watched the story on TV to see if something unusual was happening. What a joke!!! Women have babies every day. Some of them look like men. You ARE a lesbian. Good luck with your family


  • Name: Britt
    Date posted: 2009-02-09 12:27 AM
    Hometown: georgia

    Comment:

    It is apparant that Nancy and Thomas truly wanted this child and will love her. Who in there right mind would risk a lifetime of racism? Someone that truly wanted there dream, that's who. As far as those that question Thomas's gender...HE IS LEGALLY A MAN AND OUR GOVERNMENT, WHICH IS ALL OF US, SAYS HE IS. We have the right to chase our dreams as Americans. They have done nothing illegal and thus far nothing immoral. We as a government have given them this right. So whether you like it or not, you have given all of us this right when you voted. Karma is a Bitch. Today's world is not so cut and dry anymore and for those of you that seem stuck in a closed mind, my hearts go out to you. Who said god created men and women? the bible? Where is the proof? Thomas and Nancy, I give you nothing but best wishes and know that you will be okay.


  • Name: BRENDA
    Date posted: 2009-02-08 11:54 PM
    Hometown: OHIO

    Comment:

    I THINK HE IS A GREAT MAN FOR GIVING BIRTH YOU CAN TELL HE LOVES HIS WIFE NO OTHER MAN WOULD DO THAT FOR THEIR WIFE


  • Name: Heather Edwards
    Date posted: 2009-02-08 11:25 PM
    Hometown: St. Matthews, SC

    Comment:

    For those that condemn Thomas and Nancy on biblical grounds, They are the ones who will have to answer to God when their judgment day comes. NOT YOU. And the bible says, " Let he who is without sin cast the first stone". I am sure that each of you have sinned at some point in your life. We are but human, and we make mistakes. But it is God's place to judge... NOT YOU!!! To Thomas and Nancy, I hope you are finding joy in Susan Juliette. I admire your courage to find your own happiness. And what ever you do, do not let the hatefulness of small minded individuals get to you. There are a lot of us out there who admire and respect you both... God Bless


  • Name: Abbey
    Date posted: 2009-02-08 9:22 PM
    Hometown: Sioux City

    Comment:

    You say in your documentary, Pregnant Man, that you wanted to make the outside match the inside, yet you didn't. You still have a vagina and ovaries. You’re rightfully a woman, no matter how much surgery and testosterone you take. You can't change your original makeup. Real MEN DON'T GET PREGNANT because MEN don’t have vaginas! Don't you see a problem here? You cut off your breasts and kept your vagina & ovaries, yet you claim you're a man. God didn't approve this. He didn't mess up when He created you female. The Bible doesn’t say that if you don't like your sex it's okay to change it. This is not what He intended for you. You aren’t being honest with yourself or others. You're living a big lie. You've sold this lie to Oprah, who tends to ride whatever bus is moving at the time. A MAN DOESN’T HAVE OVARIES & A VAGINA. Hello! When you take away the testosterone, you once again become who you really are—a woman, right? It’s time to quit lying.


  • Name: Jessica
    Date posted: 2009-02-08 9:05 PM
    Hometown: Wahpeton

    Comment:

    I commended all men that do this. Just because someone is different doesn't mean that they are not good people. I respect what they have done. No matter what sex your parents are in life doesn't make it wrong just as long as that child is love, provided for in every way and safe thats all that matters. so i hope they have the best life possible for them.


  • Name: J
    Date posted: 2009-02-08 8:42 PM
    Hometown: California

    Comment:

    He/she is NOT a man! He was born a woman and still is because she/he still has ovaries and a uterus! He IS NOT an f-n man! I hate the fact just because he removed his breasts that makes him a man! It is disgusting...if you want to go do stuff like that than great, but do not glorify it and collect $$. God is the ultimate judge!


  • Name: Em Douglass
    Date posted: 2009-02-08 8:37 PM
    Hometown: bentonville, arkansas

    Comment:

    Dear Thomas and Nancy I do not know if you read these or not but I am hoping that you do. I admire you so much. I think what you are doing is very natural and normal and I think people who have such closed minds and can not open their views should seriously keep their mouths shut and their nose in their own business. My husband and I get looked at differently all the time because we chose to have a open relationship. I feel that this along with you chose you two have made is a chose between a man and a women not the world or God. I hope that you have has many children as you can and as many as you want. Our thoughts are with you. And if you ever need extended family you have some here in Arkansas Sincerely Yours Em Also if you two wish to contact me they may give you my e-mail address


  • Name: Emily
    Date posted: 2009-02-05 10:36 AM
    Hometown: Jacksonvaille

    Comment:

    and my best friend Andrew says....that guys who are prego are hott!


  • Name: emily
    Date posted: 2009-02-05 10:28 AM
    Hometown: jacksonville

    Comment:

    That was mean...........people can do whatever they want to do


  • Name: SICKNESS
    Date posted: 2009-02-03 10:45 PM
    Hometown: HELLYOUWILLALLBEIN

    Comment:

    this is WRONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!! OMG YOU PEOPLE ARE CRAZY AND SICK, YOU GET SO BORED SO U START TO PLAY WITH GOD AND CREATE ALLIENS! NO WONDER THIS PLACE IS FULL OF SICK MINDED PEOPLE. YOU WILL BURN IN HELL! JUST IMAGINE HOW UR CHILD WILL FEEL WHEN HE OR SHE COMES IN THIS WORLD, WHERE PEOPLE WILL TAUNT THEM AND MAKE THEM FEEL UNWELCOMED! IF YOUR WIFE CANT HAVE A CHILD THERE IS ADOPTION. THERE IS THOUSANDS OR ORPHANS IN THIS WORLD YOU SICK FUCKS! IF YOU CANT HAVE A BABY THEN DONT FORCE IT! AND ALL YOU SUPPORTING THESE SICK BASTARDS, YOU WILL BURN TOO! YOUR BORN ABNORMAL AND UR KID WILL BE BORN AS THE DEVIL WITH YOUR SICKNESS!


  • Name: Rhoda L
    Date posted: 2009-02-01 6:04 PM
    Hometown: Jackson

    Comment:

    What people say or think of my comments, is not an issue..I have read the comments posted here and quite frankly am amazed. They have ranged from "God will send you to hell" to "wishing you the best". I wish this family all the luck in the world. I am a straight mother of 4 children and what this couple is doing is wonderful. The gender issue is irrelevant to me. I believe that couples, whether gay, straight or transgender, should be able to have children of their own. Some of the most loving, open-minded children come from families that are not considered " the norm". In this day, what exactly is "the norm"? I see a Mother and a Father who will love these children and teach them values and tolerance beyond any that us "normal" parents could ever teach ours.


  • Name: Natasha Pham
    Date posted: 2009-01-31 5:33 PM
    Hometown: Philadelphia

    Comment:

    I love you Thomas and Nancy and Susan! I'm so happy there's people in the world like you. There are evil and damaging stares everywhere, but you three have prevail and I would like to think that the world will be better. Good luck to your new life. FYI- I just finished your book in 15 hours, and now commenting on your file. Mr. Beatie you have my attention. If I ever make it to Oregon, I will find you and have you sign my book and say hi to Susan.


  • Name: Betina
    Date posted: 2009-01-30 2:41 AM
    Hometown: Denmark

    Comment:

    Congratulations from Denmark. I have also heard the story, and I saw the documentary also. I can't understand what people are so upset about. Two people are loving eacother - does it really matter whos stomach the baby is inside?? If you had to adopt, it wouldnt have been in any of your stomachs anyway!!! And regarding the god-talk.... Come on!! Do you really belive he is judging such a loving thing??? You, who are screaming about men cant have children, are the ones judging, not him!! All he cares about, if he is even there, is peace and love.... I think its great, I think you are great. THANK YOU GOD FOR I'M LIVING IN A FREE WORLD, WHERE EVERYBODY HAS A CHANCE TO LIVE THEIR LIFE THE FULLEST!! With love Betina


  • Name: Melanie B.
    Date posted: 2009-01-29 4:39 AM
    Hometown: Cape Canaveral

    Comment:

    you know, you are an extremly intolerant individual. have you any idea what these people are like? they are both excellent, loving, caring people and THAT is what matters when raising children. your intolerancy is disturbing at the very least! i dont know why there are so many people like you who cannot comprehend that this is one of the most beautiful and loving things a man has ever done.


  • Name: Louisa A
    Date posted: 2009-01-28 7:44 PM
    Hometown: Tucson

    Comment:

    My love and very best wishes to you Thomas, your sweet wife Nancy and your beautiful baby girl. Thomas as a teenager you were a handsome girl, as a man you are equally handsome, inside and out. I admire all of you, including Nancy's daughters. I wish all of you a happy and bright future.


  • Name: Tara
    Date posted: 2009-01-28 7:24 PM
    Hometown: Yelm

    Comment:

    I want you Nancy and Tom to know...we love you. We support you. I am not religious in any sense of the word, and cannot claim to being close to God, but I know that there cannot be a divine being in any world that would reject you, or your beautiful family. Love is what it all about...so you love your child(ren), and you love each other. Because we support you. Congrats.


  • Name: Kelsey
    Date posted: 2009-01-28 3:31 PM
    Hometown: Philadelphia

    Comment:

    My FtM Fiancé and I would like to have a baby. I already have a child, and I would like to carry his. I don't even know how this would be possible. Inseminate his egg and inject it into my body. What doctor would seriously go along with that??? I think what you two as a loving married couple are doing is wonderful. Creating a loving family. CONGRATULATIONS!!!!!!!!!!!!


  • Name: Stephanie
    Date posted: 2009-01-27 9:23 PM
    Hometown: San Rafael

    Comment:

    I want to send my best wishes for your family and baby girl. I just wanted to say that I am truely happy for you, and am proud of you. I hope that all is well and you do have people out there that are happy for you. I just want to say this, the people that are against it are non open minded people. and don't have the right to judge people. so, I support you and no matter what, remember that it doesn't matter what people think, it is what is important to you. which is family. Best Wishes, Stephanie


  • Name: Erik
    Date posted: 2009-01-25 10:38 AM
    Hometown: Webster

    Comment:

    Is it "sick" to correct a birth defect? Since science has proven that we are born with either a male or female brain, is it "sick' if you're born with a male brain but due to something that went wrong in the womb, you have a female body, to turn to medical doctors to correct this abnormality? If a baby is born with additional limbs, would it not be the humanitarian thing to do to surgically remove those limbs? So why the rejection of transgender individuals who have a birth defect and seek medical help to correct it so they can be whole?


  • Name: Carmen
    Date posted: 2009-01-19 12:04 AM
    Hometown: Orlando

    Comment:

    Congratulations on your beautiful baby girl! I can only imagine how much your family has gone through to get to where you are now, and it seems like only a fairy tale that you can be male, and still give birth to a healthy child. With regards to the titles of "father" and "mother", my mother passed away when I was 9, so my father had to be both a father and a mother to me, and I thank God for blessing me with such a great father/mother! I believe, with loving parents like yourselves, little Susan Juliette will be very blessed as well. I wish you the very best, and can only feel sorry for those who have made this wonderful experience hard for you. I do not believe the Lord would appreciate such negative comments to any of His children. Thank you as well for being such an inspiration!


  • Name: bm
    Date posted: 2009-01-15 2:54 PM
    Hometown: sf, ca

    Comment:

    Wow, i think its crazy. I feel sorry for the baby! Your playing God and its totally wrong... I think your both sick!


  • Name: shar
    Date posted: 2009-01-14 7:27 PM
    Hometown: marion

    Comment:

    I would just like to wish Thomas and Nancy the best. I think what they are doing is the best thing that someone can do for someone they love, its almost like organ donation. But you get a cute little baby! I wish me and my sweetie had thought of that. I really support them for opening the minds of our nation. Good luck.


  • Name: Becky
    Date posted: 2009-01-12 5:12 PM
    Hometown: Goshen, IN

    Comment:

    I am SO sorry for all the negativity that this has generated and I hope you do not take them personally. If you legally became a man because you wanted to be known as a man, then you are that. A MAN. You are this child's FATHER and your sweet wife is her MOTHER. You are a "normal" (whatever THAT means, anymore) family who did what you could to have a child that was a close to biological as you could. What a precious gift! I'm sorry for those who question your motive. You have a right to want a child because you wanted to be a father. Not because of the publicity, or the money. You are a good family. By the way, I am a Christian, and I know that Jesus loves you and that He is proud of you. Hang in there! I wish you a very happy and healthy 2nd pregnancy, and congratulations!


  • Name: Michele
    Date posted: 2009-01-11 8:36 PM
    Hometown: Chapel Hill, SC

    Comment:

    In Response to Key about God creating a male and a female: Are you aware that 1 percent of live births exhibit some degree of sexual ambiguity, approximately one in every hundred births. I am not sure what the practice is today, but at least a generation and a half back, the parents and the doctor decided which gender to go with and made what ever physical changes they could. Things have never been simply black and white (or male and female). Just thought you would like to know.


  • Name: Michele
    Date posted: 2009-01-11 7:51 PM
    Hometown: Chapel Hill, NC

    Comment:

    I just watched the Beatie episode on Discovery Health, and I continue to be amazed at the level of hate people have about things that have nothing to do with them. How in the world does it effect Macho Joe Shmoe if Thomas decides to carry and give birth to the Beatie's child instead of Nancy? This is their family, it is their decision. Unlike many of the children born in this country each year, this child is wanted, was planned, and will be dearly loved and taken care of. What skin does that take off of anyone's nose? Its natural to be surprised at such news, or to think it odd or out of the ordinary. Its even understandable to think its wired or gross because you personally just don't understand why a man would want to do such a thing. But to go to the lengths to call the Beatie's and leave hateful, threatening, nasty messages is just unconscionable. I wish the Beatie's the best of luck and happiness with their family.


  • Name: Meredith Shaw
    Date posted: 2009-01-11 3:17 PM
    Hometown: Columbia, MO

    Comment:

    I think it is amazing that you have this much love and desire to want to have a child. It's amazing how little people remember from the recent past; 100 years ago, people thought the children of Irish and Italian people would be horrible freaks; 40 years ago, the danger of having an interracial child was the hot topic--the child would be ostracized, mentally damaged, etc... While your family will face challenges, I hope your children realize how lucky they are to have parents that were willing to go through anything to have them. So many children come into the world with parents who are not ready, and not excited to have them. Your children will know nothing but love from you. Congratulations!


  • Name: r
    Date posted: 2009-01-11 2:50 PM
    Hometown: baltimore

    Comment:

    I think both you and your wife are very brave. I was very touched by your story and I wish you both the best. I'm very sorry you are subject to such terrible hatred. People are very ignorant and are scared by anything different. Pay no attention to them. I think your great and you are paving the way for other alternative families and ways of life. Thank you.


  • Name: Solomon
    Date posted: 2009-01-08 8:34 PM
    Hometown: Littleton, CO

    Comment:

    "Truth", is it? Tell me, would you deny a man born without legs access to prosthetic limbs and medical treatment aimed at improving his quality of life? Because following your logic, that seems to be the case. Transmen are legitimate males who suffer from a birth defect that makes it difficult for us to function in society. We know who WE are from early on, but the rest of the world has trouble seeing it without medical intervention. Just because you may not understand us does NOT mean we are wrong, or that we're mentally ill. Our minds aren't the problem. It's our bodies. Personally, I don't see child bearing as something I would like to take on, so I had difficulty understanding Mr. Beatie's case when I first got wind of him. But then I dug deeper and found that his wife was incapable of conception, making his intact eggs the only option for the couple to have a child of their own. So, answer me this: What's so wrong about parents wanting a biological child?


  • Name: Truth
    Date posted: 2009-01-01 1:53 PM
    Hometown: Southfield

    Comment:

    Mr. or Mrs - It doesn't matter. What we all need to understand is that you are a very selfish person. Hiding behind a veil of pain, and difficulties is just a self-serving deception to somehow justify your desires to the public. Listen LADY - cutting off your breasts and getting injections does not change how you were born. It is another self-serving need such as that stemming from masochism. I feel sorry that you have not come to grips with any of your issues - taking such extreme measures to avoid recognizing your real purpose is a shame. All this is done out of a deep self-serving avoidance of deep unresolved issues. What a shame - I feel almost as bad for your children - at least they will be able to point to their biological mother as an obvious reason for their troubles. I suppose an outside force is easier to reconcile than your internal force.


  • Name: Key
    Date posted: 2008-12-31 1:52 PM
    Hometown: Washington, DC

    Comment:

    Thomas & Nancy without hurting feels "In the beginning God created male and female. If God wanted you to be a male child and you had a sex change, would he not also have you change your internal parts as well? I saw the story on Oprah i said to myself wow, its a miracle then i found out you still had a female reproductive system which lets me know that you are still Female, and trying to to fool the WORLD into thinking that a man can have a baby. God did not intend on men having babies. Did you ever thing of adobtion? Then i thought how could he have a menstral cycle being male? hum... Mr. Beatie, no one knows but you and God. Yes we all fall short of the glory of God that is why we repent daily, i am no judge and i love you your wife and daughter just the same! my prayer for 2009 is that God bless you and your family always.


  • Name: wendy
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 10:14 PM
    Hometown: doncaster south yorkshire

    Comment:

    i watched a documentary about your pregnancy last night and i must say how moved i was, i think it is amazing what you have done. I was disgusted with how some people reacted, it was totally un called for, but we all have our own opinions i guess sad that it is at times. Your little baby is amazing a beautiful little girl, i hope all goes well in your next pregnancy and hope your little family will be happy and healthy good luck with the next pregnancy.


  • Name: Michele
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 7:50 PM
    Hometown: Düsseldorf

    Comment:

    I watched the programme about Thomas Beatie and his wife Nancy yesterday. Like most people, I was incredibly touched by their story. That's how I came to be on this page. I wanted to find a way to contact Thomas and Nancy to tell them how lovely I thought it was and how happy I am for them. Unfortunately I came across a lot of really negative and hatefilled comments. Now I'm asking myself 2 questions: Why is it that the people who are against this are always bringing God into it? And if they are such believers, shouldn't they be better Christians? I was always under the impression that good Christians should be accepting of all people. I'm afraid, this page shows quite the opposite. Instead of applauding Thomas and Nancy for their bravery and the love they show each other and their lucky little girl, they are being attacked by so called Chistians. I hope they all go to confession on a regular basis, because I'm sure that ridiculing and name calling are sins!


  • Name: Pam
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 9:58 AM
    Hometown: Gaborone ,Botswana

    Comment:

    congrats! i am so happy for them and they have my support all the way,if whatever they do is legal.they wanted biological children,they have evry right to have them.to all the people judging this couple,what do you want them to do?you want them to kidnap children?please leave them alone!why are you bothering them with what they choose to do with their lives? as long as it makes Thomas and nancy happy,i dont see why people should be making a big fuss out of it.get a life and leave thomas and nancy alone!they deserve to be happy, unlike the negative low-lives out there who cannot mind their own business! To thomas and his wife, if you feel like having ten more children,go ahead and forget about these miserable people who are saying negative things about you guys....


  • Name: Connie
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 6:30 AM
    Hometown: Weymouth, England

    Comment:

    I agree with all the positive comments here. I watched a positive documentary on "The Pregant Man" last night, and was quite moved by what i heard. All the rumors i had previously heard were obviously untrue, and it is clear that Thomas and Nancy are no different to any other parents, and will be as good as any others. I may be just sixteen, but i have a strong opinion on individualism. To the people who are against Thomas and Nancy's decision, i ask you, at what point does being different stop being acceptable? What right do these people have to question this family and view their ignorant comments online, in videos or however else they do. I say Well done to Thomas and Nancy and baby Susan, you deserve the right to be happy more than ignorant, one minded idiots who have nothing better to do than cause you greif. Hope it goes well, Connie JT xxxx


  • Name: Kenneth Nshiom
    Date posted: 2008-12-30 5:55 AM
    Hometown: Bafoussam, Cameroon

    Comment:

    Incredible, what a brave, bold and courageous couple in the face of all these criticism, maltreatment and stigma. Thomas, "you are really a man" How were you feeding your baby? Well, God is in control of all things. You are expecting your second child june 12, how is Susan, your first child doing? Best Wishes, Kenneth.


  • Name: colin
    Date posted: 2008-12-29 7:57 PM
    Hometown: london

    Comment:

    i love to watch such programs with great intrest as we develope as a human race to involve to the point tha one in we can truely have peace and understanding i have read the comments of support and browsed over the views of the narrow minded few who claim thomas is not a man "on that point i feel he is more of a man than most born that way he stood proud in front of the worlds media and said i have the right to live my life and provide for my family he has a loving wife and family" and the only time i feel sorry for them is that they will have to face the contast comments and finger pointing that should really be redirected to solve the worlds misunderstanding of true life to thomas and family i hope you find some peace on that long road ahead but stay strong for only you know in your heart what is right for you and your family


  • Name: Luc D'Anaud
    Date posted: 2008-12-29 6:11 PM
    Hometown: York, UK

    Comment:

    for all the people that consider him to be a freak... take a look at yourself and your life... how perfect are you? and why do you have the right to tell others what they can or cannot do. Congrats and good luck to the family, I hear they are expecting their 2nd child. Hope everything goes well.


  • Name: Patrice
    Date posted: 2008-12-29 5:58 PM
    Hometown: Perth, Australia

    Comment:

    Just wanted to show my support for Thomas and his family. You are very brave and I applaud your decision to have a child in the face of such controversy. Well done and all the best


  • Name: Samantha
    Date posted: 2008-12-29 11:53 AM
    Hometown: New York

    Comment:

    To all the people who think that the Beatie's children will grow up to have mental or emotional trauma: YOU are the kind of people who might cause that trauma. Thomas and Nancy are obviously loving, responsible parents. IF (God forbid) their children have issues later on- which is unlikely given how much their parents care for them- it will be because of people like you who cannot accept that they are part of a normal family. Saying that transgender people shouldn't have children because their kids might be teased is like saying minorities shouldn't have children because our racist society will make their lives difficult. We should work on changing society so that people are accepted for who they are, rather than discouraging people from having children because we think they might have problems along the way. EVERYONE has obstacles in their life, but with a supportive family those obstacles can be overcome. Best of luck to Thomas and Nancy and their beautiful children.


  • Name: Jamie
    Date posted: 2008-12-27 10:40 AM
    Hometown: Birmingham, Al

    Comment:

    I am watching the documentary on Thomas and his wife - I am overwhelmed with what gentle and loving people they are. I am really excited for their daughter. Though I am quite conservative and live in the heart of Dixie, I am also very human, and I am proud to know that this child will have such loving and kind parents. I am proud that Thomas and Nancy live in my country and can contribute to the humanity we all live amongst. I wish this family all the best.


  • Name: rebecca
    Date posted: 2008-12-27 1:47 AM
    Hometown: dupont, washington

    Comment:

    i think that i stood looking at Legos on Christmas Eve next to Thomas Beatie in a Wal-Mart in Washington State - and I wanted to apologize to him (if that was him) if i seemed awkward. i was torn between wanting to congratulate him on his lovely family and wanting to just let him shop for last minute Christmas gifts without being bothered. let me take the opportunity now to say how much i respect a couple who loves each other so much they want to devote themselves to raising children. i don't care what chromosomes a person is born with - genetics is not the only thing that influences who a person is. i had a difficult pregnancy and my husband told me many times that if he could carry our next baby he would. thomas beatie, you are a decent man and a loving husband. good luck with everything. please don't listen to the negative things people say. enjoy being a daddy!


  • Name: Naji
    Date posted: 2008-12-24 7:42 PM
    Hometown: San Diego

    Comment:

    I just want to say that I am happy for Thomas, Nancy, and Susan, and I hope this second pregnancy is old news to people and they move on. There is no news story here. This is a person with a uterus using it. This is a family having another baby. These children will have a lot going for them that so many children do not have, these children will have two loving parents. The only thing here that deserves time in the media is the atrocious behavior of the doctors and other "professionals" that denied these people care. I pray that, by the time Susan and her brother or sister are grown, this country will have matured enough that their family dynamic isn't all that dynamic afterall, and that they will just be normal people, like the rest of us. Selfishness is not living as one wishes to live, it is asking others to live as one wishes to live. --- Oscar Wilde


  • Name: Aimen
    Date posted: 2008-12-24 12:06 AM
    Hometown: Benghazi

    Comment:

    I just want to ask you that what is your baby called you? Is she agreed with you about your decision? Also, if you are right, why did God create two sexes ( female and male), two electricity charges, or two ends of a magnet (positive and negative)? And, can we keep contacting the same signs easily? I just want to know, because the angels have had only one kind that neither male nor female, so that are you angel?


  • Name: Corrine
    Date posted: 2008-12-23 11:45 PM
    Hometown: New Jersey

    Comment:

    I am a 48 year old woman with 4 adult children and 5 (going on 6) grandchildren. I made it a point to raise my children to be loving, accepting, open-minded adults. I am sorry the world STILL in this day and age has small, narrow-minded people in it. The hate that still exists, the racism, etc. is completely heartbreaking. Love is love, and THAT is beautiful. God bless Thomas, Nancy and their family. May He help them through this and protect them from the closed-minded judgemental people who want to tear them down.


  • Name: Stacey
    Date posted: 2008-12-22 11:17 AM
    Hometown: Glens Falls, NY

    Comment:

    Hopefully, someone can help me out or perhaps Thomas will read this and can answer these questions. I know that he was rejected by nine doctors before he gained access to a sperm bank. Was it hard to find a gyn/ob to see him through his pregnancy and deliver the baby? And I would like to know if he was treated with respect and recognized as a man? I cannot find answers to these questions and have read just about every article. Help me please.


  • Name: Stacey
    Date posted: 2008-12-22 11:16 AM
    Hometown: Glens Falls, NY

    Comment:

    I am writing a report for my Ethics class that is due on the 26th in support of Thomas' decision to give birth. I find him to be an incredible and brave MAN and I am appalled how he and his wife were rejected by medical professionals. Shame on them. That comment, "someone like him" is unprofessional and the hospital acted in an unethical manner. The medical profession is suppose to treat their patients with respect. They violated their work ethics and should have left their personal beliefs at home. If you cannot separate your work ethics from your personal ethics, then don't bother getting involved in the medical profession. Thomas and Nancy rock.


  • Name: Ellen
    Date posted: 2008-12-21 10:15 PM
    Hometown: Liverpool

    Comment:

    i just wana say congratulations i have also just watched a programme on more 4 an i think that Thomas and his wife should be very proud of the life he has created. People just need to learn to live and let live and let them get on with it. Im sure they will be excellent parents which is better than some people do for their children. Good luck with baby number 2 x


  • Name: S Bright
    Date posted: 2008-12-21 6:18 PM
    Hometown: Exeter

    Comment:

    I watched your programme this evening on More 4 and just wanted to say congratulations. My Husband and I have been trying to get pregnant for 3 years now with no success and are going down the route of treatment. I asked my husband would you carry a baby for us if you could. He replied yes without even thinking about it. I hope that Nancy and Thomas get to read this at some point and I want to just wish them all the happiness in the would and the best of luck with baby no 2. Congratulations and enjoy it. You appear to be two loving and amazing people, ignore the biggots and faciasts of this sad world and enjoy your babies!!


  • Name: Danielle
    Date posted: 2008-12-20 7:22 PM
    Hometown: England

    Comment:

    I would just like to say congrats to the happy parents, I know how happy I was when I had my little girl. I really hope everything goes well in your lives and in the life of your beautiful Daughter. Despite what some other people think and say your little girl was brought into the world with just as much love as any other and so will any other children you may decide to have. People who say nasty things about others whether because of colour, religion, or sexual orientation obviously do not understand what they are talking about. I think you were both very brave even considering having a child, I know I would be if I was in the same situation, but you have had to be even braver to put up with the harsh comments and even threats that have been made towards you. Well done and congrats again x


  • Name: Jessica W
    Date posted: 2008-12-17 4:39 PM
    Hometown: Stockholm

    Comment:

    Hello and CONGRATULATIONS to your cute daughter! I want to be honest with you, at first I thought like most of the people seems to think - that you biologically is a woman and that it's was weird. But like I heard you say with your own words in an documentary on TV - you are a legal man (don't know if I'm using the right term). You just wanted a family to love and hold just like (almost) everybody else. To get to my point - You are a role model to people out there in the same situation like yourself. You are an, if I may use the word: "Cool" man. I now, compared to how I first felt about you, admire your strenght, your courage, your love and your patience. And I think it's horrible how people can send you threatening videos and letters, and follow your every step and hunt you and your family. I vote for you as an father, and I send you my best wishes for a loving, caring, healty, long happy life together with your daugther and wife. /Jessica from Stockholm, Sweden


  • Name: Eddie
    Date posted: 2008-12-15 2:42 PM
    Hometown: Memphis, tn

    Comment:

    "He is a she." Sorry but the DNA says so. SHE still has XX. That means she is a female no matter how you look at it. It doesn't matter how one manipulates the physical appearance. It doesn't really matter to me what they do except I think that it is ridiculous that she gets officially labeled a male and the couple gets all of the government entitlements for a married couple. Your DNA determines sex, not appearance. If a sex change, which is still appearance, determines status, then all cross dressers should be labeled legally as they choose and be able to marry.


  • Name: R. P.
    Date posted: 2008-12-15 5:05 AM
    Hometown: Sacramento

    Comment:

    A transsexual is someone who believes they are the gender opposite the one they were born with. Thomas is, and identifies as, a man, despite his female sex organs. So no, it's not just a woman with her breasts removed. He is in the psychological mindset that he is a man, and has made the appropriate changes to his body to reflect that, except he hasn't gone through surgery to modify his sexual organs. This could be due to money or health concerns, as well as personal preference as the process of creating a functional penis from a vagina is not entirely advanced and some may want to wait until the process is more polished. He's a man, and the fact that he has chosen not to have surgery for whatever reason does not take away that right. Nor does the fact that he's chosen to bring a new life into his family due to his wife being unable to do so. I wish him the best.


  • Name: Andrea
    Date posted: 2008-12-14 10:02 PM
    Hometown: Lexington

    Comment:

    I have nothing against people that have a sex change op. No biggie. However, all the hype over this is insane. He/she has a vagina and all the organs needed to have a child. Big deal. I have had two children myself, I know it's the single greatest joy in the world. But isn't this still a woman that had her breasts removed?


  • Name: Samantha
    Date posted: 2008-12-14 10:48 AM
    Hometown: Dundee Scotland

    Comment:

    I must say this show moved me to tears, as someone who knows the pain and heartbreak of having difficulty concieving, I applaud your bravery and determination. I honestly believe that if two people are in a loving, lasting relationship then no one has any right whatsoever to judge them or their actions. As for people saying its immoral and its confusing when they have to explain this to their kids, its not the dark ages!! take the time as a parent to explain that everyone is different!! also they should ask themselves if they are so high on morals how morally do they live their own lives? im willing to bet none of them follow the bible etc to the letter.. most probably pick and chose which to adhere to when it suits them. People should keep their negative comments to themselves.. i wish you both love and congradulations x


  • Name: Vai Embry
    Date posted: 2008-12-14 3:02 AM
    Hometown: Singapore

    Comment:

    I just guess everyone should just be happy for them as a new born child is coming.. Does matter is the dad is a FTM... I give all the support to Beatie and his wife cos of the courage they had to tell his story to the world.........


  • Name: Renelyn Tabiliran
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 8:11 PM
    Hometown: philippines,Dipolog City

    Comment:

    but u know thats is for a sin sa ginagawa ni thomas,, because he changed the creation of God, kung anu siya,, he didn't contented of who he was,,she is a girl before, diba? But God know everything....


  • Name: Amie
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 6:39 PM
    Hometown: England

    Comment:

    Everyone that says "Omg your not a man blah blah" - HE IS A MAN BECAUSE BEING FTM MEANS YOU FEEL MALE, DESPITE BEING BORN INTO A FEMALE BODY. Why would anyone in their right mind have top surgery and take testosterone is they didnt feel 100% like they were a man?! And just because he chose to have the baby, doesnt make him less of a man either - he sees himself as a baby carrier, and he still feels positive and secure about his gender as male. His wife would obv carry a child if she could, but she cant, so why shouldnt Thomas?! They're not hurting anyone, they are loving parents who will bring their child up wonderfully, more than can be said for some stereotypical "normal" families who abuse and mistreat their child! Love is love and happy parents are hard to come by in this world, in the week of baby P I dont know HOW people can direct their anger at these wonderful people!!! LOVE AND SUPPORT FOR THOMAS AND NANCY!


  • Name: mrs english
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 5:34 PM
    Hometown: middlesbrough

    Comment:

    I just wanted to wish thomas and nancy and their soon to be 2 children all the very best of luck anyone who is a parent knows that raising children is no easy task never mind all the additional stuff they have been through. There are so many neglected children in the world we should be condemning the parents of those not a loving couple who want to be able to have and raise a family of their own. I think they are both very brave people and i send them all our best wishes from the uk xxx


  • Name: Natasha
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 4:11 PM
    Hometown: London

    Comment:

    I watched the documentary and can't believe how narrow minded and nasty people can be! It's so obvious how much Thomas and Nancy love each other and How much that beautiful baby girl is loved and wanted. If only we could say the same about some children born into "normal" families. Good luck to them for the next baby and the future.


  • Name: nina
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 9:41 AM
    Hometown: Preston

    Comment:

    when i watched the programme all i saw were two loving people that appeared genuinely kind hearted with a beautiful and healthy liitle girl. For all the nasty comments there are as many supportive ones. Many children have a terrible upbringing with the so called 'traditional family' .Peoples gender choices dont make bad people or parents. Wish you well


  • Name: Corri Lee
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 8:41 AM
    Hometown: WEst Midlands, UK

    Comment:

    I also saw the UK documentary last night and I applaud what you're doing. If only male pregnancy was an option for men who have not had to go through the nightmare of surgically adjusting their body and struggling to seek acceptance from loved ones, the problem of some couples not being able to conceive would be less of a heartbreaking problem all over the world. Society is way too eager to blow these things out of proportion when the fact of it is what woman wouldn't prefer their significant others to go through the excruciating 'miracle' of childbirth?


  • Name: VANESSA HOLMES
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 6:00 AM
    Hometown: TODMORDEN ENGLAND

    Comment:

    I WATCHED THE PROGRAM ABOUT THOMAS AND NANCY IN THE UK LAST NIGHT ND I JUST WANT TO GIVE MY FULL SUPPORT AND GIVE MY BEST WISHES TO THE FAMILY WHAT THEY HAVE DONE IS THE MOST NATURAL THING IN THE WORLD AND THEY ARE GOING TO BE FABULOUS PARENTS TO THE BABY AND THE BABY THEY ARE EXPECTING! IT REALLY ANGERED ME HOW SOME PEOPLE CAN BE SO NARROW MINDED AND NASTY TOWARDS THEM! IA AM A MOTHER OF4 MYSELF AND KNOW WHAT ITS LIKE TO WANT A CHILD THAT BAD YOU WOULD DO ANYTHING TO GET THAT CHILD ! TO ME THOMAS AND NANCY ARE A NORMAL COUPLE LIVING A NORMAL LIFE AND SHOULD BE LEFT ALONE TO BRING THEIR CHILDREN UP JUST LIKE EVERYONE ELSE AND PEOPLE SHOULD STOP BEING SO NASTY AND LEAVE THEM ALONE!!!! SO ALL MY LOVE AND BEST WISHES TO THOAMS AND NANCY AND BABY SUZANNE AND I HOPE THEM ALL THE BEST FOR THE FUTURE XXXXXX VANESSA HOLMES UK XXXXXXX


  • Name: Sarah Johnson
    Date posted: 2008-12-12 4:56 AM
    Hometown: Northampton, England

    Comment:

    Just watched the doccumentary about Thomas and Nancy in the UK. I really don't see a problem - a loving couple having a child, why is perceived gender such a problem for some people? Gender does not dictate whether a person can be a good parent or love their child. I am horrified at the outpouring of hate against two decent individuals - the ignorant comments that this child may come to some sort of emotional harm based on other peoples tainted perceptions shocked me. Thank goodness Susan will grow up in a loving home - enough children from what the public would view as 'normal' never have that chance. Happy Christmas from me and my 5 month old son. x


  • Name: ANITA
    Date posted: 2008-12-11 8:18 PM
    Hometown: PAOLI

    Comment:

    WELL I GUESS I CAN UNDERSTAND A WOMAN GETTINSEX CHANGE TO BECOME A MAN THEN GIVING BIRTH WIERD THINGS HAPPEN BUT WHEN I SAW YOUR SHOW AND YOU SAID THAT YOU FELT LIKE THE MAN WITH A TUMOR.THAT PISSED ME OFF ITS A TUMOR GIVE ME A BREAK YOU KNOW THERE R PPL OUT HERE THAT HAVE TUMORS LIKE ME AND MY 15YR OLD IT IS CALLED NEUROFIBROMATOSIS AND WE HAVE TUMORS THAT CAUSE PAIN ALL THE TIME YOU NEED TO GROW UP AND NOT MAKE FUN OF US WHO HAVE TUMORS LIKE THAT WE CAN NOT HELP IT YOU WANT PPL TO ACCEPT YOU THEN STOP MAKING FUN OF US


  • Name: Jorunn Vea
    Date posted: 2008-12-11 3:37 PM
    Hometown: Svingvoll

    Comment:

    My God... We're surprised of all the negative comments.. Why can't people see you are a family foremost? You have acchieved somthing unexpected.. Enjoy it! And give a dam about those who have a different oppinion! We wish you all the happiness in the world. Now and in the future. Merry Christmas:o) Love from Ida and Jorunn (Mother and daughter) from Norway!


  • Name: louella belle
    Date posted: 2008-12-10 1:41 AM
    Hometown: koronadal

    Comment:

    love is love, nothing you could say or do could change that. those people who are so judgmental are just idiots. maybe you people haven't fallen in love yet. once you dont understand something, you become afraid, and once you become afraid you tend to destroy it. everybody has a chance to be happy in life. those who are too shallow and dumb to understand the idea of building a family, its not just about a man and a woman, Family is more than that, the most important component of a family is LOVE. This two people here loves eachother, and the child that will be born to them will be brought up in love too. thats what really counts. gender is just an excuse. deal with it. thats reality. nosy people who are too damn hypocrite to recognize our existence are just playing stupid, face us! we are not a virus, I dont like the reaction of people to this couple, even the doctors are just cruel an unjust. hell! are you critiques perfect?!


  • Name: jane
    Date posted: 2008-12-08 10:55 AM
    Hometown: Witchita,Kansas

    Comment:

    mr.lee or should I say ms.lee you should of had a baby befor you removed your breast surgically. that poor and soon to be hungry baby. you should've thought about how this effect this child's life.


  • Name: ashlee
    Date posted: 2008-12-05 5:42 PM
    Hometown: roswell

    Comment:

    you two are so sick. i truelly believe that the child is in for a very rough life, how could you possible want that for any child. i also believe being in the public eye is going to do alot of damage. being a man and being legally male are to very diffrent things.i don't think you thought this threw.


  • Name: Renaye K. James
    Date posted: 2008-12-05 3:05 AM
    Hometown: Atlanta, GA

    Comment:

    The only thing that makes this news is how this woman's perversion and subsequent demand for public acceptance is creating a subtle change in what society considers normal versus abnormal. The success of these two women to make like man and wife to the point that people are accepting of or complacent about it will give others the go ahead to create similar lifestyles. The problem is that where man's will conflicts with God's, HELL will break loose and it promises not to be pretty, cute, cuddly or loving... Larry King called it a "curse" for someone to feel like a man inside (mentally and emotionally) but be a woman outside (physically). According to Romans 1:18-32, looks like Larry was right on the money!


  • Name: Raven Taylor
    Date posted: 2008-12-05 2:32 AM
    Hometown: Hartford, CT

    Comment:

    Beatie still has to physically function like a woman in all other aspects except where breasts were removed and I suppose, what public restroom Beatie goes to. Beatie claims to have an enlarged clitoris that functions like a penis such that Beatie and Nancy have intercourse same as heterosexuals. Medical findings report that even w/hormone injections, as part of the female-to-male transition, the clitoris "never completely adapts to the masculinization of its owner, will never be able to ejaculate or urinate and is small in comparison to the genitalia of a natural born male." That said, there is NO SUCH THING nor will there ever be a pregnant man. Leave those seahorse books alone!


  • Name: Patty
    Date posted: 2008-12-04 4:51 PM
    Hometown: BC

    Comment:

    To Mirjana: "God" would be happy that this baby has two loving parents, regardless of gender. I'm a woman and my wife and I want to start a family. Love makes a family. I for one support Thomas Beatie's intelligent, well-thought out decision. I admire his and his wife's courage.


  • Name: mirjana
    Date posted: 2008-12-04 12:05 PM
    Hometown: Calgary,Alberta Canada

    Comment:

    I believe this world has become crazy....for a man to carry a child???Then why do we need women, man has replaced us in many ways...if these people believed in GOD they would have never done this.......


  • Name: Doug Gempel
    Date posted: 2008-12-02 11:32 PM
    Hometown: Columbus-Westerville-ohio

    Comment:

    Its not really politically coorect. The white stuff on top of chicken shit is still dung. The definition of male or man here is twisted, genetcally speaking this couple is two females.


  • Name: Gerti
    Date posted: 2008-11-30 8:17 PM
    Hometown: Michigan City, IN 46360

    Comment:

    What will happen is your daughter dates the donated sperm of the man who donated his sperm to her? Also, is going public a financial consideratin as all this is very expensive although it seems that you two love each other and last... is Nancy Bruce Jenner's former wife?


  • Name: Lisa
    Date posted: 2008-11-30 10:33 AM
    Hometown: Dover

    Comment:

    I just want to say what u did was wonderful and me and my fiance want to have a child but we wanted to know how much it cost cause ur one of the few that actually concieved a child we just wanna know how much this procidure costed.please send me an email thank you


  • Name: Rosy
    Date posted: 2008-11-26 1:29 PM
    Hometown: Denver

    Comment:

    I think that if every child were to have the good fortune to be as wanted and cherished as all of Thomas and Nancy's children will be, the world would be a far better place.


  • Name: Rachel
    Date posted: 2008-11-25 2:36 PM
    Hometown: Bowling Green

    Comment:

    My 4 year old saw the program on tv for a short moment and asked me how that man was pregnant. I had to tell him the truth that she was really a woman because that is what she is. I do not judge them in any way. I don't agree with it but I have to let my child know that he cannot have a baby when he grows up. I also told him that she just chooses to look like a man but is really a woman. This is very confusing to a child.


  • Name: reco
    Date posted: 2008-11-24 9:33 PM
    Hometown: little rock

    Comment:

    How I feel about this is god made people.No one is alike.What god has for him it is for the Lee is for Lee.Let Lee live this life and pray for the transgenders.You dont have to like what Lee's done.Who am i to say something bad about transgenderes.What I say dont live a lye let the child or children know.What happen because they will find out.God bless good bye...


  • Name: Wendy
    Date posted: 2008-11-24 9:58 AM
    Hometown: Manitowoc, WI

    Comment:

    This should not be creating the media frenzy that it is. I think it's drawn attention because things were unclear about how Thomas could be a "man" yet still have female reproductive organs. If you're trying to learn something then that is what you should be learning about, not why - that's not your business. Open your minds to learn, not judge. I definitely think the world is curious and I think the focus should be on the facts about being transgender. Too many people think THEIR opinion and views are important to others, well wake up & quit trying to push those opinions and views on everyone else.


  • Name: Katt
    Date posted: 2008-11-24 1:51 AM
    Hometown: Martinez

    Comment:

    BRAVO!!! Choosing to having a family is a blessing, not a right that someone must fight for! I wish Thomas, Nancy, & their new daughter all the best in the universe!


  • Name: Mallorie
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 10:03 PM
    Hometown: in Boise, ID

    Comment:

    It's extremely sad that in some states assisted suicide is legal and much more accepted than those who transition, let alone a transgendered person giving birth to a baby. Transgenders are some of the most honest people in the world. They are true to who they are, even when faced with violence and ridicule. Thomas and Nancy Beatie are amazing people and there shouldn't be a problem with a husband and wife raising a child. My best wishes go out to them. Unfortunately what those don't understand they fear, and fear turns to anger.


  • Name: Verona and Sean
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 9:51 PM
    Hometown: Charleston, SC

    Comment:

    first i would like to say congrats on your baby girl. And yes, there sure do seem to be a lot of "this is wrong" posts here... As I see it Thomas Beatie is a man who loves his wife, and like her, wants a family. Devotion like this is incredible. The only thing I see as being "wrong" in this picture is the worlds fascintation with how f'd up this is. A baby is a baby, and a family a family. The Beaties will be great parents and it is a shame that they cannot enjoy parenthood without ridicule. Everyone needs to get over it. they are not carrying this child. Thomas is. Most of you have never even met them. So to the beaties, stay strong, and congrats!


  • Name: Amanda
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 9:39 AM
    Hometown: Hanover PA

    Comment:

    I watched your story on t.v the other night. And also heard that you are expecting again! so soon after the last baby. I have a 10 week old baby and I can not even think about doing all that again so soon. But any way at frist I felt conflicted about you story. But after I saw your wonderful baby come into to world. I knew the kind of love you were feeling for that baby. I have done it twice and no matter how you are bringing your children into the world, Or if you call your self a male or a female. you are still bringing a percious life into this world. That is something wonderfull no matter how it is done. We are all gods childeren no matter how we are or who we are. He loves us all no matter what. That is onething those of you who say such crule things to Thomas and Nancy should rember. also " do not judge least you be judged". Thomas and Nancy I wish all the love and luck in the world.


  • Name: Airdre Knox
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 4:05 AM
    Hometown: Melbourne, Australia

    Comment:

    I have just watched your interview with Diane Sawyer and I think you're a very special couple with a wonderful view of life, and I congratulate you on your new baby (and the way your handled the interview)! I admire your strength and love for life, and for one another, and I wish you all the best for the future. It's true Thomas, you were a beautiful girl - why this matters I don't know... but now you're a much more beautiful man.


  • Name: rulit2
    Date posted: 2008-11-23 1:47 AM
    Hometown: peoria

    Comment:

    i think alot of you are missing the point here .... what they wanna do behing closed doors is nobodys business but theirs but its not about them they are bringing a life into this world and its about that child. he/she has been taking large quantities of hormones for a very long time which has a good chance of adversly affecting the baby's development/health not to mention that children can be very cruel..... can you imagine the hell this child will go through in school being teased? in my opinion its selfish of them to do it this way why not adopt and avoid the chance of having a deformed child or a child that will be psychologically tormented their entire life?


  • Name: DLJ Cromatie
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 7:35 PM
    Hometown: Youngstown

    Comment:

    I am no crazy person but i was really interested in this story and would love it if you could let the real Thomas Beatie contact me. I am a female that wants to do the same surgery to become a man and want to pick his brain and talk to someone who has been there and knows what i am in for I really would like to talk to him because i have so many questions about the whole process. THANKS!


  • Name: Sierra
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 5:45 PM
    Hometown: Denham Springs LA

    Comment:

    i think all u wanna be christians need to get a life! who gave any of u the right to judge? U do know the bible says judging other is wrong an also that u cannot be both hot an cold . meaning u cannot be in church being a holy rolie then be on here talkin about how wrong this family is an making threats . grow up there not hurting u there not doing anything wrong TO U.geez.


  • Name: Oson
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 12:39 PM
    Hometown: Darien, Georgia

    Comment:

    Also you should think about the mental state of the babies you are producing. When they are of age they will have some sort of complex or mental disorder because of you. In my opinion you are selfish and the people who buy into you being a man having a baby are no better, because they are making money off of you. You are now a circus freak for the world and the only one you will have to blame is yourself. Last but not least what you do is your business, you should have never broadcasted it to the world. Your children will suffer for this and they will blame you and hate you.


  • Name: Damian D. Williams (Oson)
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 12:38 PM
    Hometown: Darien, Georgia

    Comment:

    Truth be told Thomas or Tracy you are still a woman because what makes you A woman is the fact that you still have a womb. Men and woman are not merely determined by there genital organs but by the way they reproduce. Man with a womb "Womb-man". So you are robbing the media and the book of world records because you having a baby has been being done since Eve. If you really want to do something different change your inside and not your outside. Then have a baby through your penis.


  • Name: Carrie
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 12:20 PM
    Hometown: Bethlehem, PA

    Comment:

    Congratulations on the birth of your beautiful daughter!


  • Name: Shaye
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 11:54 AM
    Hometown: Augusta

    Comment:

    I am watching your story on tv right no. I just wanted to say congratulations to both of you. It shouldn't matter if you are male or female, gay or straight. You two are clearly in love and that is a beautiful thing. Any child who is born to two loving, supportive parents is lucky. And congratulations on your new pregnancy too.


  • Name: Valeria
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 10:19 AM
    Hometown: Madrid, London

    Comment:

    Hello Thomas and Nancy I just wanted to express my support. I find your openminded attitude moving and your courage highly admirable. You are proud of who you are and so you should be. I am an eterosexual woman, born woman, and I feel not at all shocked or outraged by your choice. I admire you as a couple as I admire Nancy's doughters maturity.


  • Name: Stacy
    Date posted: 2008-11-22 9:04 AM
    Hometown: Wisconsin

    Comment:

    I think its wrong! Because your a man on the outside and an women on the inside. So you are actually an gay couple but hiding in a man's body.., for example " A sheep in wolf's clothing" ..., Not there anything wrong with that to quote "Jerry Sienfeld".But who am I to judge. You don't have to answer to me.


  • Name: Elaine
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 8:12 PM
    Hometown: Ohio

    Comment:

    Hi Thomas and Nancy I first heard about your story when you were on Oprah. I must admit I was a bit torn when I heard the details of your story, but after watching your show on Discovery, I decided you are a happy, loving family, and Susan is a very lucky little girl. I was happy for you when I learned you are expecting a new baby, and wish you a good pregnancy, safe delivery, and another beautiful, happy child for your family.


  • Name: Tina
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 2:27 PM
    Hometown: Ohio

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy, I watched your story on Oprah and Discovery. You are a warm,happy, loving family. Every child deserves to be loved by a family, and that is what you are giving Susan and her new little brother or sister. I'm so sorry for all the hate and ignorance being directed toward you. All you want is to have a baby, and be a family. It's no one else's business. Your daughter is lucky to be born into a stable, loving family. Keep your chins up and know that there are many people out there who support you, and send love and blessings your way. Stay happy, and many congratulations!


  • Name: Lisa
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 2:13 PM
    Hometown: Hampton

    Comment:

    Ummm.... this is crazy. Really crazy. The WHOLE thing.


  • Name: COURTNEY
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 1:52 PM
    Hometown: MISSISSIPPI

    Comment:

    EVERYONE IN THE WORLD NEEDS TO PRAY FOR YOU PEOPLE IF YOU ONLY KNEW HOW IT FEELS TO BE ABLE TO BE HAPPY WITH WHAT GOD HAS GIVEN AND HOW IT FEELS TO GO HOME TO YOUR SPOUSE THATS A REAL MAN INSIDE AND OUT AND MAKE LOVE AND IT GENIUNE AND NATURAL THE OTHER GIRL IN THE RELATIONSHIP NEEDS TO RUN AWAY AS FAR AS POSSIBLE AND FIND A REAL MAN THAT WILL TAKE CARE OF HER LIKE A REAL MAN CAN


  • Name: courtney
    Date posted: 2008-11-21 1:35 PM
    Hometown: mississippi

    Comment:

    this is not really as amazing as you all have everyone thinking technically your still a woman considering you have all of our organs all you have is a penis a fake penis at that


  • Name: Elisabeth
    Date posted: 2008-11-20 10:59 PM
    Hometown: Harrisonburg, VA, USA

    Comment:

    Congratulations, Thomas and Nancy! Don't be bothered by all the poor ignorant souls who try to bring you down. You are both incredibly brave. Good luck with everything and stay strong!


  • Name: joe
    Date posted: 2008-11-20 1:48 PM
    Hometown: wallew

    Comment:

    this is bullshit. this woman is confused.


  • Name: sharon yenom
    Date posted: 2008-11-20 11:48 AM
    Hometown: toronto

    Comment:

    this is the most ridiculous thing ever, it is virtually impossible for a male to get pregnant , maybe in the future centuries but currently it sounds pretty fiction and its jsut about a couple of people trying to get some attention from society, sorry buddy, not very convincing and for those who do belive in this tale cleary is getting sucked into ur act and has messed up perception :)


  • Name: sam
    Date posted: 2008-11-20 1:53 AM
    Hometown: birmingham

    Comment:

    they are going to burn in hell and if you think that this is ok then you are messed up too. these are the end times and nothing surprise me anymore all of this is against what god says about this , and iam not surprise to hear you say this mimm.keyes anybody thats not saved would think that way .


  • Name: Reece
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:30 PM
    Hometown: Portland, OR

    Comment:

    Thomas, I think you're at the point in your life where you can finally be comfortable with yourself and your image. You have no reason to be insecure because you choose to live such an open lifestyle. Forget the negative comments, because this is your life, and everyone is free in the pursuit of happiness. The only thing that can be implied of your daughter is that she will be a strong willed person. I thank you for your courage to release your story to the media. Your life has changed the world forever. I hope one day we can look back on this and think, "wow, I can't believe people were so hateful."


  • Name: Claudia
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:29 PM
    Hometown: Houston ,TX

    Comment:

    A baby is a blessing and as longs as that baby is gonna have two loving parents it doesn't matter who they are. Nancy and Thomas congrats on the baby and i wish you the best of luck .


  • Name: kaycflores
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:28 PM
    Hometown: Texas

    Comment:

    I just wanted to say congrats on Susan and I wish you two all the best of luck with the second child. I am currently expecting my second and I believe as long as you two are in this together and love one another that is all you guys need. It doesn't matter to me who carries the child as long as both of you support one another. Again, I just wanted to congratulate you two and I wish all the best of luck to you guys.


  • Name: Becca
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:28 PM
    Hometown: kansas City, MO

    Comment:

    I am watching your story on the discovery health channel now and I just want to say how courageous you both are. I am thrilled that you are able to have a family and it is unfortunate that others cannot see it in this way. I agree with you "I am embarrassed to be a human" because of how hateful we can be. As a social work student I actually wrote a paper on your story and the discrimination you face. I admire you both and I only wish you happiness and love.


  • Name: Mark Dawson
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 10:14 PM
    Hometown: Muncie Ind.

    Comment:

    Congrats on your birthing and enjoy the family in Love... but born a woman always a woman and lets drop the false assertions of you being A Man Technicalities are things not to be over looked. Lets se a man with a real Penis have one who has both sets of plumbing.


  • Name: chantell
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 7:13 PM
    Hometown: mississippi

    Comment:

    when is the baby due or did you have the baby already if do plese tell us becuse we whont to know ok. plese tell us on tv what there names are.


  • Name: Alicia Keys
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 5:21 PM
    Hometown: New York

    Comment:

    Hey,l this is Alicia Keys. Yes, this is me. If you ask for any sort of evidence you won't get any because all that matters is I know who I am. Ok, this is a miracle this isn't as popular news to most people. But, this will make History, he is the first man ever to have a baby. We should be blessed to be seeing this.


  • Name: missey
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 5:03 PM
    Hometown: 1123 creast haven trail

    Comment:

    hey tomes my name is missey i like your wife and your baby she is so cute like if you need a baby sitter plese email me .i heard you are going to have another baby if do girl or boy and how are you going to have your baby plese tell how to opra ok thanks missey your firend missey.


  • Name: Dana Smith
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 4:51 PM
    Hometown: Harlem, New York City

    Comment:

    It's not like he wanted to have a baby. It's weird, but it gives a man a feeling what a lot women get. I think he's going to get a sea section, because well he's a guy. And the only person to blame is God, and everything he does is for a reason.


  • Name: missy
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 4:39 PM
    Hometown: 1123 creast haven trail

    Comment:

    hi my name is cassie from me and you. iav seen your out come you are so cool can you have five babys to like a human person if can send me a letter ok .but what is your babys names plese tell me ok i will be looking ford meeting you in person . love cassie and lil wane


  • Name: Maria
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 2:15 PM
    Hometown: Seattle

    Comment:

    First off let me say that what I think you two are doing is a beautiful thing, and I wish with all my heart all the world's happiness to you both and your beautiful children. I am so saddened by all the negative comments people have made. Please, people, open your minds and your hearts to this beautiful family. Who are we to judge other people? If you Christians are so religious like you say you are, then leave the judging to God. And God loves people who love others and do well for others, just like this wonderful family. All my blessings!


  • Name: Ariel
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 12:31 AM
    Hometown: Virigina

    Comment:

    i think its amazing that you are the first pregnant ( male/female) i was absolutly obessed with the whole it its pretty cool..and i have always wanted to be a OB/GYN and i would have loved to deliver your baby


  • Name: Faintly
    Date posted: 2008-11-19 12:14 AM
    Hometown: Portland

    Comment:

    Hope, you're a twit. Get a life.


  • Name: Layla
    Date posted: 2008-11-18 11:42 PM
    Hometown: Grover Beach, CA

    Comment:

    I think it's amazing and beautiful. :-)


  • Name: Tami
    Date posted: 2008-11-18 10:58 PM
    Hometown: Taylor, Michigan

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy, I want to say congradulations on your little girl. I think it is great what you guys are doing and I just wish everyone out there would open their minds and their hearts to you. I hope your family continues to grow because it is very obvious that you two really love one another. Again congradulations.


  • Name: Bonnie
    Date posted: 2008-11-18 10:46 PM
    Hometown: Northampton, Ma

    Comment:

    Thomas, the only thing that surprises me about your carrying a baby is that the pictures of you pregnant DON'T look surprising! On a completely different note, I (a straight woman divorced from a straight man) had an ectopic pregnancy and several miscarriages in all of our attempts to have the one baby we were finally able to have. So my heart completely goes out to you because of your ectopic, your experiences going on and off of hormones, and all of the emotional and physical difficulty I know you lived through. What a strong and loving man you must be. And more brave in the face of a judgmental world than I can even imagine. You announced your pregnancy with your second child on my birthday! I'm tickled for you, Nancy and Susan! What lucky babies to have such an intentional, devoted, loving family.


  • Name: marc
    Date posted: 2008-11-18 3:10 PM
    Hometown: moncton

    Comment:

    until this MAN can impregnate himself (with his own man-spirit), he is a WOMAN.


  • Name: Granny
    Date posted: 2008-11-17 11:34 PM
    Hometown: Menifee, CA

    Comment:

    Will you please tell me how a woman who has a double mastectomy and takes testosterone can get a real marriage license???????? I thought you had to be one man and one woman in most states? You say you get all the financial and legal federal benenfits. How exactly did you do that? You still have a vagina and all of your productive organs. Just how did the federal government recognize you as a man? We all need this information and this is written for purposes of gaining knowledge, not criticizing anyone.


  • Name: Hope
    Date posted: 2008-11-17 8:42 PM
    Hometown: Alabama

    Comment:

    I dont know what the big deal is about a woman giving birth. Women have been doing it since time began, hint Adam and Eve. I believe sick whack jobs who cant decide what gender they are have no business having kids. Despite your views on religion i believe a higher power decides what sex you are. Know wonder this world or shall i say country is going to hell when we praise such abominations as this. Lets just hope those two freaks dont decide thier child was born the WRONG sex and screw her up before she gets grown and can get away from those two nut and stay away from them, because she hates them for what they have done. And i promise she will hate them for it.


  • Name: Mark
    Date posted: 2008-11-17 4:32 PM
    Hometown: Houston

    Comment:

    Cause if you cant see the love that this person is doing for his spouse then maybe you need to take a look at it and maybe learn from it. Would u do something so similar Bruce if you had a wife that could not have a baby would you go over and beyond and find a way to have a child of your own. Or how about you Cheryl would you do that same if you had a husband. Or what about you Travis. I bet all three of you would not do the extreme to show your love to someone. Maybe you sending hurtful out to hurt someone is telling us that you dont care much for someone to be able to do this. I think personnal if i would be able to do this i would. No matter the obstacle i would do it. I congradualate you once more for what you are doing. ....... Thank you so much.....


  • Name: Mark
    Date posted: 2008-11-17 4:31 PM
    Hometown: Houston

    Comment:

    For those of you that dont see the point in what this MAN is trying to do then maybe you should do some research on the topics of love and of gender issues. This woman considers herself to be male mentally. So she has fixed her outter apperance to look like she feels. I congradulate him and his wife on everything they are doing. Straight people make it seems like gay couples are only out to hurt other people. My Straight bialogical mother was a major drug addict and when she bore me i was born a alcohol fetal baby. So straight people have the same faults that gay people do. Another thing Travis and Bruce and Cheryl if you dont like something then don't listen. Most of the posting on here are so rude and hurtful that it should not be allowed to be posted. But hey to all his own but out of all these posting these 3 posting were the worst. You people can really go to hell.


  • Name: Maryl
    Date posted: 2008-11-16 5:57 PM
    Hometown: KC

    Comment:

    Melanie of South Africa...I can appreciate your point but....Please don't generalize Americans. We are all individuals as your are. We don't all think, feel or beleive the same. Thanks so much for understanding


  • Name: Travis
    Date posted: 2008-11-16 3:29 PM
    Hometown: Surprise, AZ.

    Comment:

    Not right. not right at all. there is alot more to being a man than looking like one and acting like one. you are a female with alot of surgery, and gay at that. you are an abomination and a freak. you are not doing anything noble or going "above and beyond the call of a husband" as amber said you are a gay pregnant woman. i love children they are the only pure thing we have left in this world... at least they will be until we start to allow gender confused gays to birth and ruin them. your all sick and need to see the big picture.


  • Name: bruce
    Date posted: 2008-11-16 11:43 AM
    Hometown: pearland

    Comment:

    this is just a way for these two women to make money,she was born a woman and still is a woman,the whole thing about being a man is b.s. it makes me sic.what about the kids they have i can see them getting picked on because of the freaks for parents, they should tie her tubes.the family life is gone in the usa and that is why we are in the mess we are in


  • Name: Elaine
    Date posted: 2008-11-16 4:23 AM
    Hometown: Atlanta

    Comment:

    Correction on my typo...THIS has EVERYTHING to do with the want and need to have a complete family. Kudos on your selfless act of LOVE.


  • Name: Elaine
    Date posted: 2008-11-16 4:15 AM
    Hometown: Atlanta

    Comment:

    This is wonderful because it's not that you are a woman who felt that it was natural for you to became a man. THIS has nothing to do with love or the need to have a family. I am a woman who has never had a same sex or transgendered relationship. As far as I see you are a MAN that cares enough for his family and has the ability to give life that he is driven to do something that I'm sure does not feel natural nor comfortable to him. But your wife was not belssed with the ability to give completion to your family so that left you. You could have been seflish and said no but you didn't and you chose to become pregnant. I feel if every other man in this world had that choice they would not do it. So I want and need to let you know that I commend you for doing what you did. You were running a big risk health wise since you had been taking hormones but you did it any way with only concern for your family. BEST OF HEALTH AND LUCK TO YOU AND YOURS.


  • Name: Kelly
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 11:27 PM
    Hometown: Salem, NH

    Comment:

    I just watched the Barbra Walters Special on this family, and here is what I saw: LOVE. That's it people. Just two individuals who love each other, love their family, love their baby and will love their newest little baby on the way. Who are any of us to judge them? My only hope is that they are very careful because this second pregnancy makes them an even greater target than before. There are so many sickos in the world. They need to protect themselves and their children. People need to live and let live. Afterall, we are all vulnerable to judgment ... aren't we? None of us is any better than anyone else. Remember that the next time you write a nasty email about people you don't even know!


  • Name: Cheryl
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 6:02 PM
    Hometown: Kernersville NC

    Comment:

    Exactly. The world is not ready for the the life problems these obvious self centered, selfish couple has imposed on her. On in which she will probably have to spend the rest of her life in counselor for their decision. So much for loving her child.


  • Name: Jaimee
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 5:03 PM
    Hometown: Kansas City Missouri

    Comment:

    I find that being a parent the hardest thing to accomplish is knowing who you are and not losing that identity in the mix of all the new. There are really no differences between you or I. Yes, I am strait, a female, married, and have two beautiful children of my own. The truth is is that there is no difference between looking through your own eyes and seeing the beauty life has to offer. I am a true Christian, and find that sometimes things are truly misjudged by people that have no place to judge. I find it empowering that you choose to share your story, for a time has come that we all truly need to open our eyes and our hearts to each other, and embrace the differences that we all have. There are no right answers in life, and believe me I know, but things are set into play by someone other than us. And he knows what he is doing, and we need to trust in him that there is a reason behind it that maybe all of us do not see at this time. May the Lord be with you and your family.


  • Name: Glynis Touchard
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 3:24 PM
    Hometown: Houston, Texas

    Comment:

    I am no sure how to contact this family but if you can plase forward this on to them. I am probably the farthist away from this story in my own life. I am a 52 year old female. Always been female. Never been gay or struggled with gender issues. I am however very oped minded and I commend this famiy for what they have accomplished! It taks all different peope to make a family and I am happy to hear that their family will continue to grow. Many blesing to them and I wish them all the luck there is for them. Now if we can just get others to put away the hae and open their minds & their hearts to others.


  • Name: angie
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 2:31 PM
    Hometown: mexico

    Comment:

    omg :| Im so proud that gay marriages are that accepted there in usa here in mexico they're so tight!


  • Name: Laura
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 8:14 AM
    Hometown: Deland, Fl

    Comment:

    I want to Congratulate you both. I watched the Barbara Walters Special last night & you both have so much love for one another & for your beautiful little girl. If only everyone could experience the love that you have it would be a better world. True love know's no gender, race, religion or anything, it's LOVE. You both have proven this & my g/f & I wish you all the best life has to offer. You are amazing people to bring a child into the world & love them unconditionally no matter what. A parent is love, caring, patience, understanding & compassion it's not male or female. Keep up the wonderful work & we wish you nothing but the best life has to offer. With all our thoughts & prayers may you be as happy in the future as you are today. God Bless & be safe With all our love & respect Laura / Kelly


  • Name: Lisa
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 7:52 AM
    Hometown: A-town

    Comment:

    Strange story


  • Name: Ashley
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 3:11 AM
    Hometown: Eugene, OREGON

    Comment:

    I dont feel the need to judge you or your decisions. Me and my husband watched the Barbara Walters Special and saw how much you love your child. You love your child more than most heterosexual couples do. Its about love and family, not whether you are a man or a woman or whatever. I have so much respect for your courage and willingness to be so open about your lives. It gives me and my family a greater understanding of love and exceptance. Your story is inspirational and special. I wish you all the best with your expanding family and your pregancy! Iam pregnant too and know how exciting a time this is! Best of luck to you all!


  • Name: Julia
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 3:01 AM
    Hometown: Canada

    Comment:

    Thomas is a MAN! It does'nt matter that he has female parts, his gender identity is a man. There was also a comment about dressing up like a dog, and how that was like what Thomas is doing. It is NOT the same thing. When you dress up like a dog, do you feel/think like a dog? I don't think so. People also talk about how this is against God, but why does God have to dictate everything in our lives? I believe God wants us to have free choice. If He was going to direct everything, He wouldn't have allowed us to develop technology to do these things that are "against God". If you really believe in God then you should believe we're taught to do unto others as we would have done unto ourselves. To Thomas and family, I wish you the best. Always remember there are people who support you. I think you two are/will be wonderful parents and your children will grow up to be wonderful people. Best of wishes, & I hope the rest of the pregnancy and birth goes well.


  • Name: Kelsey
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 2:36 AM
    Hometown: Sunburst

    Comment:

    Mr. and Mrs. Beatie, My mother and I would like to send our suport. We really admire what you have done and don't understand why so many people have such a problem with you and your wife having your own baby. My name is Kelsey, and my mom's Carol, we both work at a hospital and I know that I love to be arround married couples that are about to have a baby. Along with couples having a new baby, there have also been couples that have not been able to conceive, or carry a baby to full term. To have a baby is a merical in it's self, and for a man that is able to give his wife, who is not able, a baby...is even a bigger merical. We wish you both the best of luck, and a happy, healthy baby. Kelsey and Carol


  • Name: Gabby
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 2:27 AM
    Hometown: Vancouver

    Comment:

    RHODA IS STUPID & BEYOND IGNORANT!


  • Name: Trish Scott
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 2:27 AM
    Hometown: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada

    Comment:

    I have seen the Beaties story on Oprah and just now on Barbara Walters Special. Congratulations!! I just don't understand some people who express rage, hate.... and it comes from their insecurity in themselves and ignornance on their part. I wish your family all of Gods blessings. You are a beautiful family and the world would be a better place with more people like you. Thank you for be so brave and sharing.


  • Name: Joni Jenkins
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 2:24 AM
    Hometown: Portland, Oregon

    Comment:

    Hummmm...all I see is a human being giving birth to a human being, while raising this human being with another human being in a loving, legally and emotionally comitted marriage. And if they do happen to make money off of humanity's obsession with not minding their own business, then more power to them. I hope they become millionaires! Better them then a father who rapes, beats, and impregnates his own daughter. Thomas and Nancy are only a mirror for us to see where our limit to love is. God loves us unconditionally without limits. I thank Thomas, Nancy and their daughter for giving me the opportunity to love more deeply and unconditionally.


  • Name: Gabby
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 2:13 AM
    Hometown: Vancouver

    Comment:

    Thomas ~ Susan is so beyond BEAUTIFUL! Wait til you have a son!! They are too cool! I am a married Mom, Step Mom & Gramma! GO MAN GO!! Go for June 12!! That is my nephew's Bday!!


  • Name: Brooke
    Date posted: 2008-11-15 2:06 AM
    Hometown: San Juan Capistrano

    Comment:

    Congratulations Thomas and Nancy! Your daughter is beautiful and you are an adorable couple and you seem like very loving parents. Shame on all the judgemental people in the world!!! This is a loving family!!! Find something productive to use your energy on - not on a happy loving family. Congratulations again! Your family makes my heart happy!!


  • Name: Matt
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 11:32 PM
    Hometown: Tupelo, MS

    Comment:

    You are so courageous for coming out with your story. I am a gay, married man who would one day love to adopt. How sad it is for those who are so quick to point fingers and judge others by their own perceptions and beliefs. What really matters in life is that when our time is up, that we've had a chance to love and be loved. Open your minds and hearts America! I mean really, what would Jesus do? He would have opened his arms to give us the biggest heartfelt hug of our lives...not send out messages of hate, but LOVE! Love one another people! Life is too short to hold onto "stuff". Let it go and live and be happy! Congratulations Thomas and Nancy on your 2 bundles of joy! I'm behind you along with millions of other people so don't let anyone get you down!


  • Name: Lori J
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 11:29 PM
    Hometown: Shamokin, PA

    Comment:

    I am a 48 yr old mother of three children in a small Pennsylvania town. I just watched the Barbara Walters Special about the Beatie's and was very impressed with what a normal family they are. I understand their desire to have a family and especially one with a biological connection, not to take away from adoption, which I think is very special as well. I totally get it and am very happy for them!! The program gave you a sincere look at their lives. I feel sorry for people in this world that choose to hate, rather than love.....that's what this is about...love!


  • Name: Desiree
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 11:29 PM
    Hometown: North Dakota

    Comment:

    Congratulations on your family! Stay strong, there is love in this world and support for you and your family.


  • Name: Rose Kupko
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 11:29 PM
    Hometown: Apache Junction, AZ

    Comment:

    I think the two of you did just as you should. You only live once and you should live your life as it makes you happy. After all it is a free country. It is obvious that you love one another and I would much rather see a loving couple raise a child than to see some of the child rearing people who are out there today. Live with love and love with life.. Congrats to you and you should be commended!


  • Name: Pam
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 11:03 PM
    Hometown: Cleveland

    Comment:

    Congratulations on your soon to be new arrival! Baby Susan will be a wonderful big sister!


  • Name: Lauren
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 10:54 PM
    Hometown: Va Bch

    Comment:

    While I don't agree with Thomas for many reasons when I heard the hateful things that people are saying to him my heart ached. When they showed little Susanon tv tonight I just couldn't imagine anybody wishing that baby ill! She's beautiful!! So although I do disagree with this family I wish them well and pray that no harm comes to them becuase of someones hate.


  • Name: Dawn
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 10:43 PM
    Hometown: Knoxville, TN

    Comment:

    Congrats Thomas and Nancy!!!


  • Name: Marcela Araujo-Delgado
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 10:42 PM
    Hometown: Detroit

    Comment:

    Good luck with your lives.


  • Name: Dani
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 10:30 PM
    Hometown: Jax

    Comment:

    I think everyone is getting the message wrong here. Its not about gender, yes, it grabs headlines, but ultimately, this is about a marriecd couple wanting to have a family. Whats the big deal? CONGRATS Thomas and Nancy!


  • Name: Andy
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 9:52 PM
    Hometown: Ft. Worth

    Comment:

    I do not believe this is a medical breakthrough or miracle. "Thomas" Beatie is still, biologically, a woman giving birth to her second child. I don't disagree on transsexuality, but this story is not very different from a normal woman giving birth. If there were a REAL man (meaning not transsexual) who gave birth, that'd be different. That has yet to happen.


  • Name: Nicole
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 8:40 PM
    Hometown: Birmingham, AL

    Comment:

    So, people like you are on here wasting your time arguing over this ridiculous story while you can be out there doing something productive and better for this world. YOU are the reason the media prints the stupid stories that don't even matter and make millions off of your stupid lazy asses. If we didn't even respond to things like this, the rest of the world might think that we are a little smarter for the great United States we are supposed to be. Hell, the U.S. might even be in a better financial and presidential situation if the people like you weren't wasting your time and money with your heads stuck up your ass not knowing the real topics and situations we are in right now!


  • Name: Corey Ann
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 7:57 PM
    Hometown: Ft Worth

    Comment:

    God this God that. For those of us freethinkers who have gotten over the santa-god thing, none of your religious crap means anything. Whats going on with Thomas is REAL. I suppose all you bible freaks think we should kill homosexuals, beat women, and many other atrocities that the "good book" says are ok? Oh wait thats right you interpret it for your own means, and use only the goody two shoes parts you like. Shut up about god and live your life, and let us live ours. If you dont like what you see stop reading, turn the channel, and stick your head in the sand like you usually do.


  • Name: shirlebe
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 7:28 PM
    Hometown: new jersey

    Comment:

    Let's be clear, legal or not, he is a woman in God's eyes, and the eyes of most americans. Despite what he chooses to call himself is besides the point, this is no medical miracle.


  • Name: Haley Talifson
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 6:28 PM
    Hometown: bend Oregon

    Comment:

    congratulations Thomas! Hope that you are having a great time being a new father and good luck on your newest addition to your family! I offer only the best of wishes!


  • Name: Lorie
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 6:19 PM
    Hometown: Germantown, Md.

    Comment:

    Only God should be our judge, those of you out there with the evil comments will have to answer to God some-day for what you said and for all of the sins you have committed in your life-time. I'm sorry that that man/women, and his wife, decided to make this so public to the media. Their child will have to put up with so much discrimination as well as the brother or sister because he/she is now pregnant again. Why wouldn't they just keep it quiet for the sake of the babies. For that reason, and only that reason, I am very saddened.


  • Name: Angie
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 4:26 PM
    Hometown: Boston, MA

    Comment:

    Armchair Psychologist here... The fascinating thing about the negative comments is how aqdamant they are to say "I don't care what you say, what this really is is..." It's as if the writer were driven by some force to categorize the relationships and identities of other people. Surely the drive to identify the gender of another person has an obvious basis in procreation, but why do these people need to announce their observation to the public, or even back to the person they are observing? Transgenders (I am one) know that there are people (fortunately few) that need to come up to you and tell you "hey, you're really a guy/chick!". We also know that these are the people who are the least secure about their own gender identity and sexuality. Live on, and congrats to the new (and pregant) parents.


  • Name: Lindsey
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 3:07 PM
    Hometown: Birmingham, Alabama

    Comment:

    After reading every comment on this article, I realize that Americans are dumber than I ever thought. More than half of you need to open your eyes & take a good look around. If he wants to be a man & carry a child for his wife who are you to judge him? Are you a perfect human? No one is perfect, if we were plastic surgeons wouldn't make millions every year. I've read all the talk about if god wanted this to happen you wouldn't have had to use artifical insemintaion- IF GOD DIDN'T WANT THIS TO HAPPEN THE ARTIFICIAL INSEMINATION WOULDN'T HAVE WORKED! It doesn't work in all cases my husband & I have tried it 4 times w/ no luck. We live IN AMERICA w/ countless people of different nationalities, races, religious preference, etc. part of being an American is accepting everyone for who they are not judging them. Congratualtions Thomas and to HIS wife on starting their new family


  • Name: Jennifer
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 2:47 PM
    Hometown: Seaatle, Washington

    Comment:

    Oh, come on.. if you wanted to be a man you would've gone all the way, reproductive organs and all. You're a shame to the GLBT community! You should've just stayed a lesbian.


  • Name: Lee
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 2:28 PM
    Hometown: San Francisco

    Comment:

    Jane Don, I am married to a transsexual man. Which means he was born biologically female but has fully transitioned to male. I am very active in the GLBT community and have many transgender & transsexual friends. I can honestly say I agree with you 100%. I have talked to many transmen that feel the same as you and feel that Thomas Beatie is the worst kind of spokesperson for transgender and transsexual people. Thomas Beatie is not the first transgender man to give birth. The others just kept it quiet and didn't turn it into a freak show. Shame on this couple for leaving this legacy for their child.


  • Name: Corey Ann
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 2:27 PM
    Hometown: Ft Worth

    Comment:

    Not too many women would cut off their breasts and grow a beard for money. Considering they had a successful screen printing business before all the publicity, your opinions about them just wanting to make money is BS. If he wants to make money while telling his story that's up to him. If I had to go through some major surgery and pregnancies, and could make money like this to help pay for it AND educate people at the same time, I would too. He is very very brave for coming out knowing he would have to face all the negativity. Funny thing is this is probably not the first time something like this has happened, he is just the first to go to the big media with it.


  • Name: rose
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 12:31 PM
    Hometown: England

    Comment:

    the only interesting about about this woman is that she has decide to change her name to Thomas; otherrwise, congratulation for the new money-making idea.


  • Name: Ann
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 12:01 PM
    Hometown: Brookfield

    Comment:

    Summer: Just curious, if you really feel that "God allowed this to happen" and that "God created this baby and placed it in this person", do you also feel that God allows abortion? After all, it was the handiwork of doctors and surgeons doing both of these things. Doctors created this pregnancy and doctors terminate pregnancies. So if you feel God allowed this to happen, then you must surely agree that God allows abortion to happen also. Personally, I feel this is just another woman having a baby. Nothing more. And as far as anyone saying we should "leave them alone", they made the choice to bring this to the spotlight and continue to do so with every interview they grant. During "his" last pregnancy, "he" even posed for photographs for money so they put theirselves out there and should expect public reaction, good or bad.


  • Name: Corey Ann
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 11:54 AM
    Hometown: Ft Worth

    Comment:

    Jane Don, you are clueless. I cant believe you wasted your time spouting all that BS. Like I said before if you werent born with the condition of being transgendered you have NO ROOM TO SPEAK, especially like you did. Whatever HIS reasons for coming out to the world, at the very least it will raise awareness that we are here, people born in between genders, mentally and physically, and all the bigotry and ignorance in the world will not make us go away. People like you will die out eventually, and all the young people who learn of this as a condition that exists will no longer share your ignorant views and opinions. Get over it and go comment on something you have a clue about.


  • Name: Jane Don
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 11:36 AM
    Hometown: Las Vegas

    Comment:

    This is a non story. This is a conwoman who clearly doesn't even really see herself as a man. A real man would never want to do the most womanly act in the world-the act of getting pregnant and having babies. This conwoman is taking advantage of today's politically correct media and society for financial gain. Her pregnancy is no different than that of any other woman. The only difference is that most women don't dress up as men and call themselves their baby's father. She wants to avoid the social stigma of being a lesbian and force society to treat her in the manner that she personally dictates. And in America, she just may get what she wants. The legal system needs to stop allowing people to change genders. There is no such thing as a gender change in reality and as such, it shouldn't exist legally. I can't wait for the day when the media stops reporting on this bogus non story.


  • Name: Melanie
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 10:35 AM
    Hometown: South Africa

    Comment:

    When I first saw the headline, just today, I thought....OH WOW..what the hell is this? I jumped on the net and found this article. Then only to find out it`s a woman having a baby...?? Duh..whats so exceptional about that? I`ve had TWO! Sorry to say, but I find Americans in general very irritating. Blah blah blah. You give the media tooooo much credit and attention. They have to sell their silly stories and from what I`ve seen, the more shocking, the more sales. Whatever.


  • Name: Corey Ann
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 10:07 AM
    Hometown: Ft Worth

    Comment:

    XX, XY, doesnt matter. There have been women born with vaginas and have xy chromosomes, then gone on to have babies. There are "men" born with xx, and xxy. Gender is so much more than chromosomes. The facts suggest that chromosomes could be an effect of gender, not cause. If you werent born with an issue such as Thomas has, and many other thousands of people, then you cannot know what it means, nor can you ever fully understand, unless you open your mind to the fact that gender is not black and white, man and woman. Many women cannot have babies, for many reasons. Are they any less a woman? Some women are born with closed/shallow vaginas and no uterus. Are they any less a woman? I find it sad that people who are not experts in gender studies or any other kind of expert in this field can judge someone so harshly. To me, a man is someone who presents as such, and the same goes for a woman. Any other opinion is biased and/or based on ignorance.


  • Name: Melanie
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 9:24 AM
    Hometown: South Africa

    Comment:

    I feel that as long as they are not hurting anyone, why not do as they like? Many people have made solid comments about Thomas not forsaking all that is female to become male. Well, even that is ok. Let him do and be as he pleases. I`ll never meet the person, the story is interesting, and thats as far as it goes for me. Believe me, and you all probably know, there are worse things going on around us. Just last week a beautiful 13 year old girl was STONED to death in Somalia because she was RAPED by three men. Now that`s fair is it? But the media ! The media who make icons out of stupid skinny ugly little "movie stars" and the like..they are to blame for blowing this out of proportion. I have to agree: Thomas is a female, albeit not a woman. But who cares? Leave them alone and let them have a shot at happiness. It`s what we`re all after, ultimately.


  • Name: John
    Date posted: 2008-11-14 5:50 AM
    Hometown: NY

    Comment:

    ”First of all this is NOT A MAN. She will never be a man. She can act like one. I could put on a fur coat and make everyone call me a dog, but underneath, I am still a human.”” Are you sure about that last sentence?


  • Name: Michelle
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 11:48 PM
    Hometown: DFW

    Comment:

    I don't believe the doctors had the right to require that Thomas seek psychological counseling before "allowing" him to become artificially inseminated. If that be the case, shouldn't ALL women be psychologically evaluated before having children? Perhaps if they were, we'd see fewer heart-wrenching reports of child abuse, neglect and abandonment. So, if it would have been socially and morally OK for Thomas and Nancy to use a surrogate or to adopt, then why the fuss over Thomas using Tracy as the surrogate? Congratulations to Thomas and Nancy on your new addition. Being a parent is the most wonderful opportunity afforded to men and women alike.


  • Name: Michelle
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 11:48 PM
    Hometown: DFW

    Comment:

    I don't believe the doctors had the right to require that Thomas seek psychological counseling before "allowing" him to become artificially inseminated. If that be the case, shouldn't ALL women be psychologically evaluated before having children? Perhaps if they were, we'd see fewer heart-wrenching reports of child abuse, neglect and abandonment. So, if it would have been socially and morally OK for Thomas and Nancy to use a surrogate or to adopt, then why the fuss over Thomas using Tracy as the surrogate? Congratulations to Thomas and Nancy on your new addition. Being a parent is the most wonderful opportunity afforded to men and women alike.


  • Name: Summer
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 9:28 PM
    Hometown: Albemarle, NC

    Comment:

    Some of you people say that you are Christians, but if you were, then you wouldn't judge this man. And you would also realize that God allowed this to happen. God created this baby and placed it into this person. Sure this is a test tube baby, but don't you think God had a hand in bringing it to life?


  • Name: Jimmy
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 8:02 PM
    Hometown: St. Louis

    Comment:

    When you are talking about what is God's job, how can this make any sense? First of all this is NOT A MAN. She will never be a man. She can act like one. I could put on a fur coat and make everyone call me a dog, but underneath, I am still a human. Let's get real. You are just doing this for publicity. You know what you are doing is not right. Just keep your sick twisted life to yourself and quit showing the world how messed up you are.


  • Name: Vanessa
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 7:17 PM
    Hometown: South Carolina

    Comment:

    Thomas, reality check, you are not a man. The fact that you were able to give birth to a child makes you 100% woman. All this hoopla of you being the first pregnant "man" shouldn't even exist.


  • Name: Ali
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 6:16 PM
    Hometown: Kansas City

    Comment:

    Dear Thomas, congratulations on your healthy baby girl, to me it looks good when a father steps up and takes the plate. it doesn't matter of your a father with a penis or a father with a vagina and a uterus, what does matter is your attitude twords it, I was reading article and when you said "we'll be a family" it brought me to tears.....good luck in the future and i hope that you guys have a fun life together.


  • Name: Tina
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 4:07 PM
    Hometown: Lawrenceville

    Comment:

    I really enjoyed the comment by Tux in Corpus Christi. The comment read, "This is like dressing a cat like a dog and being amazed that it had kittens. " Thanks Tux for the comment. It made my day.


  • Name: Tina
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 3:53 PM
    Hometown: Lawrenceville

    Comment:

    I am very curious... do you have a penis? If you stopped taking testesterone then why did you have a beard in your pregnancy photos? Who is the daddy? Are you considered the 'biological' father or mother? Who is listed as the birth mother on the birth certificate? Now that you are a man, why are you not as muscular as you were when a woman? What needs to be changed on a woman's body in order for her to be 'legally' a man?


  • Name: Manny
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 3:33 PM
    Hometown: Covina

    Comment:

    Call it what it is which is a woman giving birth to a child!


  • Name: Lee
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 1:14 PM
    Hometown: Amerst Massachusetts

    Comment:

    I agree with people who are pointing out that this is NOT a pregnant man. It is a pregnant WOMAN who has had some surgical alterations and some hormone shots. If this person really wanted to be a "man" then they would have gone all the way with surgeries and gender reassignment and accepted the limitations that being a man brings including not having babies. This might be wonderful for them but their children may grow up very gender confused. And to all who say oh-so-progressivel that "gender doesn't matter" well actually yes, to some of us it still does.


  • Name: Amber
    Date posted: 2008-11-13 12:42 PM
    Hometown: Peoria

    Comment:

    Doesn't anyone know there is a difference between a FEMALE and a WOMAN. sure he was born FEMALE. it takes more than boobs and a coochie to be a woman. What I'm seeing here is a loving dedicated husband who went WAY above and beyond to have a child with his wife. All wives should be so lucky to have a husband like this. He didn't care what people thought of him. He was doing something for his family! He has done no more that what any GOOD husband would do if a conventional husband could give birth. CONGRATS! and btw for the "christians" comment i'm a born again God-fearing christian and I think this guy is awesome!


  • Name: Jazzy
    Date posted: 2008-11-10 7:44 PM
    Hometown: new york

    Comment:

    It's about time a man feels the birth pains(smile). congrats on your new life there is nothing wrong with what u are doing.have a wonderful life with your new baby and your new family.


  • Name: nicole
    Date posted: 2008-11-09 11:25 AM
    Hometown: Oklahoma

    Comment:

    wow... these comments on here are just flat out rude...Everyone who is making fun of this "man" must have something going on in there own lives that piss them off...did you know that anger towards someone else is usually a reflection on how you feel about yourself? Take that into concideration... Grow up people and live your own life and quit judging people.. That is Gods job!!


  • Name: Chaela
    Date posted: 2008-11-09 1:44 AM
    Hometown: Arlington

    Comment:

    I think you who judge are all wrong. We have come so far and are still held back by the few IDIOTS who think they have the right to judge other people because they are "PERFECT" Worry about YOUR OWN life, actions, decisions and mistakes. Leave people alone with their own. If you cant then I hope someday some thing is publisized about your life so you can be the lovely reciever of your fellow IDIOTS and their judgement.


  • Name: Desiree
    Date posted: 2008-11-08 2:33 PM
    Hometown: Lamar, AR

    Comment:

    I agree with many people on here. Thomas Beatie is NOT a man. Thomas might of gotten rid of the breasts and grew a beard but she doesn't have the MALE parts. Pregnancy is for WOMEN not men anyway. A man does not have a uterus. A man does not produce eggs. So it is not a man who was pregnant, is was a woman with issues with her body. Your born who you are. Just because she decided to keep her female parts does not make this historical.


  • Name: Dana
    Date posted: 2008-11-02 12:11 PM
    Hometown: Winnsboro,LA

    Comment:

    i dont regret all the stuff i said on here n ill never take it back..... i said ill never accept the fact that this is the 1st pregnant man n i never will n i think thats how God reacted when he saw n heard bout this so yeah i think wut i saids right


  • Name: T
    Date posted: 2008-11-01 11:46 PM
    Hometown: Boise

    Comment:

    This is still a woman. She still has two X chromosomes which means this individual is a SHE. That's all I wanted to say. SHE can do whatever she likes but what about the proper development of the baby? I'm sure her endocrinologist was consulted in regards to her hormone supplements upon news of her pregnancy. Hopefully her hormone levels were readjusted and conducive with carrying out a healthy pregnancy. The smallest thing, such as folic acid deficiency, could have horrible results. Whatever this woman wants to do with her body is up to her. However, her child's physical (and soon psychological) development should be monitored appropriately. I guess I had more to say, after all.


  • Name: Angela
    Date posted: 2008-10-30 1:44 PM
    Hometown: Tucson

    Comment:

    To all the 'christians' that posted and told this person how horrible and wrong he is to do what he did, shame on you! We were told not to judge people who don't believe in the same way that we do. And yet that's what drives so many people to dislike our faith. This man's decision was his, and not your, decision. His 'morality' is his choice.


  • Name: L.
    Date posted: 2008-10-26 1:40 AM
    Hometown: Hoboken

    Comment:

    People on this site that have commented so negatively have completely shocked me. I didn't think I would ever come across such horrid scum existing in this world. How can you ever wish cancer or death to a child and its mother, regardless of whether she wants to live as a man? Wishing such ill things to any human being just proves that the ones who don't deserve to be in this world are you. What is the big deal? His wife can't have a baby, so he did. No one should worry if the child will be confused as they grow. There are so many horrible people out there who come from heterosexual couples: Murderers, rapists, hetero parents who neglect their children or abuse them until they die. Many homosexual/transgendered couples raise children who are intelligent, happy and most turn out to be heterosexual. So, I think that this ignorance needs to be addressed, because as humans we should move forward. You should all be ashamed of yourselves.


  • Name: chevy
    Date posted: 2008-10-19 5:10 PM
    Hometown: brooklyn

    Comment:

    A man can't get pregnant because he doesn't have the female reproductive organs to go through with the process. He is a woman wanting to be man and that is wrong. it clearly shows that she doesn't like what god has made her as. Is she really happy? She spend most of her time defending the relationship than actually enjoying it. She doesn't know what she missing, the real company of man. God loves the sinner but hate the sin.


  • Name: Dana
    Date posted: 2008-10-19 9:30 AM
    Hometown: Winnsboro,LA

    Comment:

    tina: u should know the difference b-tween a male n a female.. the female has the babies n the male gets her pregnant so this 'man' is actually a female cuz 'he' has a vagina.... got it?


  • Name: KT
    Date posted: 2008-10-14 12:34 AM
    Hometown: KS

    Comment:

    She is not a man, but only took hormones to make herself appear like a man. She still has all her female parts so I don't understand the fascination of all this. Technically, not a man so I think it would be false to say that is a pregnant man just because legally the government says she is. Good for her, having a child with her partner. No hate on that but seriously just stop with the pregnant man title.


  • Name: Tina
    Date posted: 2008-10-13 11:29 PM
    Hometown: Denver

    Comment:

    Back to topPost a CommentName: Dana Date posted: 2008-10-02 4:51 PM Hometown: Winnsboro,LA Comment: this makes me wanna freakin kill myself!!!!!!!!! Yea ! Please do !


  • Name: Miss Jenny
    Date posted: 2008-10-07 10:22 AM
    Hometown: Ft. Lauderdale

    Comment:

    i think what he's doing is wonderful


  • Name: Loopy Lulu
    Date posted: 2008-10-04 7:05 PM
    Hometown: London

    Comment:

    I can't believe in this day and age people are so upset by this..what the hell? They are just a couple who want to have a baby. It's only bible bashers and guys with insecurities about their own masculinity who feel threatened by this. Grow up already - live and let live i say...


  • Name: weatherchick05
    Date posted: 2008-10-02 5:38 PM
    Hometown: Winnsboro,LA

    Comment:

    rico: she wuz so pretty b4 all this ..... idk y she didnt wanna stay a woman cuz id like 2 b in beauty pageants n wouldve so traded bein ordinary 4 that in like 3 secs! mayb shes crazy ..... id like 2 take the baby n raise it myself even though im in college n only 18..... id even change her name cuz susan sounds old ........ i like marina better


  • Name: same gurl who said this story made her wanna kill herself
    Date posted: 2008-10-02 5:07 PM
    Hometown: same town as the gurl i mentioned above

    Comment:

    this is so stupid! this is somethin yall shouldve learned when yall were 3 ..... the difference b-tween a male n a female ..... "thomas" is a woman named tracy n cheryl wut u said wuz so nasty! u have 2 b a lesbian 2 think shes attractive like she is....... i still havent accepted this n never will !


  • Name: Dana
    Date posted: 2008-10-02 4:51 PM
    Hometown: Winnsboro,LA

    Comment:

    this makes me wanna freakin kill myself!!!!!!!!!


  • Name: hershey
    Date posted: 2008-10-01 10:29 AM
    Hometown: dookysville

    Comment:

    ok i dont know how hard you where dropped on your head when you where younger but guys males you know the ones with the rooster and the eggs arent surpose to have kids alright and do you know how confused that kid is going to be its going to be asked like whos your dad whos ur mom and hes going to say both times you thats going to be kind of weird and waite till he gets older like in high school thats going to suck and where is te baby going to come from your buthole cause man only doo doo is surpose to come out of there but man if you want that type of pain power to ya not really i think your dum but idiot and YOUR SICK you mess up the meaning of man.


  • Name: homie
    Date posted: 2008-10-01 10:27 AM
    Hometown: l town

    Comment:

    ok...so i think your an idiot. your probably the sickest person ive ever seen! and thats no lie. i think that if your sick enough to do this then your also the gayest man alive. the reason guys are on this earth is so we can help the girls make the baby. not CARRY it!!!! THATS THE GIRLS JOB!! SO GET A LIFE AND STOP THIS CRAP. OR DIE!!


  • Name: Tyler Hipsher
    Date posted: 2008-09-30 10:31 AM
    Hometown: Omaha

    Comment:

    If this transgender FREAK did not want the negitivity then they should have not gone on 60 minutes looking for publicity. Say "No Comment" walk away and then people like me won't have to tell you all how disgusting this is. The United States can give too many people too many rights they should not have. You are right people can do whatever they want, but when your freakish ways come to light, don't be pissed when other people say they hope you and your baby get cancer or get in a car wreck. I just can't believe that there are actually people out there that take this FREAKS side. Well, I guess those people are probably FREAKS themselves so I guess it makes since. Do the world a favor and kill yourself. Thanks in adavance...


  • Name: Emily
    Date posted: 2008-09-29 2:57 PM
    Hometown: NY

    Comment:

    Did your mom ever said to you if you do not have some thing nice to say do not say anything. In this case in implies and everyone has the right to do anything they like. I do not tell you how to rase your children (if you have) do I. And I am glad taht he is pregnant and is having a healthy girl. SO LEAVE THEM ALONE AND LIFE YOUR LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


  • Name: kim
    Date posted: 2008-09-26 3:13 PM
    Hometown: south carolina

    Comment:

    First of all I want to say is congrats on your baby! But the thing I have a problem with is everyone saying "first pregnant man" Yeah you look like a man but REAL men can't birth children. You still have the Female organs that allowed you to carry a baby. So all of this is not history in the making. You are just another women who had a child that all.


  • Name: Meg
    Date posted: 2008-09-24 6:15 AM
    Hometown: Phoenix

    Comment:

    This IS amazing. It's just a shame that what's supposed to be the happiest time in a couples' life, all this negativity was thrown at you.


  • Name: Paige
    Date posted: 2008-09-23 8:42 PM
    Hometown: Perth

    Comment:

    I think this is amazing and everyone should just get over it boo hoo if god didn't want women or men to have children he wouldn't have let the technology develop this far!! I think god wants human beings to evolve and change like this with roles and stereotypes to change!! everyone should have an open mind and shame on you if you criticize this new life----- people should just accept, get over it and be happy that a baby is coming into the world


  • Name: Camielle
    Date posted: 2008-09-21 1:06 PM
    Hometown: Los Angeles

    Comment:

    why r u not happy wat with wat our lord and savior Jesus Christ gave u? u r NOT a man! Jesus meant for u to b a woman! y r u not happy with that? that being said... u r probably NOT a Christian!


  • Name: poop nugget
    Date posted: 2008-09-18 11:53 AM
    Hometown: Your Mom Arsehole

    Comment:

    this is illegible wtf??? here is my response below... "god din't gave u a brayn wyph whitfch 2 theenk so why u tryi bodder???? Are people really that effing stupid? Really???? You are retarded!


  • Name: PJ
    Date posted: 2008-09-17 12:21 AM
    Hometown: Orlando

    Comment:

    The only aspect of this situation that would cause me to pause is what their choice does for the transgender community. The road a transgendered person must travel is already a difficult one, especially the legallity and the personal accptance involved. I feel that using his original biology when it suites his needs seriously damages the credibility the transgendered community had struggle to obtain. If he truly wanted to be accepted as a male, then accept the limitations that would apply to every other male. When a straight couple cannot conceive for various reasons, they adopt or hire a surrogate. I understand and empathize with the desire for the child to be biologically related to the parents, but i don't agree that they should compromise the integrity his community has fought so hard for. Bottom line, if you are a man, then you are a man. I feel that this could be conceived as a setback for the transgendered community.


  • Name: Tux
    Date posted: 2008-09-16 9:01 PM
    Hometown: Corpus Christi

    Comment:

    I see no way for them to call this the "First Mal Pregnancy," considering Lee is originally a female. Now if they implanted an embryo into a true born male then that would be something completely different. This is like dressing a cat like a dog and being amazed that it had kittens. Now I have nothing against anyone having a child, I am a firm believer in equal rights for all provided that they be able to provide an adequate home for the child because I do agree there are some parents who do not deserve to have a blessing like a child, but I don't see this conception as anything but a media sensation. This falls into the same category as Paris Hilton and a run in with the law or some sex scandal involving a celebrity. The media makes this seem like a joke and everyone is just eating it up and acting surprised. Read a science book so that way you can actually know something that is a real break through. Not something that the media is jumping on to make a few millions.


  • Name: Lauren
    Date posted: 2008-09-15 8:44 PM
    Hometown: Lake Odessa

    Comment:

    i dont understand why his life and his child has anything to do with you. i understand that you have the right to say what you want but i dont understand why you would put someone down like that. this world is changing everyday and soon cars will fly!!! is just new and we understand some people wont know how to take it...but dont hurt others in the proses. i wish the family all the best!


  • Name: Lauren
    Date posted: 2008-09-15 8:43 PM
    Hometown: Lake Odessa

    Comment:

    i dont understand why his life and his child has anything to do with you. i understand that you have the right to say what you want but i dont understand why you would put someone down like that. this world is changing everyday and soon cars will fly!!! is just new and we understand some people wont know how to take it...but dont hurt others in the proses. i wish the family all the best!


  • Name: varga
    Date posted: 2008-09-15 2:19 AM
    Hometown: manila,Phil...

    Comment:

    well!!!!!are u not contented or happy with wat GOD had given u????God created u 2 b a woman,4 he has a purpose,right??????den why do u nid to changed evrything?????


  • Name: Angela
    Date posted: 2008-09-11 2:50 AM
    Hometown: NYC

    Comment:

    To you all simple minds....come on..anonymous good for you in saying how embarrassed this child will be...NOOOOO you are so wrong...men as well have the desire to start a family..there are plenty of gay couples and to say more on a language that speaks to you Heterosexual couples that are unable to produce and offspring but are still having the desire to start a family...suppose you are opposed to adoption as well..? Open your mind and quit being so intimidated by other human beings...because thats really what it comes down to...if there are people whom are will to bring a life into the world and embrace it with love then amazing...i would say "god bless" but frankly in your terms its rather distorted. Human rights look it up.


  • Name: Ziggy
    Date posted: 2008-09-03 6:22 PM
    Hometown: London

    Comment:

    And...what's so amazing about this? Oh yes, that the mum is hairy and has no boobs... This is NOT a man but a "man looking lady", since she has a vagina although I think if this is what makes them happy it's fair enough. I just think the whole publicity bit is a bit out of order. To all of those saying this is against God, does God say you can't chop your breasts off and cut your hair and still have a baby? He had sex with a virgin who already had a boyfriend so he might go to hell too though... Good luck to the mums of the baby! xxx


  • Name: anonymous
    Date posted: 2008-08-31 10:29 PM
    Hometown: las vegas

    Comment:

    Thomas Beatie is a woman who wants to be a man, and clearly isn't so sure about that either. It is not a male desire to get pregnant and bear children. It is also not a male desire to compete in a beauty pageant for women. It is not a male function to become impregnated and carry a baby to term. Only a woman can do that. I long for the days when society stops being so politically correct and calls a spade a spade-whether the spade wants to be called a spade or not. I also long for the days when the law gets tough on conmen freak shows by making it tougher for someone to legally change their gender. Any female to male change must involve the removal of both breasts and uterus. Case closed. I can't imagine how embarrassed that child will be by its "father" who is actually and most unfortunately it's mother.


  • Name: Heather Sharpe
    Date posted: 2008-08-30 4:19 AM
    Hometown: Eau Claire

    Comment:

    Her choice to try changing her sex and body, as well as the lie that she is telling herself is all just her way of dealing with mental trauma from some experience.She needs to get her life right before God, just as all of us do.We ALL have problems, but it becomes a much larger, more dangerous problem when people bring children into their twisted, perverted, sinful lives.Sexual abuse and child molestation absolutely reigns in gay relationships.They can ruin each other's lives as much as they please but the moment they brought an innocent, perfect child into their disgusting lives they became murderers and child abusers.That is why doctors would not help or support these sick women.Someone needs to step in and give this child a normal life.This perfect baby did absolutely nothing to deserve this kind of abnormal, hopeless upbringing!


  • Name: Loz
    Date posted: 2008-08-29 8:55 AM
    Hometown: Wollongong

    Comment:

    Congratulations of course, you guys have sure been through alot in falling pregnant and I'm glad in the end it's all worked out. In response to some of the other comments, I don't think whether Thomas is male or female here is really relevant, that's not what makes this news. What makes this news is the fact that world wide it's the first transgendered person who is legally male to fall pregnant. Whether or not you agree with this I think it's a pretty big thing for Thomas and his family to share the experience, especially KNOWING the anger they might be met with. All that aside, as far as I'm concerned if Thomas feels he is male, he is male. I;m stunned by how many people have insisted on referring to him as "her" is there comments, it's pure ignorance. Best of luck with everything you guys, I think what you're doing is amazing, and that sharing it is a really big thing for all of the world, not just the transgender community.


  • Name: Whatever
    Date posted: 2008-08-18 12:27 AM
    Hometown: Flint, MI

    Comment:

    Ummm... I'm kinda confused about what is so spectacular or unique about a baby being grown and delivered from the uterus that you happened to be born with. The fact that she has a uterus means it's not really a big deal for her to have a baby from that uterus. Now, if her wife without a uterus had a baby, that would be amazing. Too bad so much senseless hype was made over something ordinary.


  • Name: Jan
    Date posted: 2008-08-10 10:39 PM
    Hometown: Madison, WI

    Comment:

    People magazine covered your story at six months of the pregnancy and I kept copies for my 1st granddaughter's baby book (born 8/4)....in the what's happened in the world when I was born section.... and in my son's wedding (8/23) album under the same section. Now I'm waiting for the follow up in People on the birth of the baby to learn the news and be happy for them and also to complete these albums with the stories....will it happen? I'm really anxious for the follow up story. Thanks- JH


  • Name: Jack
    Date posted: 2008-08-09 2:25 AM
    Hometown: Campbellsport, WI

    Comment:

    The comments on this story reflect a bigotry against transpeople which makes me physically and psychologically ill. This is the ADVOCATE! Not Focus on the Family Times or some crap. So get over it and respect the fact that Thomas and HIS wife have overcome a lot of strife to complete their family.


  • Name: Kallibell
    Date posted: 2008-08-04 1:49 AM
    Hometown: Alabama

    Comment:

    Thomas, will you be able to breastfeed after the previous breast surgery(ies) that you have had? Is Nancy interested in breastfeeding your child? Even women that have gone through hysterectomies, menopause, surrogacy, adoption, etc. can breastfeed their babies. Google "adoptive breastfeeding" or "Inducing a milk supply". Peace & Blessings.


  • Name: Jamie
    Date posted: 2008-08-01 12:13 PM
    Hometown: Warwick

    Comment:

    I don't understand why or how this has gotten the publicity it has, Beatie is a WOMEN that is it ( born with female part's, ex. reproductive organ's a vagina) , bottom line,He has taken it upon himself to construct different part's under the hood that's fine however WOMEN have children, period. I"d love to see a MAN bear a child, now that would be something!


  • Name: TJ
    Date posted: 2008-08-01 3:16 AM
    Hometown: Portland, OR

    Comment:

    Congratulations on the baby, and for entering mother/fatherhood. It's sad that people (who probably claim they are 'Christian') leave hateful comments, but you know what's right for you. I personally think it would be cool if Thomas completed the gender (genital) re-assignment, unless the plan is to have another baby. However, I hope you find peace and quiet after the attention. Thank you for bringing light to your story.


  • Name: Forbidden Angel
    Date posted: 2008-07-29 11:08 AM
    Hometown: South Africa

    Comment:

    Why can't people just accept it? I mean it's your right entirely to have a child of your own. Honestly I admire you... I am a woman and I have Tocophobia, thus I will probably never have a child of my own. You have more guts than most people in this world. It's none of their business anyway. All the best Thomas. I wish there were more people like you in the world!


  • Name: Cheryl
    Date posted: 2008-07-29 12:10 AM
    Hometown: Great Falls, Montana

    Comment:

    First off, I want to say CONGRATULATIONS to you both! You have a BEAUTIFUL baby, and you are one hell of a husband for going through the pregnancy for your wife! On another note, it doesn't matter if you're man or woman. You're completely right, it is a HUMAN desire to want children. Furthermore, my father is transgender, he didnt tell anyone until most of us kids were grown. Although he is making the transition from man to woman, I've learned that people are still people, no matter what the race or orientation. And I fully support your decision. And I must say, I think you make a pretty attractive male!!!!!


  • Name: K
    Date posted: 2008-07-28 1:58 AM
    Hometown: Eugene

    Comment:

    Wow, are some of these comments tremendously disappointing. Listen up: there's a difference between the words 'gender' and 'sex'. Sure, we all want to cling to the pedestal we place human biology on, but ultimately, its the independence of mind that dictates what gender one happens to be. As a species, we have been socialized to generate norms to make ourselves more comfortable with our surroundings, but that doesn't make anything concrete. If your really so concerned about the subject of a couple who loves one another and the daughter they've brought into the world, put down your Bibles and pick up some Judith Butler for a change. Expand your minds, quit settling for 'comfortable'. You demean your apparently 'god given' soul if you refuse to seek out the lifetimes worth of knowledge on this earth that happens to be at your disposal. Even your good book begs you to 'question everything'. Don't ever think that ends at what you feel threatened by.


  • Name: Cassandra S. Reed
    Date posted: 2008-07-27 12:26 PM
    Hometown: Orange, CA

    Comment:

    I could sit here and argue my thoughts like the majority of people, but it's obviously already happening so there isn't much point in fighting against it even if I wanted to.. so.. congrats to you and Nancy, Mr. Beatie!


  • Name: Shauny
    Date posted: 2008-07-27 11:27 AM
    Hometown: perth

    Comment:

    Uh, beatie is a woman. period. Not a surprise for a woman to give birth. a real man bearing a child. that's news to me! Wonder if it could happen.


  • Name: Maranda
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 6:47 PM
    Hometown: Aton

    Comment:

    I completely agree with Chanel Parker! I can't imagine what she (Thomas) has gone through after the birth. All those hormons are dumping in her body. I'm sure her body doesn't know what to think. I"m sure eventually this child could reap some kind of defect from all of the testosterone she took too. I'm glad you got your 15 min fame Thomas, but honestly when people contradict themselves, like what your doing, people tend not to take you serious. If you say your a man, and then you have a baby, you're contradicting yourself, and I just have to laugh.


  • Name: Lea
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 2:26 PM
    Hometown: Riverdale Bx

    Comment:

    Where R All The People With Brains?


  • Name: Lea
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 2:21 PM
    Hometown: Riverdale Bx

    Comment:

    Where r all the people with brains?


  • Name: Lea
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 2:20 PM
    Hometown: Riverdale Bx

    Comment:

    Where r all the people with brains?


  • Name: Lea
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 2:19 PM
    Hometown: Riverdale Bx

    Comment:

    Where r all the people with brains?


  • Name: Jacob Cape
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 12:27 PM
    Hometown: St. Petersburg

    Comment:

    I cannot believe everyone has so many differing opinions about this. Thomas Beatie is a woman. Having female reproductive organs and no male reproductive organs makes a person a female. Regardless of the other physically altering medical procedures (having breasts removed/flattened) and hormones taken (testosterone), this person is still a woman. Give any woman testosterone and flatten their breasts and they will still be a woman. Are we to suppose this person is a man because she has a beard?? That is the only reason people would even think to question this woman's gender. Shame on Oprah, who must have been losing in the afternoon ratings war to even think to put this joke of a lesbian couple on her show and help to publicize this pregnant woman who looks like a man. Shame on the rest of the US and world for even thinking this is news...what a sad state of affairs.


  • Name: -enitsirk-
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 11:21 AM
    Hometown: New York

    Comment:

    You people who gives comments to this couple is your right..... i know it is your opinion/insult but then again..i wonder if you look upon yourself.. people using the lesson teach by God doesnt really have the knowledge behind of it.. yes it is true that God created a male and female to distinguish physical appearance but God created Human to this world to understand what God intend to tell us. God judge us what we are currently doing to our life in way he loves us but you people doesnt have that capability we are merely human and for those people who think that if a person is a freak then they are also a freak cause they dont understand why certain person choose his/her what life he/she want to have. People have NO RIGHT to judge what other people want to pursue its own happiness in a good way. Thomas want to be happy and that is the life he/she wants to have. Let's be happy for this family


  • Name: Melissa Baxter
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 10:52 AM
    Hometown: Hamilton, Ohio

    Comment:

    Congrats Thomas, I am so happy for you!!!! I hope you and your beautiful daughter and wife have a wonderful life!!! I have two children myself and they are my world!. I think its awesome that you and your wife decided to have a child. Again for you! You are an innovator. This may open some doors for people who cannot have children, maybe their husbands can instead. That would truely be something to be thankful for! Goddess Bless you and your Family!!!


  • Name: Tyl er Hipsher
    Date posted: 2008-07-26 10:42 AM
    Hometown: Omaha

    Comment:

    I hope this freak and his baby die...Why didn't the doctors, the us government, anybody that could have stopped this atrocity should have. Burn in hell!!!


  • Name: andrew
    Date posted: 2008-07-24 8:50 AM
    Hometown: manila,philippines

    Comment:

    When we were born in this world. we did not chose to be a boy or a girl. We already have a gender not a preference. It would be your option how to behappy and how to deal with it.I would say i don't care what people say, im not hurting them and even im not feeding them. These couple just wanted to be happy and satisfied.And when your satisfied you're happy.and when you're happy you're satisfied. For those people who keeps on degrading these couple,you better open your mind now,because if God dosn't loves us,then why did he let created the homosexuals and bisexauls?


  • Name: Amber Lane
    Date posted: 2008-07-23 8:02 PM
    Hometown: Fort Worth, TX

    Comment:

    I know this is not something you will want to hear or accept but what you have chosen to do is sick and perverted. Women are created with the intention of bearing children. What on earth would ever suppose that the same role should be given to a man when you have MADE it happen? God created you to be a woman and bear a child...it is that simple. What you have done offends God and again, I know you wont want to hear that. But I want you to know that I have prayed for you, that you will discover truth and let it reign as the authority in your life. GOD'S TRUTH. The ONLY truth. Creator God is forgiving, but will not give His glory to another...especially that which He CREATED.


  • Name: Not Your Mama
    Date posted: 2008-07-23 7:33 PM
    Hometown: Sucky IRAN

    Comment:

    What a freak--just plain weird!


  • Name: ladalang
    Date posted: 2008-07-23 5:56 PM
    Hometown: Lorain

    Comment:

    What's the big deal? based on Thomas' body, he's still is a woman, although his gender identity is male. If he doesn't have the male reproductive genitalia it just becomes two women together, but for outward appearances he looks like a man. Lots of people walk around looking like the opposite sex, it isn't a crime. Granted for Thomas identifying himself as a man while having the reproductive body of a woman is his choice, it shouldn't matter to anyone. He's like a hermaphrodite only by choice. We don't know enough about the human body and brain and all it's possible configurations so who's to say this is right or wrong for him? It reminds me of the Seinfeld episode where the guy wants to be called "Maestro". If Thomas wants to be called "man", let him, he isn't hurting anyone...


  • Name: wave09
    Date posted: 2008-07-23 5:40 PM
    Hometown: phils

    Comment:

    yay! i can't believe this is happening...... God introduce only male and female don't go beyond God's decision.... but anyway, it's your life, it's up to you how you manage and draw it... God is just watching.....


  • Name: Krystle
    Date posted: 2008-07-23 5:06 PM
    Hometown: san jose

    Comment:

    i am still so confused as to how a man can have a baby i mean i have always prayed for it to be possible but never thought in my generation it would come true i am sooo happy for the both of you i hope your baby stays strong and healthy! CONGRADULATIONS!


  • Name: sa005388
    Date posted: 2008-07-23 9:54 AM
    Hometown: vienna

    Comment:

    I think that it is hard enough that the family and friends of this couple are not supportive of their actions without having the rest of the world on their backs as well. Every baby is a gift from God and this little girl will be no different. God's Word tells us that He spoke us into our mother's womb. IF she was not meant to be born, she would not be here. She is a special unique gift to this loving couple and God has a plan for her life and future. May they enjoy each and every day with her and for those who are pointing fingers in judgment, there is only one judge and He sits on His throne in Heaven and will judge your words, deeds and actions one day. You will have to give an account. Congratulations to the parents for the life of the little girl.


  • Name: Monique
    Date posted: 2008-07-23 9:00 AM
    Hometown: Grand Haven

    Comment:

    You know. After reading some of the comments, I'm disappointed in some of you. You say that this is against God's Will. Let me ask you, who gave YOU the RIGHT to judge others? No one. Why should it matter if you are a man or woman? There are Hetrosexual couples who mistreate children, but you don't get on their case. No, cause they arn't ' sinful. ' You decided to point fingers at something that is different, Because you are afraid. You never once thought about the child. His wife couldn't have a child. Science allows us now to gives those who weren't able to carry a child, be able to have one of their own. You bitch about this, simply being it's a transexual caring their child. This is the 21st century, times are changing. God doesn't rule the planet, we make our own future. So, for you people who say it's against God's Will, check again. It's against YOUR WILL, GET OVER IT. Oh, Congrats to the happy couple. I wish you the best


  • Name: 17 years old
    Date posted: 2008-07-22 11:30 PM
    Hometown: Washington d.c

    Comment:

    Why is this type of behavior being applauded? This woman chose 2 b a man. Now God makes no mistakes! The way u are created in the body that u r in is the way God intends for u 2 b. In the bible, which is the laws of God says that homosexuality is a abomination to God. Ok grant it we have a choice to decide our own fate. When u r born u r born with a gender not a preference, for those who are born gay and didnt choose to be that way. If that b the case then we would not need parents to decide things 4 us. Furthermore this woman went through massive surgeries to become a man that obviously she would never be even with her hormone injections. This baby will not get the benefits of being breast feed. Feelings have an important role in the human life. We base our lives off of emotions or the way that we feel. There is a big difference between luv and lust some people just cant tell which is which. For the sake of the child I wish them the best success because that baby is our future.


  • Name: CC
    Date posted: 2008-07-21 2:02 PM
    Hometown: Phoenix

    Comment:

    Congratulations to you both. I am terribly sorry for the issues you had to go thru in order to conceive a child. It would have been so easy for the medical community to assist you in this process but obviously there is the family value issue that many people deal with. As a hetro wife and mother I applaud you both and express my joy at the birth of your new daughter. May she grow and bask in your love and support. May she grow to be as tolerant as my husband and I hope our own children will be. May she know that she is special, wanted and be secure in that knowledge. Blessings on you and your family! And may the gods have mercy on those who ignorantly object!


  • Name: Santy DJ
    Date posted: 2008-07-21 12:35 AM
    Hometown: Hawaii

    Comment:

    I have no problem with homosexuality or people wanting to become transgendered however I do feel that if a woman wants to become a man then she gives up all rights a woman has, including the ability to become pregnant and give birth. The fact that Thomas had a sex change but decided to still want to carry a child sounds hypocritical to me. You want to be a man then be a man - getting pregnant and giving birth is not part of that package and a right you gave up when you had that sex change. I only hope God has mercy on your soul.


  • Name: Abdirahman
    Date posted: 2008-07-20 10:29 PM
    Hometown: Sundsvall

    Comment:

    It is good to respect one's perception, beliefs and values however, the most important thing that must keep in our minds is that religion play an important role in the universe. This universe was not created for playing, abusing the creation of the creator and to humiliate the nature of the creator. God has chosen man and women to be who they are not be who they want to be. I am not surprised with this weird couple but I really feel very sorry for the newly born daughter of the this couples. I would say the world must be very tolerant to the child and if we must do that then me must see these couples normal and hope that they will change back one day. Regards,


  • Name: Dinah Leavitt
    Date posted: 2008-07-16 8:57 PM
    Hometown: Tampa

    Comment:

    I want to say that I am a catholic first of all, but I do recognize that my beliefs diverge a bit from the general populace of catholics. I like to believe that it is good to be tolerant and kind to all people no matter what they believe or how they choose to live. I applaud this couple's brave decision and hope that society can begin to progress with more people like them. I extend my congratulations to their new baby and wish them happiness and tolerance in the difficult time ahead.


  • Name: Brandy
    Date posted: 2008-07-16 11:42 AM
    Hometown: Oregon

    Comment:

    Sounds to me like some "Christians" have been sleeping in church and are in need of opening their Bible and reading Galatians 5:13-26 What ever happened to: Matthew 7? In verses 1-5, it clearly states that one shouldn't pass judgement on another. If God had not wanted this little girl to be born, then it wouldn't have happened. How dare you make this wonderful new creation of our Lord into someone who will feel unwanted and unloved by society just because one of her parents is different from the majority. Hopefully she will understand just how much she is wanted and loved by not only her parents but also by TRUE Christains.


  • Name: Lee
    Date posted: 2008-07-16 8:13 AM
    Hometown: Exeter, UK

    Comment:

    This can be simplified a lot, but also too much. It seems very complicated, but at the end of the day two people, male or female, are having a baby. I would think the only concern is for the welfare of the future child. I hope everything works out well and that the prejudice we see here is never directed at the girl. Perhaps a small part of the problem here is language and identity - he, she or ...? What pronoun is gender neutral? What is the singular for "they"? I'm not worried about most minor details, I would suggest that sensationalist media has created a lot of confusion: "Pregnant Man"? What exactly is a man or woman? We have relied on biology for catagorisation for so long but now we need some flexibility in the English language (and probably other languages as well). So many more important issues, obviously, but I thought I'd raise this one.


  • Name: L.Yasin
    Date posted: 2008-07-15 10:18 AM
    Hometown: Austin

    Comment:

    Congrats to them. It was established a long time ago that men could carry a baby...they just had to have the baby feed off their intestinal wall to have the placenta get the blood flow. They just aren't built for it though. The birth would have to be by c-section and they would eventually have to be watched as they don't have a uterus to protect their organs. The haters are the same people that complain about anything outside their little worlds...transgendered, homosexual, straight there is one thing that all people have in common...if you are taught to hate you hate, if you are taught to love..well you know what I mean.


  • Name: Kirsten
    Date posted: 2008-07-15 2:09 AM
    Hometown: Bethlehem

    Comment:

    I absolutely agree with amanda. They could have adopted a child. There are thousands out there who need parents.


  • Name: Nathalie
    Date posted: 2008-07-14 4:32 AM
    Hometown: Groesbeek, The Netherlands

    Comment:

    I feel sorry for all the over-simplified, blunt and short-sighted people who post their insulting comment here.. Why does everything has to do with god and 'how-it-should-be'? Why is it so extremely difficult to understand that there are people who feel, think and act different then you do? They don't judge you for your believes, so don't judge them. And how can it be wrong that people are born with that kind of feelings, since you claim that birth is a gift from god??? If all of that is wrong, than there wouldn't be homosexuals or transgenders or others who differ from the 'devine plan'. Your live can be so much better if you could just make a little more place for 'other' people. Irritation and anger takes years off of your live.. I am a 23 year old straight woman with an open look into the world, which gives me al lot of pleasure and love. Too bad that not everyone has that. it would make the world a little bit better..


  • Name: Amanda
    Date posted: 2008-07-11 9:59 PM
    Hometown: Pittsburgh

    Comment:

    This is absolutely disguisting! And I am not hater! I have no problem w/ homosexuality or 2 gay parents raising a family. And while I don't understand trans-gender problems...I can still support them. But...when you make a choice to become a male...THEN YOU BE MALE! You can't have it both ways! Be a MALE b/c u feel trapped..while I don't understand, it's not my place to. But when you involve children! I'm sorry but I work in the medical field and see too much confusion for these kids already! I have no doubt they can raise a healthy baby...


  • Name: Seantae
    Date posted: 2008-07-11 8:29 PM
    Hometown: Central Point

    Comment:

    What everyone needs to understand that Thomas Beattie is not a man, she is a woman. Furthermore, before her surgery to make herself appear male she was not a man trapped in a woman's body. It is not natural for her to feel sexually attracted to women and it is not okay. Her partner is not her wife and is also very morally off-track for having sex with a woman who has desecrated her body. God did not intend for any of this to be possible. It is nothing to be congradulated for.


  • Name: Anne
    Date posted: 2008-07-10 12:50 AM
    Hometown: San Francisco

    Comment:

    If you read the story, Thomas got pregnant because Nancy could not. So sad there are people as hateful and rigid as you in the world. I hope and pray their sweet baby daughter will not encounter the likes of you.


  • Name: Christie
    Date posted: 2008-07-08 2:30 PM
    Hometown: Nova Scotia, Canada

    Comment:

    Congratulations on the birth of your new daughter Nancy and Thomas. As you both complete this chapter, and dive into parenthood, this ever growing child will never need to question the love you both have for her. In fact - it will probably seem most clear to her. Parent advice? Enjoy every exhausting moment! Chris


  • Name: Prof. T. P. Verma
    Date posted: 2008-07-08 6:14 AM
    Hometown: Varanasi India

    Comment:

    I am excited to hear Thomas Beatie giving birth to a child. It is simply because we have an instance in the Puranic historical annals thousands of years ago. The legendary First Man Manu had a female child who was transformed to a man. But again he became female to give birth to a male child. It is stated that periodically he changed his sex. As a man he begot three male children who became king. But her son Pururavas became a legendary king from whom at least seven dynasties of India had sprung. Mr/Mrs Thomas has proved that Puranic legend true. My congratulations. TPV


  • Name: Mz. Understood
    Date posted: 2008-07-07 10:54 PM
    Hometown: St. Louis

    Comment:

    I think it is freakin ridiculous. If SHE wanted to have a baby one day and be a MOTHER then SHE should have kept her breasts and live like the WOMAN that she wants to be. All this praise is a bunch of bull. If it were your MOTHERS claiming to be a man and having a child every single last one of you would be at your highest levels of pisstivity. I know I would so I am not even going to wish congrats and be all smiley cuz I think it is not only disgusting but unnatural and crazy.


  • Name: Georgia
    Date posted: 2008-07-05 10:47 PM
    Hometown: Dallas, Texas

    Comment:

    You people don't get that it's wonderful to be pregnant! I'm happy for this couple, it doesn't matter who carries the child!


  • Name: Sarah
    Date posted: 2008-07-05 10:11 PM
    Hometown: Denver

    Comment:

    All y'all haters need to stop trippin! Big up to happy couple! Congratulations from Denver:)


  • Name: Rico
    Date posted: 2008-07-05 2:11 PM
    Hometown: Orange County

    Comment:

    She is still a woman, isn't she? It is only in appearance that she looks like a man. So, with her being pregnant is a none issue since it is a fact that she is still a woman with her reproductive organs still intact. By the way, she really looks very pretty before her sex change. I saw it on youtube.com


  • Name: Anne
    Date posted: 2008-07-05 7:00 AM
    Hometown: Akron,OH

    Comment:

    The thing that bothers me is the headlines....First man to ever give birth. Thomas Beatie is not a man just because she cut off her breasts, takes testosterone, and dresses like a guy. It is no more a miracle than any other woman that gives birth. She is simply a lesbian that prefers to "look" like a guy. If she has a uterua ans vagina she IS a woman. A man has testicles and a penis to which Thomas Beatie does NOT have!!!!


  • Name: Me
    Date posted: 2008-07-05 1:21 AM
    Hometown: Maryland

    Comment:

    No religious objections. No issues with gays or lesbians. No issues with people who feel they are in the wrong body and get that changed. Don't have an issue with wanting to have a child being a natural human feeling and need. Don't have negative things to say about the baby's health. Don't have negative things to say about what all the commotion with do to the child in time. Do have an issue with a fraud. Yes - that's a woman - who's had her breasts removed and takes testosterone to grow a beard calling herself a man. Ok - don't even have a problem with that - her choice, her life. Do have a problem with her getting her 15 minutes of fame with what I see as helping to destroy the strides gays, lesbians, cross dressers, and transgender's have made.


  • Name: Olivia
    Date posted: 2008-07-04 12:09 PM
    Hometown: Frankfurt, Germany

    Comment:

    I think it's all ok to change your sex if you feel you weren't born with the right one. But you should stick to your decision: wanna be a man? Fine, but stay a man and behave as one! You cannot just go back and forth, as it suits you. I mean, who wouldn't like to be a man in one situation and a woman in another?! For that though, we should assume the responsabilities of our gender (given or chosen) and get along with it. I disapprove of this whole story, which is just another proof of human selfishness: so Nancy couldn't have her own babies? So what, go out there and adopt some! There are so many kids without parents, needing our love and attention, but no, we want our own, 'cause what the heck? we can!


  • Name: Susie
    Date posted: 2008-07-04 9:15 AM
    Hometown: Neenah, WI

    Comment:

    I am having a difficult time understanding this situation. I do understand the free will God gave us: Right off the bat Adam messed up in the garden of the Lord, using his free will inappropriately. Just b/c medical advances allow persons to appear to change their sex doesn't mean it's God's will. Some call themselves believers but do so w/o any expectation to live life in Christ. God is God, but we are limited by our own limitations. Our experiences play largely into who we are today & let's face it we all have been in difficult circumstances. I can in my own mind justify anything to be the “truth”. The problem w/that is my judgment is skewed. God is much greater than that– if something is truly God's will it does not have to be explained or argued–it just is. With regard to this entire situation I am sad that we have come to a state where, in our quest to seek happiness & fulfillment we turn so quickly to ourselves instead of to God. Peace be will all of you, friends.


  • Name: Anthony Rashed
    Date posted: 2008-07-04 8:56 AM
    Hometown: Montreal, QC

    Comment:

    This is not a comment; this is a REWARD CLAIME for a 25% of the 10Million BP. which the Queen Of England has Set aside some 10 years ago for any man who gives birth.This is an analogy to some one found a missing Brief case full of money. Then he wanted to give back to its Owner.


  • Name: Sylvia Degen
    Date posted: 2008-07-04 5:54 AM
    Hometown: Berlin

    Comment:

    Congratulations!!! Just read the news that everything went fine - great! Unfortunately, I also read the comments in some of the bigger German online news magazines - uuuuuuuuuuh... Lot's of respect and all the best for the whole family!!!! Sylvi (Berlin, Germany)


  • Name: Snippie
    Date posted: 2008-07-04 4:00 AM
    Hometown: Belgium

    Comment:

    Whether we like it or not whether he/she should or should not have a baby is all very well, but we should be very weary on the effects it has on the child. It is fine to say I am the daddy and she is the mommy, but when the little girl finds out about all the commotion that went around her birth, she might just wish she had a 'normal' family. And especially 'uncle' who says what kind of monster would that be.....words can do a lot of harm!!!! I have no problem with him - actually a woman who looks like a man - but I do have my concerns for the little girl. The world is going mad......


  • Name: Amber
    Date posted: 2008-07-04 2:24 AM
    Hometown: Vancouver, BC

    Comment:

    h my gosh Im so HAPPY for them to stand up and come out and be then selfs what courage. Im so thrilled that they now have a baby girl. They seem like amazing people to begin with and being a parent just makes life more amazing. Alll I can say is that this is so GREAT!


  • Name: Timothy
    Date posted: 2008-07-04 1:48 AM
    Hometown: boston

    Comment:

    When Thomas Beattie decided to become pregnant, then he stopped being a man and became a woman again. This whole notion that a "man" is having a baby is simply rediculous. I am a gay man and I support the transgendered community whole heartedly. I will attend any rally for transgendered rights.. They are our brothers and sisters in the fight for equal rights. However, because we support Thomas Beatie does not mean we get to lose our bloody minds. A transgendered person does not have their chromosomes changed, nor are they able to obtain reproductive organs of the sex they are transitioning to. Once an individual becomes transgendered, We call them man or woman based upon physical appearance, gender roles, and lifestyle. To say that Thomas Beattie is a man having a baby is a rediculous hyperbolic statement. The moment Thomas became pregnant, he became a woman again regardless of his looks and/or lifestyle.


  • Name: Meghan Fogarty
    Date posted: 2008-07-04 12:21 AM
    Hometown: Houston, Tx

    Comment:

    Congratulations on your baby! I am grateful for your courage to share your story. You and your wife are both amazing people. My finance and I have been together for about 3 and 1/2 years, he too is transgendered. The both of us have been able to come out to more people because of your story. Thank you. Sending much love and gratitude to you and your family. - Meghan


  • Name: Blake Holtzapfel
    Date posted: 2008-07-03 10:08 PM
    Hometown: South Point, Ohio

    Comment:

    To Thomas and Nancy, Congrats to you both on your new bundle of joy! I think that your story is inspirational and amazing . A higher power brought your wife and baby to you, and my wife and I are so happy for your happiness b/c that is what the meaning of life is about: kindness to others even when others are not so kind back. Helping others when others are in need w/out asking for anything in return. Forgiving others for wrong doings in hopes that one day we will be forgiven to. Loving others even though they can not find it in their hearts to love us back. This is the meaning of Life in which we are to live and this is what God, or whatever one believes the higher power to be is what is meant for us. Congrats again to you and yours and peace, love, and happiness to you.


  • Name: Bonestructure
    Date posted: 2008-07-03 8:32 PM
    Hometown: Atlanta, GA

    Comment:

    I'm in awe at Thomas and Nancy's courage and dignity in the face of a public examination of this very private matter. His simple statement, "Wanting to have a biological child is neither a male nor female desire, but a human desire" is an undeniable truth, and I'm so happy to think that in the future, a beautiful child of theirs will know just how much she was truly wanted, and is treasured by her loving and happy mother and father.


  • Name: Lindsay Miller
    Date posted: 2008-07-03 7:42 PM
    Hometown: Mountain View, CA

    Comment:

    Gender is not black and white, and the sooner you doubters get over that the happier you'll be. Congratulations Thomas and Nancy on the healthy baby girl!


  • Name: Serita
    Date posted: 2008-07-03 9:46 AM
    Hometown: Johannesburg/South Africa

    Comment:

    I do not judge Thomas and no human being has the right to,God created Tom as a woman thats the reason he is pregnant today what is so surprising about that.?The only thing that people with common sense can do at this point in time is to support him and his family and the coming baby.Much love.


  • Name: Dr. Ashley
    Date posted: 2008-07-02 2:31 AM
    Hometown: India

    Comment:

    i know its quite unnatural for guys to carry babies, kin of wierd that they would be able to feel what we woman feel when carrying babies.....but u know wot guys im a doctor n i had always wanted to experiment someting lik this...now that its happenin in real im jus waitin 4 the results....damn im very curious to knw it....i had wanted men to suffer da way we do while in labour ...but i guess pain is only 4 women......hail the lord.....


  • Name: T.E.B.B.
    Date posted: 2008-06-27 12:25 PM
    Hometown: Greensboro

    Comment:

    Congratulations on the pregnancy Thomas and Nancy! I just want you to know that there are people who support you out there! I'm so appreciative that this has happened. Soon, I'm sure it will happen again and again. I hope that people will remember that our country was not found to be a Christain country; it was founded to be a free country. Some of those founding fathers were actually Unitarian! We as a country did decide on the separation of church and state. I hope that people really think about what it means to CELEBRATE diversity and redefine what you consider to be "normal"! All this couple wants to do is raise a family of their own and be happy. They have that right! Discrimination is an evil thing! Thomas and Nancy, I wish you the best!


  • Name: April a.
    Date posted: 2008-06-26 3:53 PM
    Hometown: Michigan

    Comment:

    I think this a sad case, the Lord God destroyed two cities bcuz of the out -cry of sin was so great. America as whole built this nation on God and his laws and we are destroying every moral value one hy one. When are we as a nation going turn from our wicked and demon like ways. What more does God have to show us that this ungodly and unholy, this the most wicked generation ever. I am praying for America that we turn before we burn in everlasting hell fire.


  • Name: Sihlez
    Date posted: 2008-06-26 6:42 AM
    Hometown: Windsor East, South Africa.

    Comment:

    As a south African i was amazed at first bt as i read this guys story it was simple 4 me 2 understand. He's a she with reproductive organs and an artificial appearance. I dont understand why pple see this differently she's a woman 4 godsake and she can have a healthy baby like all other women. 1 more thing i want 2 say is SHE'S A HUNK AND BIG UP 4ROM DA MOEMISH CREW IN SOUTH AFRICA WINSOR EAST RANDBURG.


  • Name: Chanel Parker
    Date posted: 2008-06-24 3:26 PM
    Hometown: Santa Barbara

    Comment:

    This is not an issue of equal civil rights for the transgender community but rather a question of medical ethics. Thomas has been on testosterone therapy for so many years as to permanently change his physical appearance, even despite the fact he is no longer taking them during the pregnancy. His physical characteristics (the beard, facial features, chest hair) suggest latent amounts of testosterone circulating in his body. Even though physicians told him the pregancy would be fine, there is no accurate method of predicting how these altered hormonal levels will affect the developing fetus, nor can it be ruled out that Thomas' altered hormone levels will not adversely affect fetal development. This is, in effect, a form of human experimentation. While Thomas perfomed the insemination at home (which undermines the medical profession's stamp of approval), clinical providers of IVF should be cautious before allowing this option to other female to male transgender individuals.


  • Name: MUGE CELEBI
    Date posted: 2008-06-24 6:50 AM
    Hometown: ISTANBUL

    Comment:

    Dear Thomas, I’m contacting you as an editor of a Turkish national news paper, Milliyet. We are interesting in your pregnancy. (Pregnant Man) We want to share your experiences with Turkish Public. Because there is so many gay/lesbians who are curious about this “extreme situation”. Can you give us please any contact information to provide us making an phone or email interview (if you accept) Thank you so much Editor, Muge Celebi Milliyet News Paper, Istanbul, Turkey


  • Name: MUGE CELEBI
    Date posted: 2008-06-24 6:45 AM
    Hometown: ISTANBUL

    Comment:

    Dear Thomas, I’m contacting you as an editor of a Turkish national news paper, Milliyet. We are interesting in your pregnancy. We want to share your experiences with Turkish Public. Because there is so many gay/lesbians who are curious about this “extreme situation”. Can you give us please any contact information to provide us making an interview on phone or email.. Waiting for your email... Thank you so much Editor, Muge Celebi Milliyet News Paper, Istanbul, Turkey


  • Name: mary isham
    Date posted: 2008-06-24 1:37 AM
    Hometown: san francisco

    Comment:

    I raised a girl who was born to a man 13 years after surgery and hormone therapy. While it was not a planned pregnancy, this child had two fathers. One was the person who gave birth to her.By the time I entered her life at eight years old there were secrets to be sorted out. I think it is very important to tell the truth and teach the child how he or she can talk about it. This includes teaching adults how to talk about it. and identifying who is safe to talk to about it. The parents can have some impact on how to create the supportive people. This child walked by a man who was her birth parent. Unfortunately, at the time this culture was not ready for this and has its limitation now.


  • Name: Simone
    Date posted: 2008-06-23 4:31 PM
    Hometown: Germany

    Comment:

    Did you read that he's going to write a book about his special pregnancy? I can't wait to read ist. During these days I check the news regularly - if maybe the baby girl is there already. I'd really love to meet this brave couple and to make friends with them. Some minutes ago I saw a video, after an ultrasound - Thomas crying tears of joy. It's unbelieveable, how his brother could have told these first babies (he lost) monsters!! This really makes me starting to cry as well. All my best from Germany again :-)


  • Name: DK
    Date posted: 2008-06-22 9:48 PM
    Hometown: Toronto

    Comment:

    he/she is not a man man doesnt have overies so thats not the characterstic of a man y ppl sayin that shes a man she s a girl by birth changed sex organs doesnt made her 100% man she something b.w man/woman so in my opinion she is preg not he is.


  • Name: ferone kronstein
    Date posted: 2008-06-22 4:13 PM
    Hometown: new westminster, canada

    Comment:

    I first heard about this family from watching the Oprah Show. This is an amazing family. You can feel the love of Nancy and her daughters for Thomas. I wish them a wonderful life with their new baby and the love of family and friends. May their problems be few. I pray that no one hurts this loving family.


  • Name: Bob
    Date posted: 2008-06-21 9:52 PM
    Hometown: NYC

    Comment:

    As I see it, this is not a conflict of whether a person is male-female but whether their decision to raise a family is personal or political. If this were a personal matter, I don't believe I would be seeing it on Oprah or any other media for that matter. The willingness (or desire) of this family to go public with their plans puts their motives in question. They can't pretend to want a safe, secure and autonomous future for their child when they've purposefully made a circus of the event. Sadly, this story is about the parents, not the child. I wish the best for the child and sincerely hope that the parents find their way.


  • Name: Leah
    Date posted: 2008-06-20 10:10 AM
    Hometown: Douglasville

    Comment:

    Everybody who says this is bad is crazy. Should it matter who gives birth to the child as long as the baby is healthy? The Beaties are doing something amazing to bring a special little girl into the world. So the people that don't like it can SHUT UP because nothing can be changed, the baby is coming. So congratulations to the Beaties for bringing a baby girl into this world.


  • Name: david
    Date posted: 2008-06-19 1:09 PM
    Hometown: madison

    Comment:

    this is a little much and kinda strange. will the next story that you cover be "dog gives birth to 60-year-old man?" You should be happy with who you are and the way that you were born.


  • Name: Tina
    Date posted: 2008-06-19 9:06 AM
    Hometown: Aberdeen

    Comment:

    If it were not Gods will, then it wouldn't be happening. Everything in this life is by the will of God! We merely make choices. Congratulations to you both! Don't pay attention to the smug, closed minded hypocrites, they always preach one thing and do another anyway, like make judgments, when the Bible clearly tells them that it is not their place to judge but that it is his. Cant wait to see the pix


  • Name: Rhoda
    Date posted: 2008-06-19 4:01 AM
    Hometown: kampala

    Comment:

    This whole thing is sickening and disgusting.I think the world is coming to an end.Religious bodies should strenghten the spread of christianity and its ethics otherwise science will rule the world and the world will be ruled by confusion.


  • Name: Simone
    Date posted: 2008-06-18 1:01 PM
    Hometown: Stuttgart, Germany

    Comment:

    I'm so happy for him and for his wife. Since I was a teenager I have always been dreaming of a possibility like this - couples are able to share the emotions of a pregnacy in a total different way now. It's not important a all what kind of sex you have, the only thing you should rely on are your feelings. From my point of view, all those self-called Christians, who quote the bible, should remeber that Christianty means sth. else than beeing mean to others. I wished, I'd lived close to Thomas and Nancy - and I promise I'd be the first babysitter they have. In me, they'll always have a friend :-)


  • Name: martha
    Date posted: 2008-06-17 8:26 PM
    Hometown: lancaster

    Comment:

    I do not even want to approach the topic of whether someone should be allowed to have a baby or not and who should decide. My biggest argument is that the media consistently calls him a pregant man. Men can not biologically get pregnant;therefore he is not a man. He is a transgender female who chose to alter his body and live as a man; however, did not remove his ovaries. He lived and was a man for me until he chose to get pregnant. I can tolerate what he has done. I wish him and his new family all the best, but do not ask me to accept it as normal. Different is not normal by definition. You can not have it both ways, or allways, and then be injured if people do not accept it.


  • Name: NIKKI
    Date posted: 2008-06-17 5:00 PM
    Hometown: QUEEN ANNE

    Comment:

    THIS IS NOT A MAN!!


  • Name: Katelyn
    Date posted: 2008-06-17 4:28 PM
    Hometown: Washington, DC

    Comment:

    I don't understand people at all. I see dozens of comments that the Beaties are doing something horribly wrong, but all they're doing is projecting their own will and judgment onto someone else's life. A child who is loved unconditionally and supported emotionally, mentally, financially, and spiritually has the potential to be a brilliant, happy, normal child. Who cares what geno- and phenotypes the parents are? The crucial things for a child aren't things like the sexuality of the parents, they're love, support, and encouragement. A child that is loved will thrive, even if the parents are (or have been) both female. A child who is judged, berated, and beaten down will not, even if the parents are heterosexual Christians. Of course she'll have some difficult questions to answer from those who don't understand, but if her upbringing is based in love and support, she'll be just as well-adjusted as any other kid. Congratulations to Mom and Dad! I'm confident you'll do an outstanding job.


  • Name: Manadalynn
    Date posted: 2008-06-17 2:04 AM
    Hometown: Salem

    Comment:

    Fisrt off i would like to say congratulations. Secondly, everyone whom is saying this is a horrible act should revaluate life. He is bringing a child into this world. And to judge him for doing so is completly wrong. what would you do in this situation? i'm guessing the very same thing. open your minds alittle people, this is beauty at it's best. a twist of fate i think it is wonderful. once again Me and Mrs Beatie congratulations, i hope the best of luck with all three of you.


  • Name: Devon Graas
    Date posted: 2008-06-16 5:47 PM
    Hometown: Morristown NJ

    Comment:

    Thomas and Nancy! Best wishes to you and your family. Congratulations! I can't wait for the birth announcement and pics of the new baby. Remember you have LOTS ans LOTS of love and "family" out here wishing you the best. You are a beautiful couple that deserves all the happiness of a family.


  • Name: ANGELA
    Date posted: 2008-06-16 3:19 PM
    Hometown: HILLBURN

    Comment:

    I think what these 2 people as a couple are doing is wonderful.In reality he was a woman so techniaclly he really isnt doing anything wrong he just stop taking his therpy meds so his womanly hormones came back, and therfore him and his wife can have there own child.Even if he was a TRUE man and we could actullay make the man carry the baby that would ne AWESOME!!!!So I think the wife is lucky here. I would probaly have a ton of kids if that was the case ...well maybe not a ton but like the brady bunch!!Good Luck with everything in life and always remember that EVERYONE has there own battle to go through in life so it sometimes easier to sit and judge some one than to understand WE LIVE IN 2008 SO LETS MAKE THE BEST OF IT!!!


  • Name: Laura
    Date posted: 2008-06-16 6:38 AM
    Hometown: Cambridge

    Comment:

    Good on you Mr. Beatie. Very best wishes for the impending birth and for your new family.


  • Name: Sylvon
    Date posted: 2008-06-16 4:12 AM
    Hometown: Douala, Cameroon

    Comment:

    16Unto the woman he said, I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee. 17And unto Adam he said, Because thou hast hearkened unto the voice of thy wife, and hast eaten of the tree, of which I commanded thee, saying, Thou shalt not eat of it: cursed is the ground for thy sake; in sorrow shalt thou eat of it all the days of thy life; 18Thorns also and thistles shall it bring forth to thee; and thou shalt eat the herb of the field; 19In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return. 20And Adam called his wife's name Eve; because she was the mother of all living.


  • Name: kanishk
    Date posted: 2008-06-16 12:01 AM
    Hometown: New Delhi

    Comment:

    i am amazed by the response people have shown to this whole situation....some are against it..and talk of "it" being against "god's" will....some accept it saying that thomas and nancy probably do not believe in god...I'm pained to see such balderdash.....how can something as beautiful as love be against god's will..how can the creation of life...in this case tomas and nancy's baby...how can she be against god's will....i think its beautiful what has happened...in anycase lets keep god out of this cuz neither i nor any of those who claim they do know god in his/her true self....rest assured he/she blessed you with a baby girl.....I wish tom n nancy all the luck....espl tom...cuz i hear it hurts like a lot... :) cheers


  • Name: j b
    Date posted: 2008-06-15 8:18 PM
    Hometown: PdC

    Comment:

    i wish you both the best of luck. you are a rich person...rich in character, guts and emotional balance. in a few simple words of the next generation...*"YOU ROCK"*. ENJOY BEING A PARENT. JB


  • Name: panku
    Date posted: 2008-06-15 3:03 AM
    Hometown: kathmandu

    Comment:

    Amazing can't imagine, it totally out of track of the nature. but the thinkable point is that how that baby will be delivered ( born). and one more important thing is that how does it became. Meaning without sexual activities how it become.


  • Name: Ryan
    Date posted: 2008-06-14 5:01 PM
    Hometown: New Haven

    Comment:

    Happy Fathers' Day Mr. Beatie, from a parent and a medical student who thinks that what you are doing is courageous and joyful. God bless!


  • Name: MIKE
    Date posted: 2008-06-14 2:05 PM
    Hometown: Nigeria

    Comment:

    The bible said that when the end time is approaching different things will happend, this is one of them is no longer same sex marriage but changing of sex organs. is only God will save us all.


  • Name: EG
    Date posted: 2008-06-14 11:44 AM
    Hometown: NY

    Comment:

    This is the most disgusting proof of the rotting core of science when it is decided that it's alright to defy God. "Sex reassignment" surgery is awful enough - now, women who have decided to become "male" giving birth are the nadir of the awful destruction of human nature and societies. I am against abortion; however, in this case, I sincerely hope this "man" miscarries. This child has absolutely NO chance of living a normal life with these two as parents. I don't care what the "gay" militants and community say to the contrary. The child will suffer emotionally, this is child abuse and both women should be put in jail.


  • Name: Matt
    Date posted: 2008-06-13 7:29 PM
    Hometown: Danbury

    Comment:

    wat


  • Name: joe
    Date posted: 2008-06-12 12:52 PM
    Hometown: phoenix

    Comment:

    you guys are dumb!!! where is this hospital where this guy is at?


  • Name: homer
    Date posted: 2008-06-12 11:33 AM
    Hometown: redcar

    Comment:

    are ya guy ? were does your baby com out of?????????????????????????????????? from ............


  • Name: Marni
    Date posted: 2008-06-11 11:20 PM
    Hometown: Rocanville

    Comment:

    Hello, After reading your article here and watching you and your family tell your story on Oprah, I think you are beautifully articulate and brave. You are good medicine for those that need to learn the lesson of compassion. The love that exudes from you and your wife is undeniable. As this is rare and lucky to find. For those that worry about this situation I ask them to look deep into their own hearts, and look at what is really bothering them. Children need love and stability, protection and trust. And the two of you have much more of this to give than alot of individuals out there. Thank you for being here, in my time line and I wish you well. Congratulations! love and light to you both.


  • Name: ace
    Date posted: 2008-06-11 4:19 AM
    Hometown: fargo

    Comment:

    GOD DOESN'T EXIST!!! IF HE DOES THEN SHOW HIM TO ME OR PROVE TO ME THAT HE EXISTS! how was he "created"? no one knows how everything happened and no one ever will because its in the past and we cant go back in time! scientists say its because of "the big bang" and religious people say its because of "god". where did the big bang come from? where did god come from? if u can prove at least one of those to me then i will become a believer of it. so far im leaning towards the big bang theory cause it makes more sense then someone that we CANNOT SEE OR HEAR APPEARING OUT OF NOWHERE AND CREATED EVERYTHING!!!


  • Name: queene
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 10:28 PM
    Hometown: SALEM Oregon

    Comment:

    when i was younger, my first bf that i had, i told him that men should be the ones carrying the child.. i applaud you in achieving your goals, and your life dreams, and dont let others put you down in what you belive and i can see that you have and will be more of a inspiration to all..


  • Name: cru
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 7:18 PM
    Hometown: Cowley Wyoming

    Comment:

    I am a working married mother of three from a very small very conservative very religous Wyoming community. I think Thomas is a wonderful person. I believe he will be a great parent. I am very sad to hear of the doctors he had to go through to get where he is. I applaud the doctor he finally found. I sincerely hope Thomas has time to read the POSITIVE responses to his pregnancy and the intelligence to disregard the smallminded old world idiots who have Negative things to say. Thank you for bringing your story to the public in such a calm non sensationalistic way!


  • Name: Lisa
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 6:57 PM
    Hometown: West Virginia

    Comment:

    As a medical student and future obstetrician, I am totally in support of Thomas Beatie and his wife Nancy. I want him to know that not everyone in the medical profession is so narrow-minded. I would feel so blessed to be able to take part in his pregnancy! I would love to hear more about his experiences. Thomas, never let ignorant people get to you. You are very brave and you will make a wonderful father. Best wishes to you in the final month of your pregnancy!


  • Name: Kimmy
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 4:59 PM
    Hometown: Imnottelling, USA

    Comment:

    Women complain men don't understand pregnancy and birth-whine that men never will. Now that a man is stepping up for his wife, all these women who were complaining their husband can't give birth are now angry that now a man IS. These people that are spewing hate-saying this is against God...then say everything happens because of God. If He didn't want them to have a child, then the pregnancy would have terminated. True, the first one did, but it was an ectopic pregnancy. Those pregnancies typically end up miscarrying. They're now carrying a healthy baby...if GOD didn't want them to have a child, and thought them an abomination, don't you think He would have done something about it-instead of letting the couple conceive? The only way the child is going to have problems is if some hate mongering idiot spews mindless dribble and stereotypes an innocent child-just because they have an issue with the parents. Come on people, grow up.


  • Name: GOODS CHILD
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 4:28 PM
    Hometown: ATLANTA

    Comment:

    i think its a lil werid that its a pregant''man'' but he is really a woman so why are people so confused?its just like all the rest of the gay communty who dress as males and they are females or allthe males that dress like females. i mean the child wont be confused because the mommy is a lady and the 'dad; is her dad mr.lee dress and looks just like a man we wouldne have known the diffrence if we was to see them two walking down the street. so STOP HATING AND LET THE PEOPLE LIVE THEIR LIVES GOOD LUCK


  • Name: aj
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 2:23 PM
    Hometown: portland, or

    Comment:

    i think it is great that they want to start a family. but i have heard stories surrounding this couple stating that a man is pregnant. this is not a man, it is a woman that chose to change her appearance to look like a man. i think it is a selfish thing to do for the child, and i think it is a publicity stunt, or else no one would know about it. go ahead and try to get attention for this and have this baby as the "husband" in your marriage, but stay out of the public eye for goodness sakes. give your kid that at least. good luck and i truly hope that everything works out wonderfully, for the child.


  • Name: Natasha Stevens
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 9:00 AM
    Hometown: Brooklyn, New York

    Comment:

    You do your thing!! It is the year 2008. Surprise we have a black democratic candidate for president, California just legalized gay marriage, oh and a woman who didn't feel comfortable as a woman became a man and is now bringing a new life into this world. People need to let their inhibitions and judgements go!! Live you own lives and if you can't be happy with yourself leave your hating at the door.!! Let me know if you need a babysitter. Rainbow Pride~!!


  • Name: Pamela
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 3:38 AM
    Hometown: San Diego, CA

    Comment:

    This is going to be one confused kid...if she even survives the hormonal buffeting of such a counter-evolutionary gestation! Even to this civil-libertarian, in this case anti-dysgenics clearly outweighs any distaste at government intervention. SOMEONE qualified in Family Law should step in as the child's legal advocate (ideally via private funding) and sue to take that poor child out of this confused household and place her in a psychologically healthy home (preferably via private adoption). BTW, I can't help but wonder how much dough the Beaties are raking in from the international media publicity IN ADDITION TO the 1100 or so financial benefits they claim to enjoy WHICH ARE NOT AVAILABLE to openly gay couples in the USA! Finally: even transgender support groups denounce the Beaties' radical and developmentally dysfunctional design-for-living as child abuse from the moment of conception. Such actions should be CRIMINALIZED, not mainstreamed!


  • Name: Bernadette
    Date posted: 2008-06-10 1:24 AM
    Hometown: Pleasant Hill

    Comment:

    Pregnant MAN???? There is no such thing.


  • Name: Caitlyn Martin
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 10:17 PM
    Hometown: Bellingham, WA

    Comment:

    I'm sorry, i just have to yell at all of the stupid people who have posted on this article. A person's physical reproductive organs does NOT make them that gender! A person is what gender they feel in their heart to be! Gender is not what's between your legs or on your chest! It is what's in your heart!


  • Name: Caitlyn Martin
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 10:02 PM
    Hometown: Bellingham, WA

    Comment:

    This story is so amazing. It's like a message from the future. It really is a shame that so many people see this man as confused, tratorous to his gender, or even an abomination. He is simply a person, a human being, that happens to be pregnant with his and his wife's child. I salute his efforts and acheivment.


  • Name: Lynne
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 8:15 PM
    Hometown: Brooklyn, NY

    Comment:

    This is disgusting. He went and had surgery to turn himself into a Man, and he should be a Man then all the way. You can't be both; he's some kind of bizarre mix now. He should stay a Man, and they should just adopt, or get a surrogate mother. Does he have sperm to make a baby himself? No. This child is from artificial insemination. No wonder no doctor wanted any part of this. This all goes against God and nature; it's horrendous.


  • Name: Gayle
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 8:14 PM
    Hometown: Detroit, MI

    Comment:

    The fact that people are calling HER a MAN is ridiculous! Just because SHE chopped off HER breasts and changed HER name and got a new id that identifies HER as a man doesn't mean SHE is now a MAN! SHE is still a WOMAN because SHE was born with a VAGINA and SHE still has a VAGINA PEOPLE! Its not a miracle people that SHE is pregnant! SHE has VAGINA thats what WOMEN with VAGINAS and working REPRODUCTIVE SYSTEMS DO, THEY HAVE BABIES!


  • Name: jyi
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 8:13 PM
    Hometown: parsippany

    Comment:

    I wish you a lot of luck. But my concern is more for the unborn child -- not only does she not know her biological father, she will be confused by the parental roles. Will she be able to accept the fact that she was born under such an unusual circumstances? One more point: what defines gender? Biology? Legal or Social? Where and who defines gender?


  • Name: jyi
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 8:12 PM
    Hometown: parsippany

    Comment:

    I wish you a lot of luck. But my concern is more for the unborn child -- not only does she not know her biological father, she will be confused by the parental roles. Will she be able to accept the fact that she was born under such an unusual circumstances? One more point: what defines gender? Biology? Legal or Social? Where and who defines gender?


  • Name: jyi
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 8:11 PM
    Hometown: parsippany

    Comment:

    I wish you a lot of luck. But my concern is more for the unborn child -- not only does she not know her biological father, she will be confused by the parental roles. Will she be able to accept the fact that she was born under such an unusual circumstances? One more point: what defines gender? Biology? Legal or Social? Where and who defines gender?


  • Name: Bo Mosley
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 6:10 PM
    Hometown: Nacogdoches, TX

    Comment:

    I think that before such an amazing undertaking full concern and attention need to be focused on how the child will be effected. I don't think this is ground breaking, its merely a woman superficially modifying her body to legally gather attention and publicity as a pregnant "man". As a man I'm offended she is able to call herself a man, she is not nor will she ever be. I think the "wife" is just along for the publicity and is in great part responsible for the invention of this idea. I think it should be noted that MULTIPLE physicians didn't consent because they felt the parents unfit, not simply because of the unusual mechanics of the pregnancy. I'm a gay man and this deeply concerns me simply for the sake of the child, adoption is such an amazing and wonderful choice, but they were selfish and wanted something more than a child....they wanted a story a headline.


  • Name: Lynn
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 5:09 PM
    Hometown: Florida

    Comment:

    I have no problem with them having a baby. It is their business and no one elses. I am sure they will both be loving parents. It seems though that the wife is alot older than the husband giving birth! But age does not matter either! Good luck with the little one when she arrives!


  • Name: Nancy
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 4:59 PM
    Hometown: Philadelphia

    Comment:

    I am saddened that so many people wish to chastise you and Nancy for your choice. Obviously, upon first hearing this story, an typical reaction would be, "What?!" but anyone who cared to hear your story, the way you told it, would know that you are two people having a baby. I also had a surprised first reaction, but after hearing you speak and reading your comment on Advocate, I really just want to say congratulations, and I will certainly keep you and your family in my thoughts and prayers and hope that others will leave your family at peace.


  • Name: Krystale
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 3:29 PM
    Hometown: Rutland

    Comment:

    I really support you. I can see you as a man having a baby, although honestly I don't see you as male, legal or not. Men and women don't have to be male and female. Female and male are birth body conditions in my view. I hope you find doctors who can support you all the way through, and good support for your child. I suggest never keeping it a secret from the child, though, or it will be learned the hard, damaging way. I just admit a curiosity as to nursing. Those first few days of milk could make a life time immune difference. Will your wife induce? Nursing forms a strong maternal bond in infants. As for those who judge you as they think God would... they should remember... "Judge not lest ye be judged." God's own words. These people should check their own lives to see what it is that makes them lack tollerance and acceptance that their own Lord tries to teach them. Jesus would love you even if his followers didn't.


  • Name: GStew
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 2:08 PM
    Hometown: Reno

    Comment:

    This isn't a story of the first pregnant man, it's a story of a confused woman who wants attention. Stop living a lie, no one buys it but yourself!


  • Name: lexie
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 10:24 AM
    Hometown: cebu

    Comment:

    May God forgive you.pls repent while you will still on earth..I say this because i care and this whole thing is WRONG...pls don't just see your life in earth but also see the eternal life beyond..thank you


  • Name: Jaisey
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 2:34 AM
    Hometown: Salem

    Comment:

    Stop calling her a he! She was naturally born a woman but artificially turned into a MAN!! So naturally she's a WOMAN!!!!! Even if her reproductive organs will ever be removed, she's always going to be a WOMAN! Thomas, you can portray yourself as a man but deep down you know you are a woman and there's nothing you can do to change it, so learn to accept it!! And good luck with your pregnancy, mother-to-be!


  • Name: Sid
    Date posted: 2008-06-09 12:04 AM
    Hometown: Duluth

    Comment:

    Congratulations. Hope that both will be fine. As this "dad" is actually, with reproductive organs and - I assume - most of the hormones flooding his body being female too, I wonder how s/he will handle postpartum depression. Would Nancy his spouse, agree, when things might not work out (hetero marriages end up in divorce in 60% of cases) agree with still prevailing sociatal and court, chiild "protection" dpartment's belief that the parent with 2 mannal glands and a vagina is naturally, automatically and - of course - "in best interest of a child" to be granted a custody (thus a house, child support etc)?


  • Name: bob
    Date posted: 2008-06-08 7:38 PM
    Hometown: bobsville

    Comment:

    congrats but i want to make a point. Thomas is not a woman due to various procedures which have change the physical apperance but the matter of fact is that in dna there is the x and y dna chromosomes in the genetic makeup of a male human and two x chromosomes in a female human. As a result of this fact they are still female and genetically will remain so. if you feel im against this due to religion please think again


  • Name: Angelin
    Date posted: 2008-06-08 7:54 AM
    Hometown: London

    Comment:

    Not abad idea, let the males feel the pain too. Then they will respect the women. Let the women relax too. Good try Mr. But make sure you keep up your duties too.


  • Name: Kit
    Date posted: 2008-06-07 2:36 AM
    Hometown: Orlando, FL

    Comment:

    Congratulations and good luck to Mr. and Mrs. Beatie. Can't wait to see updates when the child is born. :)


  • Name: Jon Dyball
    Date posted: 2008-06-07 12:30 AM
    Hometown: Auckland

    Comment:

    I cannot believe that we still live in such a narrow minded world, that stupid God believing Rednecks sit in judgement over a couple who clearly have alot to offer a new life. Having children is a right of all who breath, not just for self rightgeous do gooders who have nothing better to do then preach on there soap boxes. I say good luck to the Beaties, 10 fingers and 10 toes and a whole lot of love!!!!!


  • Name: The
    Date posted: 2008-06-06 11:08 PM
    Hometown: One

    Comment:

    I think people should mind there own bussiness Gud luck people


  • Name: rd johns
    Date posted: 2008-06-06 9:37 PM
    Hometown: Plainville, Georgia

    Comment:

    I feel sorry for this baby. It did not ask to be brought into this. Its life will be very hard and confusing. I wish the baby well, but the he-she that is having it, in the end your judgement day will come like everyone elses. I don't agree with your life style, but I don't have to stand before god with it. You Do.


  • Name: Nomad
    Date posted: 2008-06-05 9:00 PM
    Hometown: Malaysia

    Comment:

    This person is not a Man. This person is a Woman who went though some biological surgeries which as a result gave her the appearance of a man. She may think or feel like she is a man, she may even believe she is a man, But the truth is that she was born a woman with the proper organs that a woman would have. She chose to reject and deny the body she was given at birth, and use human's own sense to try to change it. She still is a woman after the surgery, it doesn't matter what her brian says or what her ID says.


  • Name: Taylour J.
    Date posted: 2008-06-05 5:56 PM
    Hometown: Howell, Mi

    Comment:

    Congratulations to the Beaties. I think it is a wonderful thing for him to step forward and carry the child. Best of luck.


  • Name: Amy
    Date posted: 2008-06-03 11:15 PM
    Hometown: St Paul

    Comment:

    This does bring up an interesting idea. Should alcohol and cigarette labels now change to a gender-neutral pregnancy warning.


  • Name: Jess Watkins
    Date posted: 2008-06-02 2:53 AM
    Hometown: Sydney

    Comment:

    I know this is late in the argument - being the bubs is due rather soon - but power to the Beatie family! The idea of my husband being able to carry a child spurs overwhelming warm feelings - what a joy! Since hearing of this story I have had day dreams abut being pregnant at the same time - oh if only he had a womb!!!! May all the gods in the universe bless this baby and it's happy and wonderous family!


  • Name: star
    Date posted: 2008-06-01 10:23 AM
    Hometown: bengladesh

    Comment:

    this is unbeleivable and it can't be true she is just a woman converting.what a shame she is beautiful and she looks like miss world she is very beautiful as a woman and very boring and ugly as a man.the almighty god knows what he wants to create the world from man and woman but because of ignorance and illetracy they become more and more boring. what a poor child that in her belly


  • Name: Ignatius c
    Date posted: 2008-05-31 4:11 AM
    Hometown: Lagos nigeria

    Comment:

    this is unbeleivable does it means that Go d does not exist i dont beleive this he is not a man but a woman you people shoul find out exaltly how it happened okey now tell me when he was born was he a male or female i want to know if he is a man does have womb tell me what is fertilising the baby


  • Name: Ignatius c
    Date posted: 2008-05-31 4:06 AM
    Hometown: Lagos nigeria

    Comment:

    this is unbeleivable does it means that Go d does not exist i dont beleive this he is not a man but a woman you people shoul find out exaltly how it happened okey now tell me when he was born was he a male or female i want to know if he is a man does have womb tell me what is fertilising the baby


  • Name: Marisha R. Johnson
    Date posted: 2008-05-28 2:53 PM
    Hometown: York Nebraska

    Comment:

    What one family defines as normal another may not. Who are we to judge what Mr. Beatie and his wife are doing? If they are comfortable with theri circumstances more power to them. I cant say I agree or disagree with what they are doing and that is only because I dont walk in their shoes everyday nor will I ever. I can say that being in an interracial marriage is not "normal" to most in society but to us it is what is normal. I would like to give my supportive words to the Beatie family and tell them congratulations for taking a stand and doing what makes them happy.


  • Name: MaDonna
    Date posted: 2008-05-27 7:58 PM
    Hometown: Colorado Springs

    Comment:

    I am grateful that you guys feel that this is a feasable way to have a child. I totally believe in same sex marriage, and I also believe that there are people that are born the wrong gender. The fact that you are able to live as the man you have always seen yourself as, and carry your child, which your wife is medically unable to do, is awesome. I am just sad that you will not be able to have a regular birth, though a c-section is how many children are born these days. I know that although vaginal birth is painful, it is a joy to see your baby and to be able to be fully awake right after the birth also. I wish you all the best.


  • Name: annie
    Date posted: 2008-05-27 2:19 PM
    Hometown: pearland, tx

    Comment:

    STOP CALLING HIM A MAN... she is a woman with sewed on male parts, like a new nose, new breast or new hair on ones head. THIS IS NOT A MIRACLE, just one woman having a baby, so call it as it is. A WOMAN HAVING A BABY. We should not promote this very confused (her) transgender)(him ) event


  • Name: Jacquie Stewart
    Date posted: 2008-05-26 1:45 AM
    Hometown: Iron City

    Comment:

    I'm not sure if you'll ever see this, but I wish you guys the best of luck and health. Making the choice to have a child must have been hard, and what happened even harder. And I'm sure that you hear a lot of bad things for it. I hope you don't let it get to you ...no, thats impossable, isn't it? I hope you have the strength to overcome the trials, and I hope both of you, and your little girl, have the love support you need. Have a happy and loving life :)


  • Name: Brian
    Date posted: 2008-05-24 2:00 AM
    Hometown: LaGrange, GA

    Comment:

    OK, lets face the facts. "Thomas" is not a dude. Yall remember that saying "dont judge a book by its cover" well the same applies here. Tracy (Thomas) had her breasts cut out and took pills to make her quit producing estrogen, making Her look and sound like a HIM, Since SHE still has HER reproductive organs, In my book, Tracy, is just ONE UGLY CHICK. I dont think this should have all of the publicity that it does. Its just a (strange) woman having a child by A.I. It happens thousands of times a day. On the other hand i do want to send best regards to the mother, and umm mother? or step mother? or whatever? and i hope that they have a healthy, smart, "normal," and very understanding child.


  • Name: BFM
    Date posted: 2008-05-23 1:03 PM
    Hometown: Raleigh

    Comment:

    Since when did a Mastectomy become "gender reassignment surgery"???? PLEASE! This is just a woman, albeit a hairy one. What a scam..SHE can laugh all the way to the bank with it, I am sure.


  • Name: Carmen Garcia
    Date posted: 2008-05-23 8:59 AM
    Hometown: Burlington, NC

    Comment:

    I think the problem most have with Thomas is that he truly 'has it all'. He's the man he's always known himself to be yet he can have the child he's always wanted. For Greedy Americans, it's almost too much to bear. Sort of how we feel about lottery winners...know what I mean? For myself, I'm so happy for the two of you and wish you the best. Every child deserves someone to love and worship them and considering what so many 'normal' (and I use the term sarcastically) parents do to their kids, yours looks to be raised in a happy, healthy environment. You are loved and there are those of us who will always support you!


  • Name: Daniel
    Date posted: 2008-05-23 5:51 AM
    Hometown: Phoenix

    Comment:

    Stop this gay business.Basically u got some probs with your mind set,which leads you to be and live in unnatural life.Anyway,your in a wrong side of the life,get normal,for that just quit wat ever ur doing now.Ms.Beatie,your stil lovely women,pls do not confuse the world.I am on the mission of carrying goodnews of Jesus to all my brothers and sisters(Gay community).Pls change,not sex but to goodness of the life.


  • Name: Lisa Schroeder
    Date posted: 2008-05-22 9:22 AM
    Hometown: Gothenburg

    Comment:

    Every baby is a miracle, some just a little more than most... Congratulations, this is amazing in so many ways!


  • Name: Sara
    Date posted: 2008-05-22 1:03 AM
    Hometown: Perris

    Comment:

    Not that I care either way, I just have a point to make... WHen a woman adopts a child that she did not bear herself, we still allow her the luxury of being called, "Mother". Let the poor guy be the Dad he wants to be and his wife the mother she wants to be. I think that this child will be deeply loved, but will grow up asking tough questions of her parents at some point in her life; don't make it harder on her by confusing her with trivial and deeply unimprtant issues, like who to call Mom and who to call Dad. Let her have as normal a time as she can without imposing social technicalities. Good luck to the proud parents


  • Name: Katie Ridley
    Date posted: 2008-05-20 5:37 PM
    Hometown: Edinburgh, Scotland.

    Comment:

    Greetings from Scotland, Thomas! I felt I should write this in sincere hope that you, yourself read it. There are so many people quick to condemn you (most of them right wing fundamentalist Christians...American ones...'God Bless America'), and I just wanted to say that the people in the world WITH minds of their own, admire your strength and know full well that Jesus Christ himself would wish nothing but love and happiness for you both (all three of you!) You clearly have your head screwed on and are consumed with love for your wife, so we friendly souls from across the water send you a thousand blessings! God is both male AND female! Take care, God bless and good luck. :) xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx


  • Name: JD
    Date posted: 2008-05-19 10:59 PM
    Hometown: Ohio

    Comment:

    Let me start off by stating that I don't care if he/she got a sex change or not, it is his/her decision. But reading one persons comments... The focus on sex organs is pretty childish??? How the hell is it childish..that is what makes you a man or woman is the sex organs that you were born with. Doctors determine the sex of a new born by what sex organs they are born with. Not by the decisions they make in life to live or act one way or another. I do understand that there was a man that participated in an experiment where he still had a penis, but they exchanged the male innards for the urethra, fallopian tube, etc. to female parts and he did get pregnant by injecting sperm through his penis. For a "True" male though, it is scientificaly impossible considering we do not have the uterus that is needed where the child is housed for 9 months as it develops. And we do not have ovaries. So that is why so much focus is being put on the sexual organs.


  • Name: Daphne
    Date posted: 2008-05-17 11:23 AM
    Hometown: Brussels

    Comment:

    The world is changing, and some aren't able to follow up with that. How can you deny a happy, stable couple the right to have children of their own? These two people made a decision to create their own family, and nobody should think they have the right to disapprove of that!


  • Name: Jennifer
    Date posted: 2008-05-17 1:58 AM
    Hometown: Morrilton

    Comment:

    To all of you people who say "this is against God" are in a way, hypocritical. The people who say these things say God controls everything and creats everything, as well as, rules everything. In that case, he controls everything people do, including scientist. therefore Science is controlled by God. So how can you sit here and say it is against God. That is just plain stupid and hypocritical and supposely that is against God too...So you people out there that say all these stupid religious things against people trying to be happy in life, need to check yourselfs before you say anything else so stupid and contridictory. As for all you men who are having babies, YOU ROCK!!! I think it is great that not only men can share in this namazing experience. Oh, and for you women who are upset because you say "this is something that only I should be able to experience", Quit B****ing that men don't understand what we go through and they should take some of the burden, cause they are....


  • Name: mataka
    Date posted: 2008-05-16 11:39 PM
    Hometown: wdc

    Comment:

    Some 'people' have a God complex. They're always trying to transform what's natural to reflect their un-natural selves. I really wish you had your own planet, far, far, far, away. Till then, expect a response from the one who created us all.


  • Name: Ava
    Date posted: 2008-05-16 12:13 PM
    Hometown: Philippines

    Comment:

    How about breastfeeding? uhH! I was amazed reading this... i am amazed of you!


  • Name: denise
    Date posted: 2008-05-15 1:01 AM
    Hometown: NY

    Comment:

    Why can't people respect a person's chosen pronoun? It is so rude to refer to Mr Beatie as "she". Good luck to him and his family. Him and his wife are not the problem for their child. A society that can't accept a loving family is the problem.


  • Name: J.M. Keeton
    Date posted: 2008-05-14 11:42 PM
    Hometown: Salem, Indiana

    Comment:

    These days, any child who is brought into this world with two loving parents is truly blessed. I know a lot of young kids in far worse situations than having an unconventional family. In light of the parent's commitment, I'd say the child has got a great start, and I can only pray that society will not prevent this child's happiness. Lots of love and best wishes to the new family!!


  • Name: dyna
    Date posted: 2008-05-14 9:07 AM
    Hometown: philippines

    Comment:

    hello.. as for me i will pray for you guys... i know you will be a good parents despite of all issues to tackle just because not male-female thing! You've taken the first step almost half there soon be a family. Can i nanny the baby...???


  • Name: Barb
    Date posted: 2008-05-13 7:51 PM
    Hometown: Texas

    Comment:

    im doing a research paper on this issue and i have decided to remain neutral. For your beautiful baby mr.beatie i hope he/she all the health and love of the world. If there could be anyway to interview you for my school paper that would be greatly appreciated. Best wishes and stay strong.


  • Name: Danielle
    Date posted: 2008-05-13 7:43 PM
    Hometown: New Hampshire

    Comment:

    Some of us don't believe in god. You need to accept the fact that not everyone keeps god in mind when they live their lives. They decided they wanted to have a child, and they are. Everyone should have a right to do so, and they took a stance to fulfill their dreams. Stop with your religious mumbojumbo and accept that there are a lot of people who simply think god does not exist.


  • Name: Stephen
    Date posted: 2008-05-13 6:44 PM
    Hometown: New Jersey

    Comment:

    i think this is ridiculous. i understand that you are dissappointed that your wife could not have a child, but that was god's will. god had probably said, "no this couple will not have a child." it is completely sinful to go against god's will. i lost a beloved 1 1/2 year old cat because of an embolism. i tried to change that, thinking that there was some way. i loved her a lot. but then i realized that i cannot change god's will, and neither should you. you are screwing up society and nature, and i hope you go to hell for that.


  • Name: sam
    Date posted: 2008-05-12 7:28 PM
    Hometown: harleton

    Comment:

    i have no problem and i think its great that you want to carry your child. but if you have a uterus, ur a woman


  • Name: Eileen
    Date posted: 2008-05-11 11:22 PM
    Hometown: Mexico City

    Comment:

    I must admit that I had a hard time deciding whether this was wrong or right... and not to me, but to nature, the world, the meaning of being a mother... I choose to let things be the way they are and be happy for the two mothers. Things just ARE, who are we to judge what god has enabled us to achieve? Let it be. Contratulations and good wishes from México.


  • Name: Kathleen
    Date posted: 2008-05-11 10:33 PM
    Hometown: Oak Lawn, IL

    Comment:

    I am so happy for you both. You're up against a lot here, but you will be in my prayers, especially come July. I am touched by your story and know how difficult fertility problems can be for "conventional" couples. Love your wife, love your daughter, be happy despite everyone else's issues. Good Luck!


  • Name: meriam
    Date posted: 2008-05-11 8:00 AM
    Hometown: Morocco

    Comment:

    1st of all u are not a male. U make yourself injected to amke yourself feel so. Once u will have the baby You will have the tears of a mother. I think the baby will need so much help really. Please think that world is strictly supervised by God no need to change nature. meriam with love


  • Name: Rimi
    Date posted: 2008-05-11 4:55 AM
    Hometown: Silbit

    Comment:

    Thomas, can u answer me what is the definition of mother? And what is of father? We know who give birth is called mother. It is not decided by sex whatsoever. So it means mother of your child is only you. It is very difficult process to give a birth of child. A mother suffer lot to give a birth of a child even she endanger her life with the threat of dead. That is why a mother is so worthy to us. She is everything for us. We can lay down our life for her. We always know that we are a part of her but what will happen to your baby. Can she will be able to feel the same way as we do about our father and mother. You are just going to destroy the life of your baby. You people going under SRS just for sexual healing but is life all about sex?


  • Name: Brett Bews
    Date posted: 2008-05-11 1:01 AM
    Hometown: Kindersley, Saskatchewan

    Comment:

    If you do some research about gender reassignment surgeries, you'll probably realize that female-to-male reconstructions are more difficult and have less desirable results than that of male-to-females, not to mention that any major-but-unnecessary surgery is costly. So I don't blame Mr. Beatie for not getting the surgery, and that certainly doesn't make him any less male. I mean, if I woke up with a vagina one day, I'd still perceive myself as male. This focus on sex organs is pretty childish, in my opinion. Open your mind. When I encounter something I don't understand, I see it as a learning opportunity, not an excuse to spout hate and insults (I'm still trying to figure out how someone could conclude that this person is "mentally unstable" from the information presented).


  • Name: Amber Falscroft
    Date posted: 2008-05-10 12:03 PM
    Hometown: Vassar,Michigan

    Comment:

    first off Mr.Beatie is not a "she" by no means of the imagination. yes he may have been a female at birth but then he had his sex changed it does not matter if he kept his female organs or not. i think it is a wonderful thing he and his WIFE are doing. and anyone that wants to judge them for bringing a beauitful little girl into this crazy world needs to shut their mouth and look at all the messed up things in their own life before they start trying to tear down this couple all because they want to have a family. i say all the power to Mr. and Mrs.Beatie. people just need to leave them alone and let them raise their child how they want to. it is not parents like Mr. and Mrs.Beatie that make bad childern it is the idiots out in the world that judge the child that make them bad. shut up and live your own life and leave them be. to Mr. and Mrs.Beatie i hope that you have a healthy beautiful little girl and i wish all the happines in the world to you and your family.


  • Name: BraveNewWorld
    Date posted: 2008-05-09 8:17 PM
    Hometown: London

    Comment:

    I think it's fantastic that two people who have shown so much love and commitment to each other have found the strength to create a family. They have been met with bias and rejection and have stood by their decision to create a family. I wish them all the best and would love to know how their girl develops in life. I can only hope that the insecurity and hate of all those opposed will not be directed at her.


  • Name: TaKayla
    Date posted: 2008-05-08 7:55 PM
    Hometown: M Town

    Comment:

    Well now it oughta be easy cuz in stead of having a lazy nasty mean good for nothing father your baby will have 2 mothers and i think every one else should mind there bussness congrades


  • Name: Linda Moore
    Date posted: 2008-05-08 10:32 AM
    Hometown: Panama City, FL

    Comment:

    But in all aspect, He is not really a he. He still has FEMALE reproductive organs. He doesnt have male organs. He didnt get the surgery done whatever. So I dont see how legally...he can be called a he. This pregnancy is all a publicity stunt. If they had really just been wanting children, it would have never blew up in th news the way it has. They would have went about their business and that would have been it. Good luck to the child...it will need all the help it can get.


  • Name: Angelica
    Date posted: 2008-05-07 11:52 PM
    Hometown: Irving

    Comment: