Scroll To Top
News

Pete Buttigieg warns progressives to focus on reinvention and not restoration

Pete Buttigieg
footage still via youtube @petebuttigieg

Pete Buttigieg

“Our job is not to go around picking up the shards of what there was and trying to tape them back together,” the former transportation secretary said.

Cwnewser
We need your help
Your support makes The Advocate's original LGBTQ+ reporting possible. Become a member today to help us continue this work.

Pete Buttigieg traveled overseas Friday with a warning for progressives: If they do not reclaim the language of patriotism, they risk ceding it to those who wield nationalism as a weapon of exclusion.

Related: Pete Buttigieg enters the manosphere in marathon ‘Flagrant’ podcast appearance

The gay former presidential candidate and U.S. transportation secretary delivered that message at the Global Progress Action Summit in London, where he joined leaders from across the democratic left for what amounted to a strategy session in an era of populist resurgence.

“It wasn’t that long ago that progressive patriotism was considered in our country a contradiction in terms,” Buttigieg said. “Patriotism can either be a cudgel that is used to exclude and beat people down, or it can be a way to summon more and more people into a shared national project.”

Buttigieg, who served in Afghanistan as a Navy intelligence officer, recalled how survival in a combat zone depended not on political identity, religion, or sexual orientation but on the flag on a soldier’s shoulder. “We learned very quickly to trust each other with our lives even if we had really nothing in common besides the flag,” he said.

Related: Pete Buttigieg rips Trump’s Veterans Affairs cuts & defends trans troops in Iowa town hall

The New York Times reports that the London summit gathered Prime Minister Keir Starmer of Britain, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, and former New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern. The event underscored progressive vulnerabilities. Starmer, trailing Nigel Farage’s Reform U.K. by nearly 10 points, warned against “a politics of predatory grievance” and called for “patriotic renewal.”

For Democrats in attendance, including Buttigieg and Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker, the gathering doubled as a workshop for a post-Trump future. With the U.S. political landscape dominated by the president, the question of how to offer a persuasive alternative loomed large.

Buttigieg argued that progressives must pivot from defining themselves primarily in opposition to Trump and instead emphasize what they can build. “Out with the old, we’re going to do something about these abuses isn’t enough,” he said. “The more we are talking about him, the less we are talking about you.”

Related: Tucker Carlson accuses Pete Buttigieg of being ’not gay at all’

That means delivering on basics, from infrastructure to health care, and making those achievements visible. As South Bend’s mayor, Buttigieg noted, residents rarely praised clean water or safe roads. The political task, he said, is to highlight the struggles behind those victories and the values they represent.

Just as vital, he argued, is cultivating a sense of belonging. South Bend’s revival succeeded not only through development projects but through a new civic identity strong enough that residents tattooed the redesigned city flag on their arms, he said. Nationally, he suggested, Democrats must offer a similar sense of pride and purpose. “Our job is not to go around picking up the shards of what there was and trying to tape them back together,” he said.

Related: Pete Buttigieg responds to Tucker Carlson’s ‘very specific questions about gay sex’ on Kara Swisher’s podcast

Buttigieg emphasized the importance of preparation for what’s ahead. “I did not come here to tell everybody that things are better than they look. They’re not,” he said. "They’re probably going to get worse before they get better. And yet I’m optimistic, not because things are better than they look, but because things have reached the point where we will have to fashion something entirely new. We will have to do it on the day, and it will come when Donald Trump is no longer politically active in the United States, which will happen."

Cwnewser
The Advocate TV show now on Scripps News network

From our Sponsors

Most Popular

Latest Stories

Christopher Wiggins

Christopher Wiggins is The Advocate’s senior national reporter in Washington, D.C., covering the intersection of public policy and politics with LGBTQ+ lives, including The White House, U.S. Congress, Supreme Court, and federal agencies. He has written multiple cover story profiles for The Advocate’s print magazine, profiling figures like Delaware Congresswoman Sarah McBride, longtime LGBTQ+ ally Vice President Kamala Harris, and ABC Good Morning America Weekend anchor Gio Benitez. Wiggins is committed to amplifying untold stories, especially as the second Trump administration’s policies impact LGBTQ+ (and particularly transgender) rights, and can be reached at christopher.wiggins@equalpride.com or on BlueSky at cwnewser.bsky.social; whistleblowers can securely contact him on Signal at cwdc.98.
Christopher Wiggins is The Advocate’s senior national reporter in Washington, D.C., covering the intersection of public policy and politics with LGBTQ+ lives, including The White House, U.S. Congress, Supreme Court, and federal agencies. He has written multiple cover story profiles for The Advocate’s print magazine, profiling figures like Delaware Congresswoman Sarah McBride, longtime LGBTQ+ ally Vice President Kamala Harris, and ABC Good Morning America Weekend anchor Gio Benitez. Wiggins is committed to amplifying untold stories, especially as the second Trump administration’s policies impact LGBTQ+ (and particularly transgender) rights, and can be reached at christopher.wiggins@equalpride.com or on BlueSky at cwnewser.bsky.social; whistleblowers can securely contact him on Signal at cwdc.98.