Scroll To Top

The FBI Is Anonymously Calling LGBT Witnesses 'Not Credible'

The FBI Is Anonymously Calling LGBT Witnesses 'Not Credible'

Omar Mateen

A number of gay men are on the record, but the FBI is anonymously calling them "not credible."


The FBI still has provided no explanation for what led Omar Mateen to kill 49 people and wound 53 others in an attack on a gay nightclub on Latin Night. But someone at the FBI is anonymously telling multiple media outlets that Omar Mateen didn't have a secret gay life.

The witnesses who've come forward aren't buying it, and some are striking back at the FBI for its failures leading up to the shooting. The FBI had interviewed Mateen a number of times before the shooting and removed him from a terrorist watchlist.

Kevin West had first told the Los Angeles Times he talked with Mateen on the gay dating app, Jack'd, for a year.

"It's almost certain that he covered his tracks," West told the Orlando Sentinel in response to the FBI's anonymous quotes. "Lots of people are still secretive about it. They say they don't show their face online because, 'I'm not out to my family, or because of my career.'"

In other words, the FBI is naive if it really expected to find gay dating apps on Mateen's phone, or anything in his Internet browsing history, or any saved photos from others, or gay porn on his phone -- all things someone anonymously cited when telling the Los Angeles Times the FBI hadn't turned up reason to believe Mateen led a secret life. People in the closet would be careful not to have left such an obvious trail. But, it's not actually clear why the FBI claims it hasn't found any evidence, because it hasn't revealed what it checked on the record.

When asked on the record, both attorney general Loretta Lynch and Ron Hopper, the assistant special agent from the FBI who is in charge of the FBI joint terrorism task force, have said allegations are still being vetted and no determination has been made.

Speculation about Mateen's sexuality started when a number of witnesses told the Orlando Sentinel they'd seen the shooter at the club long before June 12. Others said the same thing to CNN, placing him there years earlier. And performer Lisa Lane, a transgender woman who is regular at Latin Night at the Pulse, toldThe Advocate she recognized Mateen as one of her fans.

The Los Angeles Times reports that "The FBI is continuing to explore Mateen's past, but investigators now believe the men who made the claims are not credible, or confused Mateen with someone else."

If the FBI is right, it wouldn't be the first time an LGBT person had made up claims related to a hate crime. While LGBT people are the most likely minority group to be targeted in a hate crime, a disturbing number of people have been caught inventing stories about being physically attacked, or having homophobic slurs used against them, or scrawled on dinner receipts or written on cakes.

Cord Cedeno was one of the first to come forward. He went on MSNBC and told Chris Hayes that he'd gotten messages from Mateen while on Grindr. "I can go take a lie detector test," Cedeno told the Los Angeles Times. "I know for a fact Omar messaged me." He also threw in a jab at the FBI, saying, "They let him go. They let him do this massacre. They could have arrested him."

Jim Van Horn is one of the men who said he'd seen Mateen at the club. He told the Associated Press the FBI has never talked to him, and he dismissed the FBI's trouble finding witnesses. "Nobody's going to say they slept with a terrorist and be on national TV," Van Horn told the Associated Press.

In fact, one man did tell Univision -- while wearing a disguise and calling himself "Miguel" -- that he'd slept with Mateen at a hotel and that there ought to be surveillance camera video of their comings and goings. Then gossip site TMZ reported Mateen is shown on video tape at the Ambassador Hotel, based on anonymous sources it claims to have at the hotel.

Three men in Fort Pierce, Mateen's home town, toldThe Advocate they'd seen him on Grindr. Another man, a former classmate who was not identified, had told the Palm Beach Post that Mateen asked him out while they were both at the Indian River Community College police academy. The FBI hasn't revealed on the record whether it interviewed any of them.

Advocate Channel - The Pride StoreAdvocate Magazine - Gio Benitez

From our Sponsors

Most Popular

Latest Stories

Lucas Grindley

Lucas Grindley is VP and Editorial Director for Here Media, which is parent company to The Advocate. His Twitter account is filled with politics, Philip Glass appreciation, and adorable photos of his twin toddler daughters.
Lucas Grindley is VP and Editorial Director for Here Media, which is parent company to The Advocate. His Twitter account is filled with politics, Philip Glass appreciation, and adorable photos of his twin toddler daughters.